Express & Star

Backlog of crime cases in magistrates’ courts highest on record

The number of trials in magistrates’ courts fell by 94% to ‘historical lows’ at the end of June.

Last updated
Court stock

The backlog of criminal cases waiting to be dealt with by magistrates’ courts hit the highest level on record at the height of the coronavirus pandemic, official figures show.

There were 421,539 outstanding cases in the three months to the end of June, an increase of 44% compared with the same period a year earlier (292,871), according to official Ministry of Justice (MoJ) statistics for English and Welsh courts.

This is the highest number since records began in 2012 (318,917) and well beyond the previous quarterly peak of 328,291 in the first three months of 2015.

The lowest backlog in the last seven years was 281,644, in the third quarter of September 2013.

The number of trials in magistrates’ courts fell by 94% to “historical lows” at the end of June following their suspension as part of measures to stop the spread of coronavirus.

There were just 1,715 – the lowest figure in a decade – compared with 23,455 in the first three months of this year.

Provisional department figures for the summer suggest the backlog has since peaked at 525,059 towards the end of July – another record high – but then began to fall slightly by the end of August to 517,782.

The crown court backlog rose by 25% from 34,278 in the three months to June 2019 to 42,707 for the same period this year.

This is the highest level since the end of 2016 (42,981), but still below a peak of 55,455 at the end of 2014.

Between April and June this year there were just 124 crown court trials, compared with 4,911 in the first quarter. This is also the lowest number since records began in 2014.

The guilty plea rate for defendants being dealt with in crown court trials increased “markedly” to 80%, compared with 68% for the same period in 2019.

Some lawyers have claimed defendants were considering pleading guilty for crimes they did not commit when faced with waiting several years for a trial.

The MoJ report said: “Given the sharp falls in the volume of defendants dealt with and the suspension of jury trials, it is difficult to draw conclusions from this.

“It is likely that the guilty plea rate increase is caused by the restricted ability of courts to progress jury trials (e.g. not guilty cases) as part of the Covid-19 response.”

The figures, which show there is still a backlog of nearly half a million criminal cases, come after justice minister Chris Philip claimed the court system was being run “more effectively” during the pandemic than it was before.

His comments were criticised by industry leaders as it emerged cases were being listed for 2023, following warnings last week from the director of public prosecutions, Max Hill, who said delays in cases coming to court are “corrosive” as they force victims to wait for justice.

The impact of the pandemic “remains clear to see”, the MoJ report said, adding: “Workload and trial efficiency estimates at both the magistrates’ courts and the crown court show that receipts and disposals have fallen, while both outstanding cases and trial vacations increased sharply.

“It is expected that outstanding case and trial vacation volumes will maintain these higher levels while the limited operation of the criminal courts remains in place and the gradual reintroduction of jury trials at the crown court continues.”

The number of cases courts are dealing with is growing and some are sitting extended hours, the MoJ said.

A spokesman added that the department was seeing “positive early signs stemming from our work to keep the justice system moving during the pandemic”.

Although lawyers warned they were seeing cases already being listed for 2023, the MoJ denied this was taking place.

Nightingale courts which are already open are operating at 80% capacity – higher than the average court before the pandemic, it added.

By next week, 17 will be open with 32 courtrooms. Four will be hearing criminal cases with others dealing with family and civil matters.

A further five are planned.

Sorry, we are not accepting comments on this article.