Bartley, Lyttle and Gallagher: West Brom and Swansea ‘played for both’ XI

We take a look at some of the best players to have played for West Brom and Swansea

Ahead of West Brom's Championship trip to Swansea City on Saturday, the Express & Star has picked a starting 11 of players who have represented both clubs over the years.

From Albion promotion winners and Premier League favourites to players who made their names in South Wales, here is our 'Played For Both XI' for West Brom and Swansea.

Goalkeeper: Neil Cutler

West Brom: 1991–1996 (0 appearances), Swansea: 2002 (13 appearances)

Starting between the sticks is Neil Cutler, who began his professional career at Albion after progressing through the club's youth system.

The goalkeeper spent several years on the books at The Hawthorns but was unable to establish himself in the first team, gaining experience through loan spells elsewhere before eventually leaving the Baggies.

Cutler went on to enjoy a lengthy career in the Football League, representing clubs including Chester City, Aston Villa and Stoke City.

His connection with Swansea came during a loan spell in 2002, when he made 13 appearances for the Swans. Cutler later moved into coaching and returned to Albion as goalkeeping coach, working with the club's senior goalkeepers.

Neil cutler has become an established goalkeeping coach placeholder image
Neil cutler has become an established goalkeeping coach | AMA

Defender: Kyle Bartley

West Brom: 2018–2025 (232 appearances), Swansea: 2012–2018 (21 appearances)

A commanding centre-back who spent seven years at The Hawthorns, Kyle Bartley joined Albion from Swansea in July 2018 and became an important figure in the club's defence.

The former Arsenal youngster initially struggled for consistency but established himself as a regular under Slaven Bilic, helping the Baggies secure promotion to the Premier League in 2019/20. Bartley remained a key member of the squad following their return to the Championship and later became club captain.

He had previously spent six years at Swansea after joining from Arsenal in 2012, although first-team opportunities were limited. Bartley also enjoyed loan spells at Birmingham City and Leeds United, where he played regularly during the 2016/17 campaign.

The defender announced his retirement in August 2025 after making 232 appearances for Albion, scoring 15 goals.

Kyle Bartley captained Albion during his time at the clubplaceholder image
Kyle Bartley captained Albion during his time at the club | (AMA)

Defender: Ashley Williams

West Brom: Youth career (0 senior appearances), Swansea: 2008–2016 (325 appearances)

Former Wales captain Ashley Williams began his footballing journey in Albion's academy before going on to become one of Swansea City's greatest modern-day players.

The Wolverhampton-born defender was released by the Baggies as a teenager and rebuilt his career in non-league football with Hednesford Town before joining Stockport County.

Williams eventually earned a move to Swansea in 2008 and became a central figure in the club's remarkable rise through the divisions. He helped the Swans secure promotion to the Premier League in 2011 and captained them to League Cup glory in 2013, when they defeated Bradford City 5-0 at Wembley.

He made more than 300 Premier League appearances for Swansea before joining Everton in 2016 and later represented Stoke City and Bristol City. Williams also captained Wales during their historic run to the semi-finals of Euro 2016.

The Wolverhampton-born defender was released by the Baggies as a teenagerplaceholder image
The Wolverhampton-born defender was released by the Baggies as a teenager | Local Library

Defender: Des Lyttle

West Brom: 2000–2003 (76 appearances), Swansea: 1992–1993 (46 appearances)

A versatile full-back who played an important role during Gary Megson's early years at The Hawthorns, Des Lyttle joined Albion from Watford in March 2000.

The Wolverhampton-born defender initially arrived on loan before completing a permanent move that summer, becoming a useful member of Megson's squad as Albion began their transformation from relegation candidates into promotion contenders.

Lyttle helped the Baggies reach the First Division play-offs in 2000/01 and was part of the squad that secured promotion to the Premier League the following season, although his opportunities became increasingly limited.

Earlier in his career, he had spent time on loan at Swansea from Nottingham Forest, making 46 appearances for the Welsh club. He also represented West Brom's rivals Wolves during a short loan spell in 1998.

Des Lyttle helped the Baggies reach the First Division play-offs in 2000/01placeholder image
Des Lyttle helped the Baggies reach the First Division play-offs in 2000/01 | Getty Images

Defender: David Smith

West Brom: 1994–1998 (102 appearances), Swansea: 2002–2003 (4 appearances)

Winger David Smith spent four years at The Hawthorns during the 1990s after joining Albion from Norwich City.

The former Manchester United youngster became a familiar figure in the Baggies' side, making 102 appearances and scoring twice as the club attempted to establish itself in the First Division.

Smith's versatility allowed him to operate in several positions across midfield, although he struggled to hold down a regular place towards the end of his spell.

He later represented several Football League clubs before joining Swansea towards the end of his career in 2002. His spell in South Wales was brief, with Smith making just four appearances and scoring once.

Midfielder: Kwame Ampadu

West Brom: 1991–1994 (21 appearances), Swansea: 1994–1998 (147 appearances)

A former Arsenal youngster, Kwame Ampadu joined Albion in 1991 and was part of the squad that secured promotion from the Second Division under Ossie Ardiles in 1992/93.

The midfielder struggled to establish himself as a regular at The Hawthorns, making 21 appearances before leaving for Swansea in February 1994.

Ampadu enjoyed considerably more first-team football in South Wales, scoring 12 goals in 147 appearances. He was part of the Swansea side that won the Football League Trophy in 1994 and later featured in their Third Division play-off final defeat to Northampton Town in 1997.

He subsequently moved to Leyton Orient and continued his career in the lower leagues before moving into coaching. His son, Ethan Ampadu, went on to become a Wales international.

Midfielder: Conor Gallagher

West Brom: 2020–2021 (30 appearances), Swansea: 2020 (21 appearances)

England international Conor Gallagher enjoyed loan spells at both clubs during the early stages of his career after progressing through Chelsea's academy.

The energetic midfielder joined Swansea in January 2020, having spent the first half of the campaign at Charlton Athletic. Gallagher impressed during his time in South Wales, contributing six assists as Steve Cooper's side reached the Championship play-offs.

His performances earned him a Premier League loan move to Albion in September 2020, where he quickly established himself as a regular under Slaven Bilic.

Gallagher scored his first Premier League goal in a 1-0 victory over Sheffield United and later found the net against Crystal Palace, although his efforts could not prevent Albion from suffering relegation.

He returned to Chelsea before enjoying another successful loan spell at Crystal Palace, eventually becoming a senior England international and earning a move to Atletico Madrid.

Conor Gallagher scored his first Premier League goal in a 1-0 victory over Sheffield United placeholder image
Conor Gallagher scored his first Premier League goal in a 1-0 victory over Sheffield United | Local Library

Midfielder: Scott Sinclair

West Brom: 2013–2014 (8 appearances), Swansea: 2010–2012 (82 appearances)

A winger who enjoyed contrasting fortunes at the two clubs, Scott Sinclair joined Albion on loan from Manchester City in August 2013.

The former Chelsea youngster arrived with a strong reputation after helping Swansea secure promotion to the Premier League, but struggled to establish himself under Steve Clarke and Pepe Mel.

Sinclair made just eight Premier League appearances during his time at The Hawthorns, with injuries and competition for places restricting his opportunities before he returned to Manchester City.

His spell at Swansea had been considerably more successful. Sinclair joined the Swans from Chelsea in 2010 and scored a hat-trick in their 4-2 Championship play-off final victory over Reading at Wembley in 2011, helping the Welsh club reach the Premier League for the first time.

He continued to impress in the top flight before earning a move to Manchester City in 2012, and later enjoyed a successful spell at Celtic.

Scott Sinclair joined the Swans from Chelsea in 2010 and scored a hat-trick in their 4-2 Championship play-off final victory over Reading at Wembley in 2011placeholder image
Scott Sinclair joined the Swans from Chelsea in 2010 and scored a hat-trick in their 4-2 Championship play-off final victory over Reading at Wembley in 2011 | Getty Images

Midfielder: Jefferson Montero

West Brom: 2019 (4 appearances), Swansea: 2014–2020 (85 appearances)

Ecuador international Jefferson Montero joined Albion on loan from Swansea in January 2019 as Darren Moore looked to strengthen his attacking options for the Championship promotion race.

The winger arrived alongside Jacob Murphy and Stefan Johansen on deadline day, bringing Premier League experience and plenty of pace to the Baggies' squad.

However, Montero struggled to establish himself at The Hawthorns and made only a handful of appearances before returning to Swansea at the end of the campaign.

He had previously joined the Swans from Mexican side Morelia in 2014 and spent several seasons in the Premier League, earning a reputation as a dangerous winger capable of troubling defenders with his speed and dribbling ability.

Montero later spent time on loan at Birmingham City before continuing his career abroad.

Ecuador international Jefferson Montero joined Albion on loan from Swansea in January 2019placeholder image
Ecuador international Jefferson Montero joined Albion on loan from Swansea in January 2019 | Getty Images

Forward: Luke Moore

West Brom: 2008–2011 (57 appearances), Swansea: 2011–2013 (52 appearances)

A product of Aston Villa's academy, Luke Moore joined Albion in January 2008 as Tony Mowbray looked to strengthen his attacking options during the club's push for promotion.

The striker initially arrived on loan before completing a permanent move, helping the Baggies secure the Championship title and return to the Premier League at the end of the 2007/08 season.

Moore struggled to establish himself as a consistent goal scorer in the top flight but remained part of Albion's squad following relegation, helping the club secure another promotion under Roberto Di Matteo in 2009/10.

He subsequently joined Swansea, initially on loan, and played a role in their successful push for Premier League football in 2011.

Moore spent two seasons with the Swans in the top flight and was part of the squad that lifted the League Cup in 2013, before continuing his career in Turkey and the United States.

Luke Moore in action against Albionplaceholder image
Luke Moore in action against Albion | Getty Images

Forward: Carl Heggs

West Brom: 1991–1995 (40 appearances), Swansea: 1995–1997 (45 appearances)

Completing the starting 11 is Carl Heggs, who began his Football League career at Albion after joining from Leicester United in August 1991.

The striker spent four years at The Hawthorns but struggled to establish himself as a regular, scoring three goals in 40 league appearances.

Heggs was part of the Albion squad during the club's promotion-winning 1992/93 campaign under Ossie Ardiles, although his opportunities were limited as the Baggies returned to the second tier.

After a brief loan spell at Bristol Rovers, he joined Swansea in July 1995 and spent two seasons at the Vetch Field, scoring eight league goals.

Heggs later represented Northampton Town, Rushden & Diamonds and Carlisle United before moving into non-league football and management.

Related topics:

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice