I visited a West Midlands village once dubbed Britain's 'toughest' - and found a warm welcome in a rural idyll

Television once labelled Highley as one of Britain’s toughest villages - but a visit to this riverside gem reveals reality is far more charming than fiction.

Nestled on the west bank of the River Severn, halfway between Bewdley and Bridgnorth, the former pit village is probably best known today as a pit stop for the Severn Valley Railway.

It boasts a range of shops and amenities, including a riverside pub, a butcher's, a cafe and an outdoor swimming pool.

But it's the beauty of the surrounding countryside that sets Highley apart: the quiet village feels miles away from anywhere, situated snugly among acres and acres of rolling hills and woodlands.

Highley: Photo: Steve Leathplaceholder image
Highley: Photo: Steve Leath

And a warm welcome was received when I visited on a cold and rainy December afternoon, met by friendly locals who spoke fondly of countryside walks, shooting, and days spent fishing in the river. 

How surprised I was to be told then that this rural idyll had featured on a Sky One programme called 'Toughest Villages In Britain' around two decades ago.

In the grainy footage available online, residents and visitors wearing early 2000s popped polo-neck collars are filmed revelling in the annual village carnival.

Photo: Steve Leathplaceholder image
Photo: Steve Leath

The show does little to paint the village in a good light, narrated by drunken anecdotes of punch-ups, petty theft and what, for the sake of everyone's dignity, I'll choose to call courtship.

But, if you remove the slurred and morally questionable commentary given by the inebriated young men made centrepiece of the "documentary", the day looks like any other carnival in any other village circa 2003.

Had the camera lingered for long elsewhere, I have no doubt that the day could have been painted as a jolly good time - but no one was making those programmes in the television era that brought us Fat Families and The Real Mrs Robinson.

An article from the Sunday Mercury about the coverage later mentioned that television watchdog Ofcom was "considering whether the community was treated unfairly".

Butcher Ashley Barry with daughter Maci Barry. Photo: Steve Leathplaceholder image
Butcher Ashley Barry with daughter Maci Barry. Photo: Steve Leath

I can find no record of the outcome of that investigation, but it's clear the community still feel they were done wrong by the filmmakers. 

"They came into the village on carnival day and everyone was getting beered up," said town butcher Ashley Barry. 

"It was a set-up - you could go into any town and film the worst bits and make it look like the roughest village. [Highley] has a nice community, the people are nice and friendly." 

Dale and Moira Gould with Vicar David Poyner. Photo: Steve Leathplaceholder image
Dale and Moira Gould with Vicar David Poyner. Photo: Steve Leath

Vicar David Poyner agreed: "The people are very friendly, it's a very supportive community. That's something I've noticed: people will support each other out here."

Owner of the Sip & Soul Cafe, Trinnet Dunkley, opened the cafe doors around five months ago in a move warmly welcomed by the people of Highley.

Sip & Soul Cafe owner Trinnet Dunkley, from Willenhall. Photo: Steve Leathplaceholder image
Sip & Soul Cafe owner Trinnet Dunkley, from Willenhall. Photo: Steve Leath

Trinnet travels to the village every day from her home in Willenhall: "It's very clean and tidy, the people are very nice and friendly, the scenery is great." 

Despite what television once claimed, I found Highley to be a welcoming village, where rolling hills and friendly faces make it a place that feels much tougher to leave than to love.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice