Birmingham church scheme approved despite objections over gravestones being moved

St Michael’s Church in Boldmere was seeking permission to create a new car park and vehicular access, which will help tackle parking woes on surrounding streets and improve accessibility.

The proposals attracted objections however, with some raising concerns over the impact on ‘historic graves’.

The city council acknowledges in a report that the plans will require “relocating a number of gravestones within the wider graveyard and churchyard”.

But it goes on to say the Archdeacon of Aston, on behalf of the Church of England, has provided written support, confirming that the plans are in full compliance with Church of England procedures.

These include strict guidelines and codes of practice to respect graves and memorials.

Speaking at a council planning meeting today, Coun Gareth Moore said: “I appreciate there is a sensitive aspect to this.

“But I do know the church in question and parking is an absolute nightmare in that area.

“I don’t think it’ll solve all the parking problems but it’ll go some way.”

He added: “There is a process to be followed in terms of re-purposing graveyards and I’m sure the Church of England will follow those very strict rules closely.”

Coun Jamie Scott acknowledged the sensitivities and welcomed the proposals, saying lots of churches are “really struggling”.

“It’s positive that this church is in a position where they are able to put this forward to try and strengthen a community asset,” he said.

Coun Jane Jones described the parking situation as “terrible,” saying: “[The proposals] will definitely help.”

She added that the plans were a “no-brainer” amid assurances that the relocation of gravestones would be handled sensitively.

The planning committee went on to unanimously approve the proposals.

‘Impact on graves is acceptable’

The council said in its report prior to the meeting that several objections had been received, raising concerns that gravestones in the proposed area would be “affected or relocated”.

It continued that efforts were made to trace descendants of the graves and gravestones that would be affected but were unsuccessful.

“However, they have confirmed that the chosen location for the car park and vehicular access will have minimal impact on graves and gravestones,” the report said.

“The car park is to be constructed using a proprietary no-dig grid system to avoid disturbing graves.”

It went on to conclude: “In light of the site’s lack of heritage and archaeological designation and considering the operational needs and long-term viability of the church, the impact on graves and gravestones is considered acceptable.

“Especially given these will be appropriately relocated within the same church ground within a nearby setting.”

On why the plans have been recommended for approval, the report said: “The proposed development seeks to deliver essential improvements to St Michael’s Church.

[These include] the creation of a car park and associated vehicular access, installation of solar panels and air source heat pumps, and accessibility enhancements.

“While the scheme will […] require the sensitive relocation of gravestones, the site is not a designated heritage asset, lies outside a conservation area, and has no archaeological interest.”