Government expert sent in to improve Dudley Council’s ‘inadequate’ children’s services

Dudley Council Houseplaceholder image
Dudley Council House | LDRS

Councillors told recruitment suffers due to poor pay for social workers

The government is sending in an expert to improve Dudley Council’s beleaguered children’s services which have been rated ‘inadequate’ by Ofsted.

A meeting of the council’s Children and Young People Scrutiny Committee on September 30 gave elected members their first opportunity to publicly question bosses on a damning report from watchdogs published in August 2026.

Dudley director of children and young people, John Macilwraith, told councillors the challenge was ‘significant’ after Ofsted identified ten priority areas to improve.

Mr Macilwraith said: “As a result of the inadequate inspection we are assigned by the Department of Education and expert advisor, she will spend 20 to 40 days working with Dudley children’s services assessing how robust our arrangements are and how secure are our plans.

“The expert will assume the chair of our improvement board which is currently chaired by our chief executive.

“This is about Dudley’s children and that’s the bottom line, we need to make it better and make improvements as fast as we can but as sustainably as we can.”

The director told councillors his department was already looking to recruit another 22 social workers and had recently hired new permanent senior managers.

Committee chairperson, Cllr Sue Ridney, said: “In the past we have had difficulty recruiting and one of the things that has come up is that we don’t pay well.

“When you have been interviewing, was the reason you had less applying due to finance or due to the inspection?”

Mr Macilwraith said it was, in part, due to remuneration but also terms and conditions and a review was under way to create more tempting deals for experienced staff.

He added: “Currently our agency rate is about 25 percent of children’s social workers, we need to move to a more permanent arrangement.”

Cllr Cathryn Bayton said: “The frustration for me, I’ve been on children’s scrutiny on and off for ten years and we are having exactly the same conversation about the difficulty with recruitment that we were having ten years ago.

“If things don’t improve in terms of recruitment and a permanent workforce all the other things that have been highlighted by Ofsted won’t improve, I am really concerned.”

Co-opted committee member Richard May reminded councillors of conversations he had with social workers at Dudley.

Mr May said: “Ones I talked to said ‘yep, happy to take a job in Dudley, I will get all the training but I can do the same job with less case load for four, five even six thousand pounds more across the M5’.

“How are you going to solve it unless you are paying what Birmingham is paying? It’s as simple as that.”

Cllr Wayne Little, Dudley cabinet member for children and young people, reminded the committee that the council had recently had to make big savings to avoid the possibility of running out of cash.

Cllr Little said: “A couple of years ago we were facing uncertainty in finance, we prioritised children with what we’d got trying to balance the trade off.

“I’m glad to say we have come through that and we have heard how extra investment has gone in.

“Part of the appeal of getting good people has been the narrative and the commitment of Dudley, my aspiration is ‘outstanding’.

“The intention is there and we should all, as a council, get behind that and make sure we are delivering to the frontline what they need.”

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice