Patient died after communication blunder between Walsall Manor and New Cross hospitals

A coroner raised concerns over the patient's missed ‘urgent’ referral

A cancer patient suffering from a rare and aggressive prostate condition was not given an urgent appointment due to a communication blunder between Walsall Manor and New Cross hospitals.

Martin Poole, of Walsall, died on January 24, just five months after staff spotted he had prostate issues due to a hernia. Walsall Manor Hospital staff made a phone call and an email request for an appointment for him, but the case was subsequently downgraded to “routine” resulting in a delay.

After an inquest into Mr Poole’s death, the cause of death was given as stage four prostate cancer.

Following the inquest Senior Black Country Coroner Zafar Siddique made a regulation 28 report to prevent future deaths due his concerns over the handling of the urgent urology referral from Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust (WHT) to Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust (RWT).

In response trust bosses stated that Mr Poole’s case had been logged and tracked, but some details had not been uploaded to his electronic case notes; the hospitals acknowledged that “the cross-trust communication process could be improved” and the electronic system “requires modernising”.

Mr Siddique’s report stated: “The deceased, Mr Poole was a 69-year-old gentleman. He was admitted into Manor Hospital in Walsall with a hernia on August 11, 2025 where a CT scan and notes reflected that he would be referred for urgent follow-up by urology.

Walsall Manor Hospitalplaceholder image
Walsall Manor Hospital

“This referral was made by telephone but then subsequently downgraded to non-urgent. Mr Poole then presented to his GP who also made a referral to urology. However, in November of the same year he was admitted to New Cross Hospital and was experiencing problems.

“Further examination diagnosed widespread metastatic disease. His condition declined and by January 16 he was placed into Goscote Hospice for end-of-life care and sadly passed away on January 24.

“During the course of the inquest I heard evidence giving rise to concern. In my opinion there is a risk that future deaths could occur unless action is taken.

“I have concerns about the trusts’ referral process between hospitals when an urgent referral is made by telephone only. There is a risk of no formal recording of the request including documentation and subsequent audit trails.”

However, in a joint response to the coroner the hospitals stated that an email was sent and a phone call was made requesting a referral. “The trusts would like to assure that the factual context provided clarifies the paper trail that existed in Mr Poole’s care, while acknowledging that the historical reliance on email created procedural gaps that requires modernising.

“The leadership of both organisations remain dedicated to embedding these digital referral workflows to ensure patient safety.”

New Cross Hospital in Wolverhamptonplaceholder image
New Cross Hospital in Wolverhampton

Bosses said they wanted to express their “sincere condolences to the family and loved ones of the late Martin Alan Poole”.

“We take the findings of the inquest and the coroner’s concerns very seriously and are committed to ensuring that inter-hospital communication, referral management, and audit trails remain safe, reliable and transparent.

“The on-call urology specialist registrar at RWT sent a formal written email referral to the urology secretarial booking team requesting that Mr Poole be booked into the outpatient clinic.

“On August 18 at 9.16am the referral received from WHT was formally acknowledged on the clinical web portal system. A concurrent referral from Mr Poole's GP was received via the NHS Referral Assessment Service on August 19.

“On September 3 this was triaged by a consultant urologist. Because the clinical findings at that time reflected benign rather than red-flag cancer symptoms, it was triaged and booked as routine rather than on a two-week cancer pathway.

“Although the referral was formally received, processed, and tracked within RWT systems, the joint internal review identified the cross-trust communication process could be improved. The email-based referral sent by the inpatient team was not automatically integrated or uploaded into the electronic patient record at WHT or at RWT, leaving an incomplete record. We recognise that the use of email inboxes between trusts creates fragmentation, lacks standard workflow visibility, and makes real-time end-to-end auditing difficult.”

The trusts added that since Mr Poole’s death a standard instruction had been given to administrative staff requiring that written or email referrals must be saved directly on the patient’s notes or electronic clinical record.

Mr Siddique said copies of his report had been sent to the deceased’s family and to the Chief Coroner.

In a narrative conclusion the inquest recorded that Mr Poole died after developing an aggressive and fast-developing cancer of the prostrate which on balance would have had limited response to conventional treatments.

Related topics:

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice