Shinedown lead a formidable night of rock in Birmingham – review
Andy Shaw reviews Shinedown, Coheed and Cambria and Those Damn Crows at bp pulse LIVE, Birmingham (November 14) where three very different rock bands deliver a memorable triple bill
There is more than one way to make an arena-sized statement. Those Damn Crows favour direct, muscular rock; Coheed and Cambria take the winding road through intricate guitars and ambitious songwriting; Shinedown bring the emotional weight and anthems to tie it all together. At Birmingham’s bp pulse LIVE, that combination makes for a formidable triple bill.


Those Damn Crows waste little time getting down to business. Who Did It provides a punchy introduction, with vocalist Shane Greenhall at the centre of a band whose songs balance hard edges with enormous melodic hooks.
Guitarists Ian “Shiner” Thomas and David Winchurch supply the bite, while bassist Lloyd Wood and drummer Ronnie Huxford give the six-song selection its driving backbone. Man on Fire and No Surrender make an especially forceful pairing, their titles neatly capturing the determination running through this opening salvo.


There is room for melody within that muscle. Find a Way and Blink of an Eye broaden the emotional range before “Go Get It” provides a suitably assertive finish. It is a concise introduction to a band with the songwriting ambition to make every available minute count.
Coheed and Cambria bring a different kind of intensity. Their music demands attention through its twists, rhythmic shifts and the unmistakable voice of Claudio Sanchez, whose high-reaching melodies give even the heaviest passages a distinctive character.
An opening run of A Favor House Atlantic, The Suffering and Ten Speed (Of God’s Blood & Burial) puts their combination of complexity and accessibility firmly in focus. Sanchez and guitarist Travis Stever weave the melodic detail around the sturdy foundation supplied by bassist Zach Cooper and drummer Josh Eppard.


Shoulders adds a heavier punch, while Holly Wood the Cracked and Sentry the Defiant underline the band’s theatrical streak. Here to Mars offers a more expansive melodic moment, and The Liars Club brings another injection of urgency.
Then comes Welcome Home. Built around that imposing guitar figure, it is the natural heavyweight conclusion: dramatic, elaborate and powerful enough to make its mark without sacrificing the musical identity that separates Coheed from the rest of the bill.
Shinedown’s headline selection is equally assured in its construction. Safe and Sound opens a 20-song journey that moves between confrontation, reflection and release, with Asking for It and Diamond Eyes quickly establishing its harder edge.


Brent Smith’s voice is the focal point, but this is a four-man operation. Zach Myers supplies the guitar attack and melodic colour, Eric Bass anchors the songs on bass, and Barry Kerch’s drumming gives the heavier material its physical force. Coupled with the copious amount flames and fireworks made for a fantastic sight.
If You Only Knew introduces the emotional openness that makes Shinedown’s catalogue so effective. Alongside 365, Devil, Searchlight and Enemies, it helps establish a set with considerable range: the aggression has purpose, and the quieter passages carry their own weight.
Call Me, Get Up and The Crow & the Butterfly form a particularly affecting stretch. These songs give Smith room to communicate vulnerability as convincingly as defiance, adding depth to a performance that could easily have relied on brute force.


Bully sharpens the mood again, while Your Love and Young Again carry the set towards a formidable closing sequence. Symptom of Being Human offers connection and reassurance before Cut the Cord delivers a much fiercer kind of release.
Monsters keeps the emotional stakes high, and Simple Man provides a measured change of pace before the unmistakable crunch of Sound of Madness.


Finally, Second Chance supplies the closing statement. Its themes of change and self-determination make it a fitting destination for a set that repeatedly finds strength in difficult emotions.
Across three contrasting bands, the evening offers far more than a succession of heavy riffs. Those Damn Crows bring conviction, Coheed and Cambria bring imagination, and Shinedown bring the songs to turn personal struggles into arena-sized anthems.