I tried an EIGHT cheese pizza at Birmingham New Street station - here’s my verdict on the neapolitan wonder

A restaurant at Birmingham New Street train station is serving a pizza with eight different cheese toppings - so we went along to try it out

Brothers James and Thom Elliot quit their corporate jobs in TV and advertising in London and flew out to the toe end of Italy.

Here they picked up a three-wheel Piaggio Ape van (a converted Tuk Tuk) and began a journey of pizza discovery from the top to the bottom of the country where the beloved dough and cheese dish was born.

It was a trip that changed their lives. Inspired by growing up above pubs that their parents ran in Gloucestershire and Dorset, the brothers learned everything they could about pizza making - and dreamt of opening their own pizza restaurant back home in the UK.

Fourteen years later the pair are the proud owners of their own pizza empire, aptly called Pizza Pilgrims after their Italian quest, which became a TV series.

There are 29 Pizza Pilgrims restaurants across the UK - 20 are in London - and there’s one at Birmingham New Street.

And this is where we headed to on a Wednesday evening arriving at around 6.30pm.

Pizza Pilgrims at Grand Central at Birmingham New Streetplaceholder image
Pizza Pilgrims at Grand Central at Birmingham New Street | Fionnuala Bourke

It’s a great spot for casual dining, tucked behind Ozzy the Bull in a corner of Grand Central that offers a more secluded area on the upper floor of the train station for their guests.

There’s a three wheel Piaggio Ape van in the centre with colourful table cloths, a bright bar area and stripey awning around the open oven near the entrance.

Charming posters cheering Naples (the birthplace of pizza) and entertaining artefacts are placed around the space which is filled with music - all helping to transport diners away from the train station below, offering a taste of the streets of Italy.

Pizza Pilgrims certainly has its own distinctive mood which sets it apart from some of the other Grand Central restaurants around this side of the leisure space which are more open plan.

We were warmly welcomed as we arrived and swiftly shown to our table, which was next to a guitar hanging on a wall.

There was a selection of cocktails, wines, beers and soft drinks.

But obviously the main purpose of this visit was to check out the pizza - especially the one with EIGHT cheeses.

Eight cheese pizza at Pizza Pilgrims at Grand Central at Birmingham New Streetplaceholder image
Eight cheese pizza at Pizza Pilgrims at Grand Central at Birmingham New Street | Fionnuala Bourke

I didn’t have too long to wait after I began sipping on my first glass of ‘snazzy’ Pinot Grigio until it arrived.

My first impression was one of relief. I had feared I could be defeated by an eight cheese dough feast.

But as this was a 12 inch dish, I immediately realised that there was every likelihood that all that cheese did not stand a chance of survival - it would all be consumed.

After my eyes became accustomed to appetising size, they were next drawn to the pinnacle of pizza heaven, and one of my all-time favourite ever pieces of food - burrata.

There can never be enough burrata in the world - that soft, squishy, dairy goodness oozing with cool, soothing, buttery beauty can bring joy to the dreariest of days.

It sat in the middle of my pizza and was as good as it looked - maybe not the best ever burrata I’ve eaten, but it was very, very good.

You may be wondering what other cheeses were featured on this eight cheese wonder.

Well, I’m happy to report the others were gorgonzola, provola, ricotta, fior di latte mozzarella, grana padano, parmesan and buffalo mozzarella.

My mouth is actually watering as I type all of these out.

Pizza Pilgrims at Grand Central at Birmingham New Streetplaceholder image
Pizza Pilgrims at Grand Central at Birmingham New Street | Fionnuala Bourke

My second favourite after the burrata was the powerful gorgonzola - creamy yet sharp in taste, bringing a tantalizingly tangy hit of blue cheese swagger to the pizza, which had no tomato, by the way.

Who needs tomatoes when you’ve got eight cheeses!

There was sweet chilli jam though - this added another layer of texture and taste adding a welcome variety to each bite.

The charred crust - a must for Neapolitan pizzas - was suitably blackened and leopard-like - soft and warm, springy and airy offering mountain tops of taste where rivers of cheese ran through..

If you like cheese, this really is a treat to try.

My friend ordered the double pepperoni and spicy honey. I tried a slice - it was gorgeous, especially with the chilli infused honey drizzled over the two types of pepperoni.

We also managed to, almost, polish off two side dishes - a rocket, parmesan and balsamic salad (yup, more cheese) and artichokes fritti served with a white truffle dip.

Double Pepperoni & Hot Honeyplaceholder image
Double Pepperoni & Hot Honey | Fionnuala Bourke

As well as food, Pizza Pilgrims is passionate about sustainability which they champion across their brand.

The B Corp certified business is currently collaborating with Dishoom, Honest Burgers, Pho and Sweet Dee’s Jerk BBQ on its dip menu which is raising money for the Make-A-Wish Foundation.

We tried the rosemary chips dip from Honest Burger which was a great way to make the most out of those pizza crusts.

Eight Cheeses isn’t the only gimmicky style pizza offered at Pizza Pilgrims - you can get a carbonara pizza too. I’ve heard decent reports on this - a gimmick that works as a great meal to enjoy is all good so far as I’m concerned.

You can also order Pizza Pilgrims pizzas by post - now that isn’t something I can vouch for though.

Handy to know, I guess - you never know when you might need a good pizza.

But if you don’t want to rely on the post to get your next fix of decent pizza, then give Pizza Pilgrims a go - a casual dining spot inspired by an Italian journey sitting two floors above hundreds of Birmingham train journeys.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice