Government has no power to make Google remove Russell Brand video, minister says


Google has reportedly rejected a request to remove a video in which Brand’s wife Laura Gallacher shared the message from the jailed sex offender.
The Government has no power to make Google take down a YouTube video in which Russell Brand claims he is innocent of his crimes, a minister has said, but appealed to the tech giant to think of the convicted rapist’s victims.
Google has reportedly rejected a request from the Government to remove a video in which Brand’s wife Laura Gallacher shared a message from the jailed sex offender in which he insisted he was not guilty of the offences for which he is serving a 10-and-a-half-year term.
Ms Gallacher read out the message on their YouTube podcast on Sunday, prompting an official investigation into whether Brand had breached prison rules.
The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) submitted an official request to Google, which owns YouTube, asking for the video to be removed.
But, according to the BBC, Google denied the request because it determined its rules had not been broken.
Asked by the BBC’s Breakfast programme on Thursday morning if the Government could force Google to remove the video, housing minister Matthew Pennycook said: “We don’t have any power to mandate a removal of content. That is up to Google. It’s based on their terms and conditions.
“But as I’ve been very clear, we’ve made a request in this instance because we feel very strongly that victims shouldn’t have to see this content.”
He added: “We hope they do so because they have taken action on their platform before, they banned, for example in 2023, Russell Brand for making money off the platform because his off-platform behaviour was seen to cause harm.”
Mr Pennycook also told Sky News the MoJ was currently in a “dialogue” with Google about the video.
An MoJ spokesperson said: “It is only right that the Government asks for content that is distressing for victims to be taken down and we strongly believe YouTube should remove this content.
“Removal ultimately depends on the platform’s own terms.”
Meta disabled Brand’s Instagram and Facebook accounts after his conviction.
A Google spokesperson said: “We’re aware of the new content and our teams are investigating. We suspended Russell Brand’s channel from the YouTube Partner Programme in September 2023. The channel has not been able to monetise on YouTube since then.”
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch suggested that if she was in power she would not immediately demand Google remove the video.
She also told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme: “My personal opinion is that Russell Brand has been convicted. He is guilty under the law. The rule of law applies to everyone in this country.
“His wife is a separate person. She can make the protestations that she likes. I’m very concerned if people in prison are able to use other conduits to be able to send messages. I think that that is unorthodox.
“But YouTube is a private platform. I think that immediately demanding the private platforms take things down without looking at exactly whether a law has been broken is not where I would start from.
“If we want to make legislation for that, then we can look at that. But I’m quite worried about Government intervening.”