Player ratings after Walsall make it to Wembley

Walsall beat Chesterfield 4-1 over two legs in their League Two play-off clash - here we rated the players after a historic night at Bescot. 

Walsall have booked their place at Wembley for only the second time in their history.placeholder image
Walsall have booked their place at Wembley for only the second time in their history.

Tommy Simkin 

The keeper had very little to do over the course of the 90 minutes. He did go down with a couple of injuries, of course - they were tactical. 

Smart: 7

Liam Gordon

Played such an important part in the fixture over the two legs. Constant threat on the left, and defended expertly too.

Exceptional: 8 

Taylor Allen 

Made one outstanding challenge in the first half that stopped what looked like a certain goal for Chesterfield. Complete Rolls-Royce in the second.

Superb: 9

Harry Williams

Had a couple of tricky moments up against the pacey Bim Pepple, who turned him a few times, but was good in the air and ensured the pacey forward was quiet after the break.

Solid: 8

David Okagbue 

It was always going to be a night where Walsall had to defend, and Okagbue was equal to everything the Spireites threw at him.

Excellent: 8

Nathan Asiimwe 

Picked up a yellow card for time wasting, but was a real threat down the right side. He holds onto the ball and glides across the turf.

Terrific: 8

Ryan Stirk 

Excellent in the heart of midfield. Covered every blade of Bescot turf and won countless 50/50 challenges. This was a really composed display. 

Composed: 9

Alfie Chang 

Another 60 minutes in the tank for Chang, who was not quite as good as he was in the first tie, but still showed one or two moments of real class. 

Moments: 7

Jamie Jellis 

Was the Saddlers' biggest threat in the first period. He had bags of energy, and on another day, he could have had a couple of goals.

Energetic: 9

George Hall 

On the opposite wing, Hall put in a good showing during the first period. Lively after the break as well. 

Lively: 8

Jamille Matt 

Always tricky up against Kyle McFadzean, a big central defender, but he kept him honest. His experience was needed on the night.

Vital: 7

Substitutes: 

Levi Amantchi 8 (Matt 61), Brandon Comley 8 (Chang 61) Albert Adomah 9 (Jellis 73), Charlie Lakin 8 (Hall 73), Donervon Daniels (Asiimwe 90)

Not used: Hornby, Gordon.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice