Hit or miss: Bilkul's West Brom loan record and why there is a need for an improvement as January window set to open
As the January transfer window opens up tomorrow - Albion and many other clubs will be looking to the market to strengthen.
It is unclear if Albion will have any money to spend in the January window - but if they do then it will be minimal.
There will be an emphasis on the loan market - which Albion have utilised in the last three windows under the owners Bilkul.
But how successful have they been. The short answer is not very.
Here is a breakdown of the loan signings over the last three windows and whether they have been hits or misses:
Charlie Taylor - Half hit
Signed in the summer as what looked like cover, Taylor has played at both left back and centre half.
Of the loan signings this season, he has probably been the best to date although he has had a few dodgy displays.
Samuel Iling-Junior - Miss but potential
One who came in with promise, but has failed to really hit the heights expected.
He has shown flashes, but nowhere near enough.
Toby Collyer - Miss
A miss. His quality is there but we haven't seen it. A lot of it is down to injuries and he is expected to now return to Manchester United.
Adam Armstrong - Miss
A signed that was more from the manager - with Tony Mowbray influencing a return. Despite promise, he failed to deliver. In truth Albion failed to deliver much for the striker by way of chances.
Mason Holgate - Half hit
A late signing last summer - his second loan spell was okay, but just that. He had some dodgy displays, as did others for Albion. He did a job, but not much more than that.


Paddy McNair - Injury hit
A six month cover loan - McNair was hit by injuries. When he did briefly feature, it looked like a good signing but Albion never really got anything out of him.
Will Lankshear - Half hit
One who suffered with a lack of chances amid other loan signings. Lankshear's qualities as a Championship striker were there to be seen - but he wasn't given enough of a run in the side.
Uros Racic - Miss
Of all the loan signings in the Bilkul era, Racic played as many games as most in the first half of last season. But there was not enough consistency. Early on he was promising but he soon tailed off.


Lewis Dobbin - Miss
Signed with big expectations but again suffered with the arrival of others. But when he did feature, he failed to make a mark. He has shown his quality this season though with a loan elsewhere.
