Midfielders and January recruit: Who starred and struggled in West Brom player ratings
How did the Albion players fare from our ratings across a miserable campaign?
It was a season to forget almost across the board for Albion.
The only crumb of comfort was how it ended - as caretaker and club legend James Morrison steered the Baggies to safety and away from the clutches of League One.
At the Express & Star we hand out player ratings to mark performances out of 10 for each game. Below we have calculated Albion’s average ratings across the miserable 2025/26 campaign.
Below in ascending order is a list of 10 Baggies men who featured the most in terms of games started - and graded - across the season. Players had to feature in around half of Albion’s 49 games to make the cut.
Isaac Price - 5.9
It was a real rollercoaster campaign for the attack-minded midfielder.
Price started the season in excellent form under Ryan Mason and everything looked rosy as he rattled in the goals.
That form dipped, however, and alarmingly so in a Baggies side that badly struggled. A frustrated Price had an argument with fans as things threatened to boil over.
He got it back together under Morrison, however, and finished with a flourish and nine goals in all.
Mikey Johnston - 6.1
One of his side's brighter performers across the first half of the season and he had a league-leading nine assists by the new year.
Johnston's form remained patchy, albeit he was often the most likely source of creativity.
His season ended with a broken ankle at Oxford in Morrison's first game - before the 10-match saving run.
Nat Phillips - 6.2
Centre-back Phillips started his debut campaign well but struggled thereafter in Albion's desperate run of form.
A stack of partners in the backline did not help and by January Albion had spiralled.
He responded excellently under Morrison next to George Campbell.
Josh Griffiths - 6.3
The academy graduate was Baggies No.1 until December but lost his place to Joe Wildsmith under Mason.
There had been highlights - Norwich away was a remarkable match-winning display - but he was guilty of conceding some poor goals and the xG and shots-faced stats did not make for good reading.
Max O’Leary ousted him from January.
Ousmane Diakite - 6.3
Mostly been a squad player at The Hawthorns and seldom used in the first half of the campaign.
But he showed what he can do in the improvements late on in the season where Diakite kept Alex Mowatt out the side more often than not.
The combative midfielder's form was well worth a triggered contract extension and first international call.
George Campbell - 6.3
There was sympathy with the American centre-half playing out of position at right-back under Mason until after Christmas.
He gave it his all and, while limited in parts of that role over the halfway line, gained support.
Campbell was class when used at centre-back under Morrison, however. He grabbed the chance and did not look back with solid displays and key goals.
Aune Heggebo - 6.3
There was pressure and expectation on the Norwegian frontman after his £4.7million move from Brann.
He took time to adjust but immediately showed signs of battling qualities.
Heggebo had droughts without a goal with too much burden on his shoulders at times. He finished as Albion's 10-goal top scorer, mostly thanks to a purple patch of seven goals in seven games before Christmas.
Callum Styles - 6.3
Double Albion player of the season and there was little doubt the left-back deserved those accolades.
He was consistent throughout a campaign where others struggled to find the same level.
Just fell shot of coming out on top here - possibly because he failed to find the net all season which must be improved on for an attack-minded full-back of his ability.
Jayson Molumby - 6.4
The central midfield pair have come out on top, somewhat surprisingly, albeit in a season where aside from Diakite there was little competition for their roles.
Molumby weighed in with a couple of vital goals, at home to Swansea and Southampton, though you would back him to net more. He let himself down badly with the Coventry red card but responded well.
Higher average mark shows he manages a level of consistency across the piece.
Alex Mowatt - 6.4
Probably more of a surprise than Molumby to feature at the top of the ratings given that for periods, including the run of good results late on, he lost his place to Diakite.
But Mowatt has been the player in recent years that tends to get Albion going with the ball.
There was not nearly enough of it this season from anybody, but he still showed a level of dependability.
How those with fewer appearances and ratings fared
Chris Mepham 5.6 (22 matches)
Charlie Taylor 5.2 (19 matches)
Karlan Grant 6.1 (16 matches)
Josh Maja 6.0 (16 matches)
Max O’Leary 6.1 (16 matches)
Samuel Iling-Junior 5.6 (14 matches)
Danny Imray 6.4 (13 matches)
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.
