Matt Maher: Ref justice? Why it is hard not to have sympathy with Aston Villa and Jhon Duran
For more than two years, Unai Emery barely uttered a word about referees.


The only time the Villa boss ever spoke about officiating was to say he wouldn’t be speaking about it. No criticism was ever issued in its direction.
Yet for the past few weeks it feels he has barely talked about anything else. Post-match press conferences in consecutive away Premier League matches were dominated by a discussion on refereeing decisions, while Emery devoted the bulk of his programme notes ahead of Monday’s 2-2 draw with Brighton to the subject, putting forward an argument for why he believes officials should make more use of VAR.
Regular readers of his space won’t be surprised to learn we will not be backing the Spaniard up on that point. The long-held view of his writer is football would be better off if VAR disappeared completely.
Yet when it comes to the cause of Emery’s frustration, the recent decisions he believes have gone against his team at important times in key games, it is hard not to have some sympathy.
That is particularly true when it comes to the red card and subsequent three-match ban received by Jhon Duran for an alleged stamp in the 3-0 Boxing Day defeat at Newcastle. It is less the incident itself which feels cause for irritation, than the comparison to how similar events elsewhere were handled and what it says about the inconsistencies in approach and - most importantly - the big problem it reveals in how the current laws and FA protocols are drawn up.
We are not talking, at least in this debate, about the two-match ban eventually handed down to Matheus Cunha following the altercation which occurred at the end of last month’s 2-1 defeat to Ipswich.
Even the most one-eyed Wolves supporter, having witnessed the footage which emerged in the aftermath, would have to concede surprise at the apparent leniency. Yet there was much about the way the FA dealt with the case which raised eyebrows and one suspects the written reasons for the two-match sanction, when released, will prove illuminating. It would be better to wait until then before giving an opinion.
What is fair to compare with the Duran case is that involving the Brighton striker Joao Pedro, who escaped sanction entirely after swinging an elbow in the direction of Brentford midfielder Yehor Yarmoliuk barely 24 hours after the Villa forward had been dismissed on Tyneside.
Set in isolation and when referred against the football law book, it becomes easier to understand how both of the respective decisions were reached. It is only when placed alongside each other they appear prime evidence of the perceived inconsistency which exists, fair or otherwise, in the Premier League’s refereeing standards.
Both incidents, essentially, came down to how two different referees and video assistants interpreted the laws surrounding violent conduct.
Duran was sent-off because referee Anthony Taylor believed he meant to tread on Newcastle defender Fabian Schar as both tumbled to the ground. Or, to quote directly from the IFAB rulebook, that he used or attempted to use “excessive force or brutality against an opponent.”
Video assistant Graham Scott, having reviewed the footage, felt that was a fair assessment and did not call for a pitchside review. To all intents and purposes, it was a matter of opinion.
Yet even when viewing the incident several times, from numerous angles, it felt impossible to ascertain whether Duran really had attempted to “use excessive force” or whether he had simply collided with Schar accidentally after losing his footing. Even Newcastle boss Eddie Howe and Magpies legend Alan Shearer felt he had been rather unlucky.
Fast forward 24 hours or so and there could be little doubt Pedro meant to swing his arm. There could also be no dispute the force with which it was swung appeared excessive. Under the laws of the game, the fact he did not make contact with Yarmoliuk would make no difference to whether the act be deemed violent conduct.
Referee Andy Madley, however, chose only to issue a yellow card and VAR Chris Kavanagh, after reviewing the incident, agreed. The only possible explanation is both concluded Pedro was not deliberately attempting to strike Yarmoliuk when he swung his arm.
“Astonishing,” is how former referee Dermot Gallagher described that assessment, during his weekly TV show on Sky Sports. It would be fair to say for the majority of observers, that was the prevailing view. Pedro, it was generally agreed, had a very fortunate escape.
To most this felt a case where the officials had blundered but the prospect of the FA taking retrospective action was always remote, due to the incident having been seen by the referee and reviewed by VAR at the time.
One might consider this piece of protocol which might be considered for review. What good does it do the game if the FA is unable to correct an error which appeared clear and obvious to all but those officiating the match?
On the one hand you have Duran, suspended for three matches for an alleged offence where it remains impossible to know for sure whether he attempted to do anything. Then there is Pedro, recipient of a yellow card and free to play and set up two goals for his team at Villa Park on Monday night, despite clear evidence he attempted to swing his arm with an opponent in close proximity.
Clear evidence is what Villa lacked in their failed attempt to get Duran’s dismissal overturned. In that decision, there was at least some logic. Why should the guesswork of an FA commission supersede that of the referee?
That doesn’t alter Villa’s sense of injustice, further heightened by the striker then being hit by a further charge for kicking a water bottle.
Neither does it change the fact that, while the laws of the game might naturally need to be open to interpretation, there also needs to be room for a little common sense.
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.
