Cheltenham Town 2-2 Walsall player ratings: One 8 as Saddlers blow two-goal lead

George Bennett gives his Walsall player ratings from their 2-2 against Cheltenham Town at the EV Charger Points Stadium in League Two. 

Walsall conceded two late goals to draw 2-2 against Cheltenham Town in February 2025.placeholder image
Walsall conceded two late goals to draw 2-2 against Cheltenham Town in February 2025.

Tommy Simkin - 7

Made an impressive near post save to deny George Miller late on but had very little chances of keeping out both of Cheltenham's late strikes.

Oisin McEntee - 7

Aerially dominant - Good in the air in both boxes as his flicked header forced Joe Day to parry into the goalmouth for Ellis Harrison to prod home the opener.

David Okagbue - 7

Solid - Booked for pulling down Manchester United loanee Ethan Williams in the first half but looked relatively solid in the centre of the back-three. 

Taylor Allen - 7

Good - Tasked with defending a couple of teasing balls in behind but dealt with the danger well and set-up a header from Jamille Matt after venturing forward from the back.

Brandon Comley - 8

Alert - Kept his place in the team and served as a real calming influence to help settle the game down at times. Read the game so well and was first to so many balls.

Connor Barrett - 7

Lively - Perhaps fortunate to have gone unpunished for a shirt pull on Ethan Williams inside the box but threatened down the right with a lively performance.

Jamie Jellis - 7 

Threat - Threatened between the lines with a series of neat passes and played a key role in Walsall's opener with his long throw. However, he was guilty of failing to clear his lines for Cheltenham's equaliser.

Ryan Stirk - 7

Fluent - Constantly looked to get on the ball and helped Walsall produce a fluent midfield performance with both his movement and accurate passing.

Liam Gordon - 7 

Mixed - A livewire down the left especially going forward but perhaps was culpable of leaving George Miller unmarked at the back post to volley home Cheltenham's first goal.

Jamille Matt - 7

Relentless - Played well with his back to goal with a few tidy touches in the final third and pressed relentlessly to keep Cheltenham penned in before he was taken off midway into the second half.

Ellis Harrison - 7 

Opener - Showcased his predatory instincts inside the box to pounce on Oisin McEntee's parried header and prod home from close-range. 

Substitutes 

Levi Amantchi (for Harrison, 69) - 6

Ineffectual - Struggled to have much of an impact after being introduced midway into the second half.

Albert Adomah (for Matt, 69) - 7

Pounced on a poor mistake from Sam Stubbs to round Cheltenham goalkeeper Day and tap into an empty net for his 99th professional goal.

Unused: Hornby, Williams, Weir, Lakin, Johnson.

Related topics:

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice