Council broke planning rules by obstructing archaeologists, says theatre body
A public body set up to protect and preserve the nation's theatres has accused Dudley Council of breaching planning rules by obstructing its experts as they tried to compile an historic record of the town's Hippodrome theatre.


Dudley Council planners gave the go-ahead for the demolition of the council-owned theatre in December, 2021, subject to approval from the Secretary of State for Local Government. But one of the conditions was that archaeologists appointed by the Theatres Trust – a government regulatory body – must be allowed inside the theatre to compile an historic record before demolition took place.
Tom Clarke, national planning adviser to the Theatres Trust, has written to Dudley Council accusing it of failing to comply with its obligations.
He wrote: "We do not consider the council to have acted within the spirit of its own planning condition and its approach is not one we have encountered before.
"We would expect the council to take formal action to address and remedy what appears to be a breach of condition as it would take against any other applicant."
Mr Clarke said the report published on behalf of the trust, which recorded the historic features of the Hippodrome, was limited by actions of council workmen who had removed important features before they were able to access the building.
"It is regrettable that the overall content has been compromised by the actions of the council in stripping so much fabric and not affording an appropriate opportunity to go into the building between works," wrote Mr Clarke.
"There could have been an interim stage whereby photographs were taken prior to stripping of the later bingo fit-out.
"We consider that the final report is the best that can be expected under the circumstances and constraints the author had to work within."
Mr Clarke said that notwithstanding these objections, he accepted that the report published was sufficient to allow the planning conditions to be discharged.
Councillor Patrick Harley, leader of Dudley Council, denied there had been any breaches of planning conditions.
"The appointed archaeologists visited and recorded the building prior to the stripping out of asbestos," he said.
"The applicant then arranged for the archaeologists to have subsequent visits so further recording of the building could be undertaken. Consequently, the local planning authority is satisfied that the demolition works are being carried out in full compliance with the original consent.”
The report, carried out by independent consultants Oxford Archaeology, said that when it opened, the Hippodrome stage was said to compare favourably 'with those of the Paris, Milan and Rome Opera Houses'.
It also stated that the authority had successfully removed a restrictive covenant placed by the Earl of Dudley, when he provided the land for the theatre, which stipulated it could only be used for entertainment or housing purposes.
The council, which bought the theatre in 2010 for an undisclosed sum, is demolishing the building to make way for a £36 million nursing college, which will be run by Worcester University.
The authority has also begun proceedings to place a compulsory purchase order on the neighbouring former roller-skate rink, now occupied by a banqueting suite, as part of the project, which will receive £25 million from the Department for Levelling Up.
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.
