Peter Rhodes on cows, cards and a new job vacancy in Gaza
Keir Starmer sings the praises of digital identity cards. He declares: “Digital ID is an enormous opportunity for the UK.”


Well, if it's such an enormous opportunity today, why wasn't it even mentioned in Labour's manifesto for the 2024 general election? For that matter, what is the point in a manifesto at all?
Time after time, from imposing 20mph speed limits to scrapping winter fuel allowance and launching ID cards, issues which have a profound effect on our daily life never appear in any manifesto and are not even debated but are simply announced in Whitehall, like diktats from Putin's Kremlin.
The argument that ID cards would help deter illegal immigrants is simply ludicrous. As a reader put it three years ago, cards would be pointless because “nothing would happen to people who hadn't got them".
And while Starmer and Co talk bravely of “inclusion,” any internet-connected ID system would exclude the estimated five per cent of Britons, mostly the elderly, who have no internet connection. The Government promises “consultation” on this issue. I bet. And would these consultations be invited by text, email and social media, but definitely not hand-written, by any chance...?
If Whitehall really wants to stop migrants vanishing into the black economy and being exploited on starvation wages, it should look no further than its own cattle tracing system which tracks livestock with a unique number on an ear tag and a physical cattle passport. Keepers must register births, movements, and deaths. It is a proven system. Some years ago a farmer suggested to me that the best way to keep track of migrants would be to give every newcomer, on arrival, not an ID card but a cow.
Tony Blair is said to be “willing to sacrifice his time” to end the war in Gaza and help run the place until a permanent government is in place. Very noble. But is this not a job demanding someone skilled in the dark arts of compromise and diplomacy, currently without a job and eager to rebuild his reputation? You can't keep a good Mandelson down.
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.