Woman left with 'life changing' physical and mental injuries after argument over £30

An argument over £30 between two people who lived in the same high rise block of flats in Birmingham led to one of them being stabbed and suffering 'life changing injuries.'

placeholder image

At Wolverhampton Crown Court, Paul Garland, aged 45 of Guild Close, Birmingham was handed an 11 year jail term with seven to be served behind bars for the attack on Letitia Kavanagh on March 5 this year.

He had earlier pleaded guilty to three counts: Wounding with intent, threats to kill and intentional strangulation.

The court heard both lived in on the third floor of the flats in Ladywood and were friendly, spending time in each others respective homes.

On the day, an arrangement was made where Ms Kavanagh would transfer £30 into Mr Garland's account and he would withdraw it from a cashpoint, as she didn't have a bank account.

But an argument ensued over the bankcard which Garland accused Ms Kavanagh of taking and additional money for taking part in the transaction, the court heard.

The situation got out of hand and led to 'chaotic scenes,' with Ms Kavanagh grabbed by the throat, punched in the stomach and chased around the flat where she threw multiple objects such as pictures and a glass ashtray and tried to smash a window with a speaker to get away.

The victim was eventually stabbed in the hand with a pair of scissors, had to undergo a surgical procedure to reattach the tendon and was wearing a splint for many weeks afterwards - she was also left with permanent scarring.

A victim impact statement read out to the court said the attack had lasting effects on the victim, who was already suffering from anxiety and her mental health before it.

It said: "This attack which was unprovoked, unexpected and unforeseen has left me physically shaken to this day and has had a profound effect on me doing everyday tasks like getting dressed which I have to get help from my partner with.

"It has taken away my independence and five months later I am still struggling and when I walk past his (Garland's) flat and when I hear banging think that he has been let out and it's him living close by again and that he is going to attack me again - physically it will take 18 months to get the strength back in my hand."

Jailing Garland, who has seven convictions for eight offences including assault and ABH stretching back to 2003, Judge John Butterfield said drugs and drink may have been a significant factor in the attack but that offered no excuse.

He said: "The pre-sentence report highlights this and the problem I'm afraid is that you are an entrenched substance abuser which needs to be addressed but I am satisfied you pose a high risk of serious harm to the public and only a custodial sentence will justify the gravity of the offence and the injuries inflicted."

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice