Why can’t Britain build railways on time anymore? Birmingham–Manchester rail link pushed back to the 2040s
Building railways, it would appear, has become a notoriously difficult task, writes Dr Steve McCabe
That the proposed link between Birmingham and Manchester, only announced earlier this year, will be delayed until the 2040s “at the earliest" will come as little surprise to those who question our ability to deliver major infrastructure projects in a timely way.
This line, it should be remembered, was to replace the high-speed connection, High Speed Two, usually referred to as HS2, between the two cities that was part of the original scheme proposed in March 2010 by the then Transport Secretary Lord Adonis.
Given that HS1 between St Pancras and the Channel Tunnel had been such a success, positively contributing to the Kent economy and increasing employment, and the 68.3-mile line had been built on budget (around £6 billion) and within the planned timetable, there was a view within the Labour government under Gordon Brown that this could be repeated.
Hence, Adonis announced a Y-shaped line that would link London to Manchester and Leeds, both via Birmingham, and that this would be achieved at an estimated cost of £35 billion.
Significantly, it was stated in 2010, the first phase of HS2 would be the line between London (Euston) and Birmingham (Curzon Street), with stops at Old Oak Common (allowing access to what is now the Elixabeth Underground Line thus allowing travel to St. Pancras), and an interchange station proximate to Birmingham International Airport, would cost between
The estimated cost Adonis proclaimed, would be £15.8-17.4 billion and would be complete by 2026.
As we know, this stretch of line is nowhere near completion and, we’re informed, unlikely to be so until well into the next decade.
Worse, the best estimate of the total cost of what’s left of HS2, from London to Birmingham, the Leeds leg and Birmingham to Manchester route having been abandoned due to intense concern at the cost of the whole project, is in excess of £100 billion.
Building railways, it would appear, has become a notoriously difficult task which takes far longer than planned and costs a great deal more than is estimated at the outset.
It might be asked what has changed since HS1 was completed in November 2007 when the first new railway to be built in England for over 100 years, on which trains reach speeds of up to 300 km/h (185mph), was built without problems?
There’s no straightforward answer to the ongoing farce that HS2 has become but, it should be stressed, one of the reasons for the cost and time delay, it’s explained, was the desire to operate the fastest trains in Europe that were capable of travelling at up to 400 kilometres an hour (250 mph).
The riposte is that if building line for such fast trains is problematic, wouldn’t it have made more sense to construct lines on which trains ran at lower speeds?
This is exactly what the line between Birmingham and Manchester, proposed earlier this year, would be.
Unfortunately, and though seen by some as a ‘second best’ when compared to the high-speed line that was originally envisaged in 2010, even a more conventional line, urgently required to cope with the rapidly developing capacity issue on the existing West Coast Main Line (WCML), will, at best, not be completed for at least two decades.
As Jo Shanmugalingam, Permanent Secretary at the Department for Transport (DfT) informed a recent Public Accounts Committee session on Northern Powerhouse Rail (NPR), there’s no specification – an essential prerequisite of any construction project – for the line which means any commencement date is uncertain.
The members of the committee, MPs, heard that the line forms the third and final part of a three-phase NPR programme in which the order of priority is upgrades in Yorkshire, a new Liverpool–Manchester line and links east.
Notably, DfT officials who attended the committee with Shanmugalingam explained that finance for the proposed Birmingham–Manchester line will not come from the £45 billon NPR budget.
As such, and without a firm commitment on funding, it’s questionable whether the line will ever be built.
What’s disappointing, to say the least, is that as money is literally being chucked at the high-speed line between Birmingham and London, ostensibly to solve the capacity problem in that part of the WCML, which could easily have been built to run at a slower rate and therefore reduced cost, the connections north of the Midlands are being neglected.
We’ve heard so much about the need to revitalise the north of England, which, since the loss of traditional industries in the 1980s, has experienced decline and marked increases in deprivation and the social ills associated with lack of opportunity.
Improved infrastructure and transport links are universally acknowledged as crucial to addressing such problems, and the putative line between Birmingham and Manchester would seem to represent an ideal opportunity to achieve such economic and social progress.
However, as we’re hearing on a daily basis, government finances are in a parlous state, and because of uncertainty by lenders as to the state of the UK economy, long-term costs of repaying government debt have increased to the highest level since 1998.
The consequence of this is that even more of the money received by the exchequer from taxes we all pay will be hoovered up simply to service the debt which exacerbates the threat of the UK being sucked into a ‘vortex of decline’.
There’s little opposition to the argument that much of our vital infrastructure, not to forget services, is in need of urgent investment if only to keep them at their, relatively, poor level.
Obtaining the incredible levels of efficiency and service, especially in transport, enjoyed by most Western countries and which positively contribute to their economic development, will not be possible unless a more strategic view of investment is taken.
Perhaps the creation in April last year of the National Infrastructure and Service Transformation Authority (NISTA), formed by merging the National Infrastructure Commission (NIC) and the Infrastructure and Projects Authority (IPA), might enable the strategic overview of national infrastructure so desperately needed.
However, as we’ve experienced for decades in the UK, priorities wax and wane according to political whim and, all too frequently, the exigencies forced upon us by the latest unforeseen short-term crisis.
So, it appears we'll continue to ‘make do and mend’ as the slogan used during the Second World War went and, more likely in hope than expectation, believe that things will eventually get better.
In conclusion, whilst we may be able to travel faster to London on high-speed trains sometime in the next in ten years at a cost which may be prohibitive, our ability to get to destinations such as Manchester, may become increasingly prone to delays and cancellations as the WCML reaches capacity.
To think, our railways were once the envy of the world!
Dr Steve McCabe
Steve is Professor and Pro Vice Chancellor, DoctorateHub.
Previously, having worked for Birmingham City Council, he spent the last 35 years as an academic at Birmingham City University teaching and researching economics, management and business. Additionally, he has written extensively for edited texts examining economics and politics.
He regularly writes and comments regularly in the national and international media on politics and the economy and has published texts on quality management, benchmarking, ‘Brexit’ and its economic and social impact, the green economy and manufacturing, house prices and India’s progress since independence.
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.