Unauthorised extension faces demolition after Walsall homeowner loses planning appeal

The homeowner built the rear dormer without planning permission

A homeowner in Streetly may have to demolish an unauthorised loft dormer after failing to win over the planning inspectorate. 

Inspector N. Bromley said the development at the rear of 40 Lowlands Avenue ‘unacceptably harms the appearance’ of the area. 

The decision followed an earlier refusal by Walsall Council’s planning committee in April 2026. 

40 Lowlands Avenue, Streetlyplaceholder image
40 Lowlands Avenue, Streetly | LDRS

Members at the meeting heard how homeowner Mr Mani Singh had built the extension without planning permission. 

Following enforcement action by Walsall Council, an application was submitted to regularise the works. 

Ahead of the April meeting officers had recommended the application be approved, but this was challenged by then Streetly ward councillor Sarah Cooper.

At the meeting the applicant argued the work came under permitted development rights, but some members disagreed.

Officers also said the type of work was in line with others at nearby properties.

Residents objecting claimed the extensions referred to were not comparable as they backed onto Blackwood Park, rather than private gardens.

The development also breached the council’s separation policy by half a metre.

The plans were refused by councillors on the grounds of the breach of separation policy, incongruous development, loss of light and detriment to neighbouring amenities.

Mr Singh tried to overturn the committee’s ruling by challenging the decision at appeal.

Inspector Bromley found that while the dormer does ‘not cause unacceptable harm’ to the privacy of neighbours, it ‘unacceptably harms the character and appearance’ of the area, and therefore dismissed the appeal.

Related topics:

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice