Council blocks plan to turn well-known former Walsall menswear shop and offices into 21-bed hostel
Plans for well-known former clothes shop and saddle workshop are turned down amid concerns over smells from restaurant
Plans to turn a well-known former menswear shop and neighbouring offices into a 21-bedroom hostel have been turned down by council planners.
Walsall council refused permission to turn the former Duncan James shop in Mountrath Street into a house of multiple occupation (HMO).
For the latest planning applications and public notices in your area, visit the Public Notices Portal
Head of planning Adrian Harding said the scheme was refused amid concerns that smells from a neighbouring restaurant would make two buildings, previously used as a saddlery, unsuitable for such use.
Mr Harding also cited concerns about a lack of outdoor recreation space in the plans.
Isteni Property Holdings submitted plans to convert the former menswear building into an eight-bedroom hostel, with a further 13 bedrooms in the adjacent office block.
The Duncan James building dates back to the mid-19th century, when it belonged to Elijah Stanley, a wholesale saddler, harness and bridle cutter. By 1890 it was known as Victoria Works and in the early 20th century was occupied by J Blackwell, a leather goods manufacturer.
During the 1920s the J A Bednall tailoring company moved in, before it was later taken over by Duncan James in 1981.
A report by planning officer Rebecca Rowley said the building was recommended for inclusion in the Walsall local heritage list in 2022.
“Although this has not yet been formally adopted, the building is a rare survivor of a building type which would have been typical in this area in the 19th century, and its form, style and materials are in-keeping with the industrial character of neighbouring Little Newport Street and Bradford Lane,” she said.
“The building also is a relic of the historic layout of Mountrath Street which has been much altered by demolition on its western side where it is now a carpark. The rear of the property also retains an historic brick pathway, ‘Vicarage Passage’ which has an historic association with Vicarage Walk, a narrow road south of Vicarage Place, which maintains the form of a passageway that is discernible on maps from the 1840s and is likely to be an earlier routeway along a field boundary.”
A statement issued on behalf of the developer said the scheme would improve the appearance of a dilapidated building.
“HMOs in particular can help meet the needs of local populations, including younger professionals, key workers or single-person households seeking affordable, convenient, urban living,” it said.
“Well-managed HMOs can provide high-quality, affordable housing that meets modern standards for safety, comfort, and well-being.“
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.
