Green belt development approval overthrown by new Walsall Council committee ahead of appeal
It was approved by the council’s planning committee last year
Walsall Council will now oppose controversial plans to build two five-bedroom homes at appeal despite having an earlier approval.
The proposal to build two properties on Barr Lakes Lane was approved by the council’s planning committee in June last year.
Planning officers at the time recommended that the plans be refused after objections from five statutory consultees and 25 neighbours and interested parties.
At last year’s planning meeting the council’s principal solicitor warned members that approving the plans within the Great Barr Conservation Area would put the authority in a “vulnerable position”.
Members felt the green belt land was previously developed and could therefore be considered ‘grey belt’.
At the time, the protected zone boundary was under review, and members expected the site to fall outside the conservation area. However, the review has since concluded, with no changes to the boundaries.
Members were also of the view that passing bays could be created on Barr Lakes Lane to help overcome the issue of highways. However the applicant does not own the land required to carry out that work.
Following the approval applicant Shahzad Akram submitted additional information that has reduced the number of refusal reasons from seven down to four.
The four remaining reasons for refusal were inappropriate development in the green belt, harm to the open countryside, harm to the conservation area, and highways.
No decision notice was ever issued to Mr Akram and he eventually submitted an appeal to the planning inspector on the grounds of non-determination.
It meant that the application was again brought before planning committee members at a meeting on July 30 to ask whether they would have approved or refused the application had it not gone to appeal.


Many of the members have changed since the previous meeting due to the local elections and a reduction in committee members.
Speaking against the proposal on Thursday (July 30) was local resident Jenny Hulme on behalf of Robert Winkle for the Beacon Action Group.
She said the application was the “most nefarious” and described last year’s planning committee meeting as the “most irregular”.
Ms Hulme criticised members and said the decision to approve the plans “raised serious questions about the integrity of committee members”.
Both Councillor Aftab Nawaz and Councillor John Murray, members on both the previous and current planning committees, rejected the accusation and said the earlier decision was made “in good faith”.
Councillor Murray said at the time of last year’s meeting that he considered the site as previously developed, grey belt and an eyesore.
At the meeting on Thursday he said he could no longer support the application if there was ‘any indication’ that the site could be green belt.
Councillor Nawaz said he found it “inconceivable” that the site is not considered grey belt “at best”, when Walsall Council’s planning officers are designating agriculture fields between Pheasey and Streetly as grey belt in the Walsall Borough Local Plan.
Councillor Nawaz said he still considered the site to be previously developed and grey belt and moved that the plans be approved. No seconder came forward to support the move.
Councillor Rohan Beecha instead moved that the plans be refused in line with officers’ recommendation which members were in favour of.
He said: “We can’t ignore the fact that this proposed development is in the green belt. That alone is sufficient grounds to refuse the application. If we approve this we set a dangerous precedent for other developers.”
The council’s refusal will now go before a government planning inspector who will decide whether to approve or reject the plans.
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.