Unauthorised garden outbuilding in Walsall deferred by committee for a third time

Members voted in favour, for a third time, to defer the application for a later date

Plans to convert an outbuilding into a self-contained home have been deferred by the planning committee for a third time.

At a Walsall Council meeting on Thursday (October 1) members heard how applicant Mr S Ali built the property at the rear of 255 Birmingham Road three years ago without planning permission.

Since the outbuilding was created, it has been subjected to three enforcement cases, two of which were closed; one remains open.

Paddock Councillor Amrik Dhesy spoke against the application at the meeting.

He said it was “hard to convey” how much of a negative impact the development has had for residents living next to the access onto Brookhouse Road.

255 Birmingham Road, Walsallplaceholder image
255 Birmingham Road, Walsall | Photo: Google

Councillor Dhesy added that residents had reported couriers and takeaways being delivered to their doors looking for an address that “does not exist”.

Members heard how the homeowner had now blocked off the Brookhouse Road access and tenants only had use of the Birmingham Road entrance in response to neighbours’ complaints.

Also opposing was nearby resident Jay Hussain who said approving the plans would give permission for landlords to “build first and then resubmit applications until the council gives way”.

This application marks the second of its kind put forward by Mr Ali to try and get the building regularised.

Walsall Council’s planning officers recommended a refusal for the latest application for four reasons.

They found it did not integrate with the street scene, gave a poor outlook for occupiers, lack of amenity space and failed to meet biodiversity net gain requirements.

Former Streetly ward member Suky Samra spoke in favour of the application at the meeting and said all the reasons for refusal should be discounted.

He said poor street scene did not qualify as a reason for refusal as the dwelling could not be seen from Birmingham Road or Brookhouse Road and there was “more than adequate” amenity space.

He said the request for biodiversity net gain information was only provided last week.

During the meeting there was a dispute between officers and those representing the applicant about how much amenity space was available for residents.

For the five host flats and a separate dwelling, planning officers said 168 square metres were required, but only 142 square metres were available.

Representing the applicant, Faraz Ashad said there were “definitely” 157 square metres.

Mr Samra also said the development was covered by permitted development rights.

However, Walsall Council’s planning officers said that because the host building was five-self contained flats, the permitted rights did not apply.

Councillor Aftab Nawaz moved that the plans be approved on the grounds that they don’t negatively impact the street scene, that there was “sufficient” amenity space and that the biodiversity reason for refusal could be managed with a planning condition.

The motion was not seconded and Councillor John Murray said he struggled to support Councillor Nawaz because of the difference between the required amenity space and what was available.

He said: “It’s such a shame that the applicant didn’t come to this committee before. I’m sure, with the officers, they could have tweaked something to get a property there with all the correct rules applied to it. But instead you went and built it three years ago and now you’re trying to shoehorn it into the rules.”

Councillor Richard Tapper moved that the plans be deferred for another assessment to find out “what can be achieved”.

Members voted in favour, for a third time, to defer the application for a later date.

Related topics:

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice