The remarkable West Midlands police UFO sightings that still defy explanation
Triangular craft feature repeatedly throughout Roy Teague's research
For Inspector Roy Teague, it was never one spectacular encounter that changed his mind.
Instead, it was the sheer number of remarkably similar accounts given by serving and retired West Midlands police officers, many of whom had never met and whose sightings were separated by decades.
From a giant flying saucer over Burntwood in the late 1970s to unexplained objects above Birmingham Airport in 2014, Teague says the consistency between many of the reports is difficult to ignore.
One of the earliest accounts in Close Encounters of the Police Kind comes from Sergeant Robert Pritchard.
As a young boy growing up in Burntwood during the summer of 1978 or 1979, he watched what he described as a huge metallic saucer, around 45 to 50 metres in diameter, silently skim over rooftops before rapidly climbing hundreds of feet into the air. His mother and neighbour also witnessed the object as it glided away over a nearby school. More than four decades later, Pritchard, now a serving West Midlands Police sergeant, says he still has no explanation for what he saw.
Triangular craft feature repeatedly throughout Teague's research.
Former PC Stephen Favill described watching three brilliant lights over Sedgley Beacon during the mid-1980s before they accelerated vertically out of sight within seconds. He believes the lights were attached to a triangular craft unlike anything known to aviation.
Around 15 years later, serving officer Deborah Douthwaite reported seeing a large black triangular object hovering silently above a community building in Bushbury while driving along Kempthorne Avenue. She estimates she observed the craft for around 10 seconds before it disappeared.
For Teague, those reports form part of what he jokingly calls the "Dudley Dorito" – a series of black triangle sightings reported across the Black Country and wider West Midlands.


Perhaps the best-known case involves former Inspector Gary Nock.
In December 2011, just weeks before retiring from West Midlands Police, Nock stopped his car near the Badger's Sett pub on the Hagley Causeway after noticing unusual lights over nearby fields.
He says he watched a huge black triangular craft, which he estimated to be at least half the length of a football pitch, glide silently across the sky at low level before disappearing towards Bromsgrove. Concerned about the professional consequences of revealing his occupation, Nock initially contacted the Express & Star but identified himself only as a property developer. He has only recently disclosed that he was, in fact, a serving police inspector.


Not every sighting involved triangles.
In April 2010, PC Garry McHugh and colleague PC Robert Williams were guarding a property following a disorder in Birmingham when members of the crowd suddenly pointed skywards.
Everyone present, including both officers, watched what McHugh described as a silver, J-shaped metallic object moving slowly against the wind. The incident was reported to the force control room, Birmingham Airport was contacted and other officers were sent to try to follow the object, but no explanation was ever found. McHugh believes the unexpected appearance of the object even helped calm what had been a volatile situation.
One of the most unusual accounts came from an anonymous officer working within West Midlands Police's Counter Terrorism Unit in 2014.
From an office overlooking Birmingham Airport, the officer spotted what was described as a black, tic-tac-shaped object hovering in the distance. Colleagues, police staff and security personnel also observed the object, while enquiries were made with Birmingham Airport and the force control room. Despite concerns that it could pose a risk to aircraft or represent hostile reconnaissance, no explanation was identified and the object remained visible for several hours before darkness fell.
Teague is careful not to claim these accounts prove extra-terrestrial life.
Instead, he says they demonstrate that trained police officers have, for decades, encountered aerial phenomena they were unable to identify despite applying the observational skills demanded by their profession.
Whether those sightings ultimately prove to be advanced military technology, rare atmospheric phenomena or something far more extraordinary remains a matter of debate.
For Teague, however, they represent something he believes deserves investigation rather than ridicule.
"I don't say I know what these objects are," he said. "What I do say is that some of these officers have described things that, after extensive investigation, I simply cannot explain."
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.