Analysis

Reform cleans up in the West Midlands - but the big test is yet to come

Reform has done astonishingly well at the local elections in the West Midlands. But Mark Andrews says the hardest test is yet to come

The fact that Reform has done well in the council elections is little surprise, but the results have surpassed most expectations.

Most people expected Reform would make considerable gains in these elections, you only have to look at the opinion polls for that. What is astonishing, though, is the ruthless efficiency with which they have swept away strongholds that have been held by the traditional parties for generations.

When we spoke to people on the streets of the West Midlands during the run-up to this election, people invariably expressed distaste for the traditional parties, and said they would be voting Reform. But as any seasoned analyst will tell you, saying they will vote for an insurgent opposition party and actually doing it are two very different things.

Turnout is usually pitiful in local elections, and all too often the disgruntled protesters stay at home. But not this time, with high turnouts proving that public anger is more than just talk.

The result in Sandwell is truly astonishing. Labour has controlled the borough for 51 of its 52 years, with elections often seeming little more than a formality. Now leader-elect Ray Nock, who spent years languishing as an opposition Tory councillor before losing his seat in 2012, finds himself in a position he could never have envisaged back then.

Ray Nock will now play a vital role in determining whether Nigel Farage makes it to Downing Streetplaceholder image
Ray Nock will now play a vital role in determining whether Nigel Farage makes it to Downing Street | Express & Star

In Walsall too, veteran council leader Mike Bird, who seems to have reigned over Walsall for a generation, was unceremoniously dethroned in his own back yard. That’s a slight exaggeration - he has actually been leader for 17 of the past 34 years - but the spells when he was out of office always seemed like a temporary interregnum. Will the comeback king return? It seems unlikely, but you would be brave to rule it out.

Mike Birdplaceholder image
Mike Bird | Tim Thursfield/Iconic Media Group

A near-clean sweep in Dudley leaves the council in a state of deadlock. The Tories remain the largest party, but well short of a majority, with Reform breathing down their necks. Tory leader Patrick Harley, who has been in charge for eight of the past 10 years, said he would be prepared to talk to anyone, including Reform. But former Tory MP Marco Longhi, now a Reform councillor talks about being a “noisy opposition” - those do not sound like the words of a man about to do a deal.

The irony in Dudley is that Labour, which now occupies a distant third place, could yet hold the whip hand by deciding who runs the council. Expect group leader Adam Aston to drive a hard bargain.

Wolverhampton Council’s Labour leader Stephen Simkins only needed to hold two seats to retain control of the council, and will probably be relieved to have held six, although he may not relish facing ex-Labour councillor Celia Hibbert - now leader of the Reform principal opposition - in the council chamber. Reform is now the largest party in Cannock Chase too, and it will be interesting to see what deal is struck at the annual meeting.

Nigel Farage can be forgiven for toasting the results with an ale or two, after all results like this do not come along very often. But he is doubtless aware that landslide wins can be a double-edged sword.

Up until now, he has been successful in pitching the party as an anti-establishment, insurgent movement, but not any more. Reform is now at the heart of the political establishment, and the party will now face scrutiny like never before. How Sandwell and Walsall councils fare, along with others across the country, could yet decide whether Mr Farage makes it to No. 10.

No pressure there, then.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice