'Why hapless Tory MPs have well and truly shot themselves in the foot' – Andy Richardson

The Tories consider themselves the most sophisticated electorate in the world.

placeholder image

It’s odd, therefore, that they managed to get rid of the two candidates who had the best chance of taking on Sir Keir Starmer and his band of football ticket-grabbing, P&O-Ferry-lambasting brethren.

The last election demonstrated unequivocably that elections are won from the centre ground. While Sir Keir cleverly parked his tanks on the Tory lawn, the Tories foolishly tried to take on Nigel Farage (again) and succeeded only in damaging their own prospects of success.

And having run an election to find a replacement for the defeated Rishi Sunak, they’ve shown us that they’ve learned none of the lessons of that brutal defeat. While Robert Jenrick has made himself the pawn of his party’s right-wing, and while Kemi Badenoch’s natural home is the hard right, they’ve given themselves every chance of another electoral defeat.

Rejecting the credible Tom Tugendhat wasn’t a particular surprise. The MP for Tonbridge who was elected in 2015 was likeable and as a centrist would have taken the fight to the Lid Dems and Labour, which is where the next election will be won or lost.

James Cleverly, a figure with considerable experience, might not be the most remarkable Parliamentarian to have graced Westminster. Yet he won the Tory Party Conference, just as David Cameron had, some years earlier. His reward for inspiring the masses was to be rejected by MPs, presumably those who thought he was safely into the final two, and lent their votes to another candidate. That’s right – the most sophisticated electorate in the world, ensuring the favourite lost.

Not that Cleverley should be too downcast. It’s highly improbable that either Jenrick or Badenoch will lead their party to success – and the bookies are most likely offering decent odds of them being replaced before we reach the next General Election.

As both Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak found, there’s hope in the face of defeat and it may well be that Cleverley’s narrow exclusion from the final two is a blessing in disguise. He doesn’t have to take on the poisoned chalice of leadership at a time when the Tories are so far behind in the polls that they appear to be living in a different country.

The result is a huge boost for the Labour Party, which has endured an unspectacular start to its term in office. Transport Secretary Louise Haigh has lost the party of growth an estimated £1 billion in investment by having a go at the owners of P&O Ferries, who were so incensed that they decided to take their ball home and play with it in their own back garden. P&O’s parent company, DP World, postponed announcing a major £1bn port investment in the UK, in the light of the remarks.

It's the latest challenge to Sir Keir, a leader who’s admitted facing choppy days during his first three months as Prime Minister.

The man who wants to promote growth, restore living standards, and restore our ailing NHS is now £1 billion down, thanks to his foot-in-mouth minister, whose personal views might have been better being kept to herself.

Yet for all of the challenges and all of the upheaval of recent years – Covid, Brexit, Cost of Living crisis, Boris Johnson, and Liz Truss – Britain remains a remarkably stable nation, compared with others.

While the Far Right is on the march across Europe and while populists are winning elections around the world, Britain has become an unlikely entrant in the book called: ‘How To Run A Country’.

Sir Keir is proving himself to be an effective leader who maintains party discipline and has a very human outlook. While Boris Johnson was buying £800 rolls of wallpaper, the Labour leader is more interested in getting five or ten minutes with his kids, after school. While Rishi Sunak appeared to be addicted to travelling by helicopter, Sir Keir thinks it’s odd that his flat above the shop is full of armed police. Which, of course, it is.

It’s even odder for the Tories to have gone for a sure-fire election loser, though Labour made that mistake with Corbyn – and that became the turning point that led them back to power.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice