This is how the West Midlands Mayoral election will probably play out - and it's not how you think

Based on national polling and sentiment about the Conservative Party, Andy Street should be headed for a massive defeat in this week's West Midlands Mayoral Election, but that won't be how it plays out, and one poll might just explain why.

placeholder image

According to a report and poll by More In Common, the West Midlands Combined Authority Mayoral Elections will be very much neck and neck between incumbent Andy Street and Labour challenger Richard Parker.

If regional voting behaviours mirrored national sentiment, Andy Street would be heading for a painful drubbing in his second re-election bid this week. But that's not what this poll says will happen.

Instead, with the electorate increasingly voting differently in local elections to how they vote nationally, this poll finds Mr Street dramatically outperforming the Conservative national average and he finds himself in a "statistical dead heat" with Labour's Mr Parker.

The six candidates who attended the Express & Star's hustings event (clockwise from top left: Andy Street, Richard Parker, Elaine Williams, Akhmed Yakoob, Sunny Virk and Siobhan Harper-Nunes).placeholder image
The six candidates who attended the Express & Star's hustings event (clockwise from top left: Andy Street, Richard Parker, Elaine Williams, Akhmed Yakoob, Sunny Virk and Siobhan Harper-Nunes).

More In Common's West Midlands analysis said: "In our focus group of voters in the West Midlands, attitudes to Street were undoubtedly more positive than those of almost any other politician we have spoken to voters about in recent years.

"There was genuine recognition of his work for the area from the Metro tram extensions to the Commonwealth Games.

"Voters liked the fact that Street acted as a national champion for the West Midlands, that he wasn’t seen as overly partisan (or even a Conservative), and crucially that he did what he promised to do."

Below is a bar chart published by More In Common detailing the results of their latest poll.

West Midlands Mayoral Voting Intention (Graphic: More In Common).placeholder image
West Midlands Mayoral Voting Intention (Graphic: More In Common).

The conclusion, therefore, is that this week's mayoral election will be decided by two major factors:

  • Has Andy Street got a a strong enough personal brand to "overcome Tory toxicity" and Rishi Sunak's abysmal personal ratings?
  • Can Labour squeeze the Green vote or can the Conservatives squeeze the Reform UK vote sufficiently to win?

This incredibly interesting analysis also touches on demographics, claiming: "Andy Street leads Parker among over-55 year-olds, but Parker is ahead among younger voters. Andy Street also enjoys a lead among women, leading by 44 per cent to Parker’s 35 per cent."

Turn-out, then, may play somewhat of a deciding role.

The report added: "Street is managing to keep this race close because unlike the Conservatives nationally he is holding on to most of those who voted Conservative in 2019.

"80 per cent of those who voted Tory in 2019 are backing Andy Street, with only 10 per cent intending to vote for Reform’s Elaine Williams."

Nationally, there are fears among Conservatives that Reform UK would steal a good chunk of their votes, but it doesn't look like that's going to happen in a major way in the West Midlands.

According to the analysis, reducing crime, tackling anti-social behaviour and improving local transport links are among the key issues, with things like housebuilding and improving the state of local high streets also on voters' minds.

It has to be said that this poll and analysis relies on a focus group from Solihull, which is traditionally seen as more wealthy and Conservative that many other areas of the region, meaning it might be argued that people are generally more likely to be pro Andy Street, but that it speculation.

The race is very obviously between Richard Parker and Andy Street - Labour and Conservative. The Conservative outlook is more positive than on the national stage, but Labour are neck and neck as we approach the finish line.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice