Policy to reduce Staffordshire council costs could be increasing carbon emissions

A policy aimed at reducing council expenditure could be driving up carbon emissions.

A policy aimed at reducing council expenditure could be driving up carbon emissions. A long running report has been presented to council leaders on the impact of charging residents for emptying garden waste.

In 2024, East Staffordshire Borough Council announced that it was implementing a charge for residents to get their garden waste emptied. A subscription-based, opt-in service was introduced at £40 per calendar year, or £35 for those subscribing early.

The scrutiny climate change and environment committee at East Staffordshire Borough Council concluded its 22-month report, which recommends that the council look to introduce a banding scheme instead of the current flat charge.

Burton Town Hall Where East Staffordshire Borough Council Meetings Take Place. Photo by Staffordshire LDR Kerry Ashdown. Free for use by all BBC news wire partnersplaceholder image
Burton Town Hall Where East Staffordshire Borough Council Meetings Take Place. Photo by Staffordshire LDR Kerry Ashdown. Free for use by all BBC news wire partners

The report suggested that if all non-subscribing households were to drive to a household recycling centre, emissions would increase by 4,529.2 kg CO2, the equivalent of charging 366,171 phones a year.

Committee chairman Councillor Michael Slater told council leaders: “We identified possible causes of increases in greenhouse gas emissions by this policy. We considered that there will be more flytipping, which would involve extra vehicles to collect the flytipping and general pollution.

“We considered that people may undertake more burning of compost domestically and also the black bins might be contaminated with green waste. We also considered that people may decide rather than subscribe to the scheme, drive to a waste site themselves and produce more car journeys and therefore more emissions.

“We thought, maybe if we could increase the number of people subscribing to the scheme if we had a different measure of charging for it like a banded subscription scheme. We also considered that people should be encouraged to do more composting.”

Despite fears when the charge was originally introduced over an increase in flytipping, the report states there is “no statistical difference” in rates. Similarly, compared with data from other councils there is little impact on the amount of waste being collected by the council

He added: “The committee would like to be involved in any further review of the brown bin service that you might be thinking of doing. We think there should be a corporate target of the information given to the public on what material goes into what bin. Additionally, a corporate target on converting unused brown bins into water butts or into a compost bin would help people with our other recommendation to encourage people to compost more.”

Deputy council leader, Councillor Dennis Fletcher, said: “We are going to note the recommendations, that means they can be further considered by the cabinet and by officers going forward. There is a lot to think about.”

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice