Plans for 5G mast in Birmingham given the green light despite concerns

The 20-metre mast is set to be located at land opposite 101 Walsall Road in the Sutton Four Oaks area, near numerous homes and The Crown pub.

Plans to erect a 5G mast in a Birmingham neighbourhood have been given the green light despite concerns it could be “intrusive” for nearby homes.

The 20-metre mast is set to be located at land opposite 101 Walsall Road in the Sutton Four Oaks area, near numerous homes and The Crown pub.

The city council has said the mast will provide the latest 4G and 5G technologies and stressed there is a  “specific requirement” for coverage at this location.

But the plans attracted backlash, with Sutton Town Council arguing that “locating a 20m high pole at such an exposed location […] would result in an adverse visual impact for neighbouring properties”.

They continued the proposal by Jet Infrastructure Ltd would not be supported and suggested an alternative location should be found.

Similar fears over the mast possibly being an “overbearing feature beside a public footpath” were raised in other letters of objection

Sutton Four Oaks councillor Raaj Shamji, spoke about residents’ concerns at a recent planning meeting and previously argued the mast would appear “visually dominant and out of keeping with the surrounding low-rise residential character”.

Cllr Martin Brooks, chair of the planning committee, acknowledged the concerns at the meeting, saying:  “This is indeed a difficult one.

“It’s difficult to argue that a 20m mast is not somewhat intrusive of people living very close by.”

But he went on to compare the proposed mast to similar infrastructure, continuing: “It may not be perfect but I think the single 20m pole is a great advantage to what it could be.

“I understand residents’ concerns but access to digital services [is] really important in terms of the future of the city.

Cllr Gareth Moore also acknowledged the divisive nature of the proposal, saying: “We need more 5G, we need to invest in technology.

“But I understand these masts are controversial in themselves.”

He added that he was concerned about the grass verge at the site being ‘cluttered’ and ‘unsightly’.

Cllr Manni Butt said: “If we want to improve the digital infrastructure in our city, I think we should be supporting it.”

The committee ultimately voted to let the installation of the mast to go ahead.

Benefits ‘outweigh limited harm’

In a report, a council officer acknowledged that the proposal would be visible by pedestrians and motorists along Walsall Road.

“There are various street structures within the proximity of the site, including a bus shelter, signs, lamp posts and other telecoms equipment,” they wrote. “As such, the proposed development would not appear as incongruous or as an isolated structure within this street scene.”

They continued that the proposed infrastructure would be above the height of the surrounding buildings and trees to provide “clear sightlines and greater coverage”.

“As a consequence, screening can only be achieved to a certain degree,” the report accepted.

“The site would be partially screened from the view by the row of existing highway trees, so the visual intrusion of the mast would be reduced.”

It continued that national policies advise that “significant weight” should be placed on the need to support economic growth and productivity.

“The need of such development (which includes social and economic benefits) should be weighed on balance, against any detrimental visual impact they may cause on Birmingham’s environment,” the report said.

It also suggested that mature trees that line the road, around 13m in height, provide a “substantial visual buffer” between the site and nearby homes.

“The distance separation, combined with the tree coverage, is considered sufficient,” it said. “The proposal would not therefore harm the outlook from those properties or impact on residential amenity.”

On why this particular location was chosen, the council officer said the applicant considered 40 alternative locations within the search area.

“Some of the locations were discounted due to those alternative locations being more prominent in terms of the proximity to the residential properties,” they said. “Other alternative sites were discounted due to being close to more sensitive locations.

“Other sites were discounted due to the height of the trees that would impact on the coverage and not providing the level of coverage required.”

They continued the application site was chosen as the “least harmful option” in terms of its proximity to nearby homes.

“This location was chosen by the applicant because it offered the best option that would provide the most effective coverage, while not impacting greatly upon the amenity of the wider residential area,” they said.

The council officer concluded that the proposal’s benefits and the absence of a more suitable alternative site “outweighs the limited harm”.

Related topics:

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice