Mayor told to 'come clean over cronyism claims' as £35,000-a-year post given to ex-Sandwell Council leader

Tories accuse mayor Richard Parker of trying to avoid scrutiny as controversial appointment suspended

A senior Wolverhampton councillor has challenged regional mayor Richard Parker to “come clean” amid claims of cronyism surrounding the decision to appoint a Labour Party colleague to a £34,655-a-year ‘commissioner’ role.

Last week Mr Parker, elected mayor for the West Midlands, suspended the appointment of Kerrie Carmichael as the first ‘mayoral commissioner’ after questions were raised about the appointment process.

Richard Parkerplaceholder image
Richard Parker | Photo: West Midlands Combined Authority

Mrs Carmichael had been leader of Sandwell Council until Labour lost control of the authority at May’s local elections.

The process behind the decision was ‘called in’ by West Midlands Combined Authority’s scrutiny committee, and was due to have been examined at a meeting on Monday (September 7).

But shortly before the meeting, the committee was informed that the mayor had suspended the appointment to call his own review, and the item was pulled from the agenda.

Councillor Simon Bennett, leader of the Conservative group on Wolverhampton Council, accused the mayor of trying to avoid scrutiny, and said questions about the appointment would not go away.

Councillor Simon Bennettplaceholder image
Councillor Simon Bennett | Photo: Wolverhampton Council

But a spokesman for the combined authority said the committee would still get the chance to question the mayor at a later date.

He stressed that the review related to the recruitment process, and in no way reflected on Mrs Carmichael’s ability or suitability for the post.

Councillor Bennett said: “This is simply not good enough. A legitimate decision was taken to call in this appointment and subject it to proper democratic scrutiny. Now, at the last minute, that hearing has been called off.

“The mayor cannot expect difficult questions about his decisions to disappear.

“If mistakes have been made in the appointment process, the mayor should come before scrutiny, admit what went wrong and explain himself.

“Instead, we are left with more questions than answers about an appointment that has already attracted concerns over potential cronyism.

“With further mayoral commissioners expected to be appointed, this is an extremely poor start. If the mayor cannot get the process right for his first commissioner, residents are entitled to ask what confidence they can have in the appointments that follow."

Suzanne Webbplaceholder image
Suzanne Webb

Suzanne Webb, former MP for Stourbridge, also criticised the decision.

“People across the West Midlands deserve openness and transparency from their mayor, not important scrutiny being called off when difficult questions need answering,” she said.

“The mayor must come clean about what has happened, explain why this appointment has reached this point and make sure it is subjected to proper scrutiny.

“No mayor should be above scrutiny. The rules and processes exist for a reason, and mayor Parker must follow them and come to the table and answer important questions."

A spokesman for the combined authority said the mayor had asked for a review of the appointment process.

“As a result it was not appropriate to continue with the scrutiny committee agenda item,” he said.

“The committee will be given the opportunity to scrutinise the proposed appointment of the commissioner in full once this process is completed.

“The issues under review relate to final stages of the authority’s application process rather than the merits of the individual concerned – it reflects in no way on their suitability, capability or integrity.

“There will be no further comment from the West Midlands Combined Authority until this is concluded.”

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice