Local elections: Could Dudley be about to experience a 'blue bin' election?

Could the ‘blue bin’ controversy leave Dudley Council in a state of deadlock?

When the people of Dudley last went to the polls two years ago, the borough was one of the few bright spots for the beleaguered Conservatives.

When Sir Keir Starmer chose the town for the national launch of his local election campaigns, the future prime minister unashamedly had the borough in his sites. If Labour could win in Dudley, it would put provide the party with a springboard for the impending General Election.

Sir Keir, of course, soon found himself in Downing Street, as his resurgent Labour Party sentenced the Tories to their heaviest defeat in history. But his pitch for control of Dudley Council was less successful. While the Conservatives haemorrhaged support across the country, their vote in Dudley proved surprisingly resilient - even snatching the traditional Labour stronghold of Castle & Priory ward, a result which would have once been unthinkable.

Dudley Council leader Councillor Patrick Harleyplaceholder image
Dudley Council leader Councillor Patrick Harley | Local Library

While Labour made enough gains to tie with the Conservatives in the council chamber, a deal was done with the opposition parties which would see them remain in charge. And if Labour could not win then, when the entire country appeared to be against the Tories, when would they ever win?

It turned out to be just the beginning of a torrid time for the party which, through a string of resignations, defections and a by-election defeat managed to lose almost a third of its councillors. Group leader Pete Lowe quit the party, and went on to lead the breakaway Black Country Party, leaving Councillor Adam Aston - appointed leader by the Labour hierarchy - in charge of a depleted rump of 24 councillors.

Like Mike Bird in Walsall, long-serving Tory leader Patrick Harley is nothing if not a survivor, but he nevertheless faces a significant challenge in his bid to retain control. In his favour, he goes into the election with 25 seats in the bank, and Labour is defending 10 seats compared to the Tories’ eight. For Labour to take overall control, it would need to win 22 of the 25 seats being contested, which seems unlikely given the opinion polls. By contrast, the Tories only need four gains to secure a majority, with the party fighting to retake its traditional heartlands of Sedgley and Pedmore & Stourbridge East.

Since 2024 the Liberal Democrats, led by Ryan Priest, have held the balance of powerplaceholder image
Since 2024 the Liberal Democrats, led by Ryan Priest, have held the balance of power | Local Library

Two obstacles stand in Councillor Harley’s way, both of them blue. One is Reform UK’s turquoise revolution, which could yet take thousands of votes from both Labour and the Conservatives. The other is the controversy over the blue-bin recycling scheme, which has left thousands of residents tearing their hair out since its launch last month.

With regards to the latter, Councillor Harley says the council is a victim of its own success: while neighbouring authorities have completley failed to meet government instructions to provide weekly food waste collections and simplified recycling services, Dudley not only launched them within a week of the deadline date, but also managed to collect double the national average amount of recycling. But the bigger-than-expected take-up, coupled with difficulties of training new operatives, have left the council playing catch-up from the start. Bins have regularly been emptied late and, in the month before an election, the timing could scarcely have been worse.

Rita Collett is unhappy with the new bin collectionsplaceholder image
Rita Collett is unhappy with the new bin collections | Local Library

Rita Collett, from Grange Road, close to the town centre, needs no prompting when it comes to identifying her main bugbear when approached in Dudley market place.

“One thing I’m finding very awkward at the moment is the new bin collections, it’s an absolute shambles, collecting the blue bin,” she says.

“Last week, I left the bin out over two days, and the black one, and they’ve never collected, so I brought it back in. So on Sunday morning, early morning, they collected them.

“I gather that some areas haven’t had any of the blue bins collected, it’s absolute chaos. They tell you to put them out, they ask you not to leave them out, and for days they’re not collecting them, so what are you supposed to do?”

She is undecided on how she will vote.

“I don’t think there’s much difference between any of them,” says.

“I’ve voted different ways at different times, it depends what I think’s right for Dudley.

“They all promise this and that, but you know very well that when it comes to it, it’s not going to happen.”

Former Labour group leader Peter Lowe quit to set up the Black Country Partyplaceholder image
Former Labour group leader Peter Lowe quit to set up the Black Country Party | Local Library

Beverly Davies, 79, from Coseley, has voted in every election since she turned 21.

Like many people, she begins by voicing her anger towards the Government about ‘the state of the country, the economy, immigration’.

“It’s frightening really, for a person of my age,” she says.

But when pressed on what local issues she is unhappy with, she replies: “The roads, the potholes - and the bin collections.”

Referring to the new recycling scheme, she says: “It’s all new, and we’re getting to grips with it as a household, and I think the council have tried to sort it out, making it easier.”

Does she think the council is doing a good job?

“No.”

Beverly Davies, 79, from Coseley, feels her area is forgottenplaceholder image
Beverly Davies, 79, from Coseley, feels her area is forgotten | Local Library

She feels that Coseley, on the fringe of the borough and close to the boundaries with Wolverhampton and Sandwell, is often something of a forgotten area, a ‘no man’s land’.

“Nobody bothers with us in Coseley East, I don’t think they care about the community, there are only certain parts of the community that they really care about, and others get really neglected.

“They care about Stourbridge way, compared to Dudley and Coseley, and the surrounding area here.”

Beverly is determined to make her vote count, but has not yet decided which way she will go.

“I keep swinging one way and another,” she says.

“There’s some I like, some I don’t and some I’m disgusted with.

“I’m towards Reform I think, I’ve got no faith in Labour or Conservative, none at all.

Councillor Damian Corfield with Dudley Council's new recycling bin and caddies for food wasteplaceholder image
Councillor Damian Corfield with Dudley Council's new recycling bin and caddies for food waste | Dudley Council

Helen Morris, 53, from Netherton, says she will be voting Reform, to voice her unhappiness with Labour.

But Dudley Council is Conservative run?

“I don’t think they’re doing anything for us,” she says.

“Bills seem to be going up, and services going down.”

She cannot pinpoint anything specific she is unhappy about, but feels a sense of dissatisfaction.

“I think in general they seem to have had their day,” she says.

“Reform seem to be a bit more for the people.”

Steve Weaver is torn between Labour and the Conservativesplaceholder image
Steve Weaver is torn between Labour and the Conservatives | Local Library

Steve Weaver voted Labour in the ‘all up’ election two years ago, but this time he is undecided.

“Conservative or Labour, I don’t know,” he says.

“They need to sort the holes in the road out.”

Ex Tories Marco Longhi and Shaun Keasey are now standing for Reformplaceholder image
Ex Tories Marco Longhi and Shaun Keasey are now standing for Reform | LDRS

Councillor Harley will take comfort from the fact that the council got it’s ‘all out’ election out of the way two years ago. Reform, bolstered by the defection of ex Tory MP Marco Longhi, and ex Tory councillors Jason Thorne and Shaun Keasey - the latter who was elected last time as an independent - is predicted to make considerable gains at the expense of both Labour and the Conservatives. For Labour, which could find itself squeezed in a pincer movement by Reform on the Right, and the breakaway Black Country Party on the Left, the threat could be even greater.

Councillor Adam Aston is leader of Dudley Labour groupplaceholder image
Councillor Adam Aston is leader of Dudley Labour group | LDRS

With only a third of the seats up for election this time, it is impossible for Reform to seize control of the council. And, barring a total wipeout, the chances are Councillor Harley will still be leading the largest party on the council come May 8.

However, if Reform does as well as some polls suggest, the council could yet find itself in a state of gridlock. With bad blood clearly existing between some senior Conservative and Reform figures, the prospect of any deal between the two parties looks problematic. If a situation arose where Reform held the balance of power, who - if anyone - would it side with? Keen students of politics will recall how a short-lived deal between Ukip and Labour saw the latter briefly take charge of the council about 10 years ago. Could a similar deal be struck between present Labour leader Adam Aston and Reform? It seems unlikely, but somebody is going to have to lead the council.

The Tories have run Dudley for eight of the past 10 years - but it may well be the negotiations that take place after the election which determine whether that continues.

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice