Dudley Council hit with damning report - full list of findings
The report follows a value for money (VFM) investigation by independent consultants Grant Thornton.
Dudley Council has been hit with a damning report from auditors who found officers under pressure and weak governance.
The report follows a value for money (VFM) investigation by independent consultants Grant Thornton who looked into property deals between 2021 and 2024, including the failed sale of the former leisure centre on Wellington Road in Dudley.
The report concluded the authority at the time was beset with ‘significant weaknesses in governance or control arrangements’ however no evidence of fraud, bribery, or wrongdoing was uncovered.
On the role of officers and elected members, Grant Tornton’s report said: “Senior elected members, particularly the council leader, were directly involved in operational property transactions in ways that went beyond strategic oversight.
“In our view, this blurred role boundaries, created pressure on officers and weakened the control environment.”
The report goes on to say officers also experienced pressure from colleagues which pointed to senior councillors influencing how officers applied professional judgement.
Officers also experienced ‘undue pressure’ from the council leader which led to a risk of departure from due process and to comply with the leader’s wishes rather than apply independent judgement.
On the sale of properties, the report said: “Disposal controls were inconsistently applied. Marketing and approval processes were shortened or bypassed, decisions were poorly documented and public announcements were made before transactions were contractually secure.”
Data protection was also an issue; in one incident an officer sent a spreadsheet containing sensitive health data from 178 people to the council leader’s personal email address despite the leader requesting only a cumulative figure, not individual data.
Grant Thornton said: “Our GDPR specialist concluded that, given the volume and sensitivity of the data involved, the incident would likely meet the threshold for notification to the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO). We disagreed with the council’s assessment on this point.”
Also on sale of buildings, the investigation found inconsistency and a failure to show a clear, well-documented decision making process.
The report said: “Although all disposals within the scope of this review were ultimately found to be legally compliant, in at least one case the council relied on retrospective justification and was not always able to demonstrate compliance through a clear and transparent audit trail.”
The council also fell short on anti-corruption safeguards, the investigation concluded: “No evidence of corruption was identified.
“In our opinion, however, preventative anti-corruption arrangements were not sufficiently robust, were not consistently applied and did not adequately address the risk of actual or perceived impropriety — particularly during property disposals, which are inherently high-risk activities.”
In a lengthy response to the report, Dudley Council chief executive, Balvinder Heran, said: “The council has taken substantial action to address the weaknesses identified in the Grant Thornton report.
“Grant Thornton will test the revised governance arrangements as part of its 2025/26 VFM audit work and report its findings to the Audit Committee.
“In the meantime, the council welcomes Grant Thornton’s recommendation that it obtains its own independent assurance through internal audit or other means.”
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.