Decision on plan to turn former DIY shop in Willenhall into 12-bedroom HMO
Fears were raised about the direct line of view from two bedroom windows into the Classic Academy of Dance opposite
Plans for a 12-bedroom house of multiple occupation (HMO) in a former Willenhall DIY shop have been refused by members of Walsall Council’s planning committee.
Plans to convert 116-118 Lower Lichfield Street, the former Roy Birch’s hardware shop, had originally been recommended for approval by planning officers.


But on June 18, members turned it down on the grounds of oversaturation of HMOs in the town already, the effect on community cohesion and the surrounding character of the area.
Councillors heard how a petition against the plans was signed by nearly 900 people with fears over parking provision and waste storage.
Willenhall ward member Councillor Simran Cheema, who launched the petition, spoke against the plans at the committee meeting last week.
She raised issues of community safety, anti-social behaviour and lack of adequate parking for the facility.
In addition, fears were raised about the direct line of view from two bedroom windows of the HMO into the Classic Academy of Dance opposite.
Councillor Cheema said a representative from the dance school informed her it would have to close down if the application was approved.
Walsall Council said it is the responsibility of the academy to put appropriate safeguarding measures in place but since it is in a locally listed building, frosted windows would not be “desirable”.
It proposed to mitigate the line of sight at source by adding glazed windows in the two bedrooms.
Councillor John Murray said the glazing would be pointless as any tenant in the HMO could just open the window.
Speaking in favour of the proposal was the building’s owner Dr Matha. He said creating the HMO was a project in memory of his daughter who recently died.
Dr Matha said he was not a “typical property developer” and wanted to support people who are less fortunate in the area.
Several members were erring on the side of refusal but feared it would simply be overturned by the planning inspector, resulting in large financial costs for the Walsall taxpayer.
Planning officers said committee members could approve the plans but include a condition that the window looking into the dance school could be fixed shut.
But members voted in favour to refuse the plans altogether on the grounds of oversaturation of HMOs, the effect on community cohesion and the surrounding character of the area.
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.