Convicted PC had 'no justification' for assaulting woman says police watchdog boss

PC Calum Brand was convicted of assaulting a West Midlands mother

A senior director at the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) said a West Midlands Police officer had no justification for grabbing and elbowing a mother in the face when he was helping to arrest her partner.

PC Calum Brand, aged 26, was found guilty of assaulting Sophie Meese when he lost his temper after she hit him in the back as she tried to interrupt officers who were escorting handcuffed Adam Manson down a stairwell at flats in Cradley on June 16 last year.

The office denied pulling her hair and elbowing her, but was convicted this week following a trial of one count of assault by beating at Nottingham Magistrates Court after video footage of the incident was played to the court.

Nottingham Magistrates Courtplaceholder image
Nottingham Magistrates Court

Following the incident the IOPC launched an independent investigation following a mandatory conduct referral by West Midlands Police lodged on July 4, 2025.

Speaking after the hearing the IOPC’s engagement director Derrick Campbell said: “This was a challenging situation for the officers. The man was clearly drunk, largely incoherent, and there was a struggle in the stairwell.

“The woman tried to intervene, and PC Brand’s response was disproportionate and unnecessary. There was no justification for the level of force he used and no attempt to de-escalate the situation. The woman did not pose a genuine threat to PC Brand and, to that point, had not shown any aggression towards the officers.

“The woman suffered facial injuries at the hands of an officer who should have been there to help protect and safeguard her.

Lloyd House, West Midlands Police headquarters in Birminghamplaceholder image
Lloyd House, West Midlands Police headquarters in Birmingham

“Our investigation also concluded that PC Brand had a case to answer for gross misconduct. Now that criminal matters have concluded, it will be for West Midlands Police to hold a misconduct hearing at the earliest opportunity.”

The watchdog said its investigators examined video footage, took statements from officers, interviewed PC Brand, of Lea Street, Kidderminster, and reviewed relevant force training, policies and police guidance. A file of evidence was then given to the Crown Prosecution Service and prosecutors authorised the force to charge the officer with assault by beating.

District Judge Katy Rafter described Brand’s actions as “wholly unnecessary disproportionate” and “excessive” for the situation. She said she found the victim's explanation in court of what happened clear and credible.

Brand, a former prison officer, will be sentenced in September. He was granted bail until then.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice