Food review: Brilliant food in idyllic setting at The Bracebridge, Sutton Park
He was on TV. Andy Sheridan, the Michelin-star-chasing, TV-show-starring cook who’s dazzled at restaurants around the UK, was whipping up a storm on BBC TV’s Great British Menu.


Which was funny, because he was also in the kitchen of The Bracebridge, a delightfully refurbished, fabulously glamorous restaurant in Royal Sutton Coldfield. Funny that.
Perhaps the guy in the kitchen was an apparition, though, judging by the quality of our food, he couldn’t have been. So maybe they film these TV shows months in advance, keep the results a secret, and then let us all imagine there’s audiovisual magic, as well as that of the culinary kind.
Either way, the chef who made his name at 8, in Birmingham, was very definitely present and correct. No AI. No hologram. Just a hard-working chef, sleeves rolled up, cooking at the refurbished Bracebridge, a restaurant that has been much loved over the years.
So, to the history part. The Bracebridge has long been part of the region’s rich, culinary history. Located in an idyllic lakeside spot, in Sutton Park, it’s the sort of space that looks as though it’s from picture perfect Cornwall, or the Lake District.


With an outdoor eating area for use in spring and summer, with a snack bar for pizzas, cakes, cookies, and coffee, called Sip and Slice, it serves as a pitstop for walkers and locals, as well as a slightly-posh-but-not-at-all-formal place for dining.
It’s the sort of place that people will eat at semi-regularly, rather than one where they’ll save and visit once a year, for a special occasion.
It’s not gunning for the sort of lofty accolades that some of Sheridan’s other restaurants seek. – though a Michelin Bib Gourmand might not be entirely out of the question. The pub closed unexpectedly at the end of last year and was rescued quickly by a consortium of local businesspeople, along with Sheridan and his business partners, Sam and Emma Morgan. With the collective knowledge, experience, and investment to breathe new life into it, it was relaunched a week or two ago – with bookings going through the roof.
And it’s easy to see why that is so. The Bracebridge has a real community-feel about it. It’s very much the destination of choice for those in Sutton Park, Four Oaks, and their hinterland, who don’t fancy the schlep into Birmingham. It’s equally desirable for those living in Walsall, Lichfield, and surrounding towns, who want to eat something every-so-slightly fancy in magnificent surrounds.
The new team have clearly spent well on refurbishing the venue. Décor that had started to look tired has been given a sophisticated make-over, while the kitchen purrs to the sound of expensive new toys as Sheridan and his team inject new life into tried and tested classics.
The menu is a mix of pub classics done well – it’s as though they’ve taken a leaf out of Tom Kerridge’s not-inconsiderable recipe book, when designing the menu – along with elevated, Sheridan-esque specials.
So there’s a giant prawn toast with a silky Marie Rose sauce, a Welsh rarebit with apple ketchup, or a hand-dived scallop with tikka sauce and coriander, to start. Mains feature an epic burger with tomato jam, a beer-battered, line-caught fish and chips with mushy peas, curry sauce, and chips, or a Wiltshire truffle gnocchi with mushroom, cream and thyme.
There’s an epic offering for Sunday lunch while a grill menu features a spiced monkfish tail with curried cauliflower cream sauce, a roasted Welsh dairy cow steak with ox cheek macaroni cheese – yes, ox cheek macaroni cheese – or a soy caramel Middle White pork chop with jasmine rice and pork mince. And who doesn’t want to eat all of those? I booked a table with a friend during the venue’s first week.


And though that’s traditionally the worst time to visit – we all know the drill, the builders have just left, the staff haven’t been trained, and people are finding their feet – under Sheridan’s guidance, The Bracebridge felt like a much-travelled classic.
There were none of the problems associated with new venues – a consequence, presumably, of a good recruitment policy, with an impressively reassuring blend of youth and experience waiting tables.


The main man was in the kitchen, too, flipping burgers and making the region’s poshest fish finger sandwich, rather than topping A5 wagyu beef with N25 caviar at his other restaurants – lucky diners.
We began with three starters – well, it would have been rude not to, given the calibre of the guy in the kitchen. A prawn toast was like the poshest Chinese takeaway of all time, with salty-sweet prawns, crunchy, moreish toast, and an indulgent, creamy sauce. Mushroom parfait was exceptional. Earthy, umami-rich, and intense, it was neatly paired with a little lightly pickled dressing, to cut through the richness, along with hunks of exceptional bread.
A Welsh rarebit was a work of beauty. Comforting, indulgent, and the sort of at-home classic that guests know and love, it kind of typified what the Bracebridge is all about – stuff people like to eat, done remarkably well by a Grade A chef. The mains were wonderful. A Wiltshire truffle gnocchi was intense, nicely seasoned, and served with a dreamy, mushroom cream sauce.


A colossal burger – or, as I like to call it, STATEMENT BURGER – was somewhere near epic. Towering higher than the BT Tower, it featured great ingredients, a balance between savoury, sweet, pickle, and cheesey, and left a lasting impression.
The best of all was a colossal pork chop, in a soy caramel. There’s everything to be said about using sensational ingredients and treating them with respect, which sums up the artistry on the plate. Wow. And a little bit more wow. Desserts were spectacular.
A Great British Menu rice pudding was dreamy and light – and, funnily enough, the chef was on GBM the same evening. Who knew? Perhaps he rides a fast car. A saffron trifle was epic, the sort of dish you’d imagine the Queen might have liked, when she was knocking around Buckingham Palace.


The Bracebridge is one of the region’s best-loved, most-spectacularly-sited restaurants. Under the leadership of Andy Sheridan, and with his cohort of local backers, it’s back with a bang. Watch it fly.
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.