Birmingham gambling venue plan approved - despite 'risk' warning from councillors
Plans for gambling venue approved as Birmingham councillors warned over 'risk.
Plans to convert a shop into an ‘adult gaming centre’ have been backed by councillors despite fears of an ‘over-concentration’ in the area.
Proposals were seeking permission for a convenience store at 15 Watford Road in Cotteridge to become a gambling premises, which has proposed operating hours of 24 hours, seven days a week.
But the application triggered dozens of objections, including one from Birmingham Selly Oak MP Al Carns.
According to a council report, he raised concerns the plans could have a “negative impact upon the character of the area” with fears raised over anti-social behaviour.
The Labour MP also reportedly said there is a similar business on Cotteridge High Street and therefore “no justification for a second enterprise”.


Cllr Roxanne Green (Bournville and Cotteridge) also took issue with the plans and argued they could lead to an “over-concentration of gambling establishments” in the suburb.
“The primary shopping area in Cotteridge local centre already has three gambling establishments within 0.1 miles,” Cllr Green for the Green Party said at a planning meeting this week.
“A fourth gambling centre […] is clearly an overconcentration.
“I constantly hear from residents about the way the local centre has declined and how it’s steadily losing its amenities.
“Another adult gaming centre is the last thing the community wants or needs. We must protect the remaining retail units.”
Andrew Woods, representing the applicants, told the planning committee that the application was made by a “family business [who] know the area very well”.
He endorsed the conclusions made by the council officer, who wrote prior to the meeting that the proposal was “acceptable subject to conditions”.
Responding to the concerns raised, the officer suggested the main source of noise and disturbance arising from the adult gaming centre would be from customers’ coming and goings.
“It is reasonable to expect that this would not result in noise nuisance as this is commonly seen within a busy district centre where the background noise is high,” they wrote in the report.
Their report also noted that West Midlands Police said there was “nothing to suggest at this stage” that the change of use would lead to an increase in crime or anti-social behaviour.
“I appreciate gambling is not everybody’s cup of tea,” Mr Woods said. “But in terms of planning considerations and policy, your officer sets out clearly why this application can be granted.”
But concerns over the proposals persisted at the meeting, with Cllr Joe Peacock (Green, Billesley) saying: “Four [gambling establishments] within 0.1 miles – how can that not be an over-concentration?
“I just don’t understand how we can not stand up against that kind of thing.”
Cllr Duncan Ali (Green, Balsall Heath West) added: “I looked at [national policy] which has a whole section entitled ‘promoting healthy communities.
“I was very perplexed as to how this might be seen as promoting a healthy community.
“Excessive gambling creates problems, financial difficulties, stress, family breakdown.”
Cllr Gareth Moore (Conservative, Erdington) said the number of gambling establishments in his own ward and the impact on the high street there was a “real concern”.
But he pointed out appeals were successful for a number of similar applications after initially being refused, adding: “Planning history is definitely against us.”
“I personally don’t see that there are planning grounds in terms of opposing this,” Cllr Martin Brooks, chair of the planning committee, added.
“We take as a risk as a committee, not only of losing an appeal but possibly having costs awarded against us.
“That’s cost to the council that could have been spent on other things – we do need to be really careful.”
The planning committee ultimately voted to approve temporary planning permission for a period of 12 months.
‘The loss of a shop is regrettable’
In their report, the council officer clarified that such premises would be subject to a separate licensing regime.
This would need to demonstrate how the use would be operated in a manner that would address concerns around matters such as anti-social behaviour, criminal behaviour and drug taking.
“It is not the role of the planning system to regulate these matters,” the report said.
“In the absence of substantive evident showing a direct correlation between the proposed use and anti-social behaviour and/or an increase in crime, it is considered that on balance a reason for refusal could not be sustained.”
It did acknowledge that there are already a number of existing gambling outlets within Cotteridge neighbourhood centre – including a betting shop/casino in the adjoining premises to the application site.
But it continued that the proposal would be compliant with certain policies within the Birmingham Development Plan.
“The proposal would be located within an existing commercial unit in a designated neighbourhood centre and its primary shopping frontage.” they went on to say.
“[These] are considered to be the most favourable and sustainable locations in planning policy for a range of commercial uses.
“The loss of a retail shop is regrettable but ultimately the proposal would not erode the retail core of Cotteridge neighbourhood centre to a degree where fewer than 50 per cent of the units would not be in retail use.
“Furthermore, the existing retail shop operates with 24 hour, seven day a week opening and so the proposed adult gaming centre operation is considered acceptable, especially given that WM Police Service support the application.”
They added: “The proposal […] has no unacceptable impacts on design and appearance, neighbouring amenity and highway safety.”
For the latest planning applications and public notices in your area, visit the Public Notices Portal.
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.
