Birmingham Council defends plans to slash affordable housing target

The council has had a target of 35 per cent affordable housing on all schemes over 15 homes in recent years but that may be about to change

The deputy leader of Birmingham Council has defended plans to lower an affordable housing target after concerns were raised by a coalition of organisations.

The council has had a target of 35 per cent affordable housing on all schemes over 15 homes in recent years – but that may be about to change.

The council’s draft Local Plan – a major vision for the city’s future over the next two decades – suggests this target could be dropped to 20 to 25 per cent for brownfield sites.

With thousands of people on Birmingham’s housing waiting list, a coalition of groups has this week called on the council – now led by a minority administration including the Lib Dems and Greens – to rethink this proposed change.

This alliance includes ACORN Community Union, Birmingham Fair Housing Campaign, Save Smallbrook Queensway and resident groups in Ladywood and Druids Heath, both areas where major regeneration schemes are planned.

“The coalition has raised particular concerns around Birmingham City Council’s plan to lower the affordable housing threshold from 35 to 20 per cent in core areas across the city,” a statement from the groups said.

“We argue that the plan does not provide sufficient evidence or safeguards to demonstrate that the proposed lowering of the affordable housing threshold will result in the delivery of social housing provision needed to meet Birmingham’s pressing housing needs.”

They added: “Without a change in direction, the coalition believes the plan risks failing to address Birmingham’s housing crisis.”

Green councillor Julien Pritchard, deputy leader of the council, responded to such concerns by saying the previous 35 per cent threshold was rarely hit due to the national “developer-led” planning system.

Against this backdrop, he said this previous figure had been a “target in name only” in the past.

“Councils like Birmingham are unlikely to get high targets for affordable homes in Local Plans because the national planning system is too tilted in favour of developers,” he argued.

“The Labour Government’s incoming changes skews the planning system even more in favour of developers in the future.

“The Government urgently needs to take a different approach to development, and produce a planning system which prioritises genuinely affordable housing over developer profits.”

Birmingham councillor Julien Pritchard, who represents Druids Heathplaceholder image
Birmingham councillor Julien Pritchard, who represents Druids Heath | Photo: Alexander Brock/LDRS

“Few, if any, planning approvals for developments in Birmingham ever hit [the 35 per cent target].” he continued.

“Developers should not be able to back out of their commitments on affordable housing.”

Councillor Pritchard went on to say that the new Local Plan is part of “ensuring that more affordable housing is actually built in Birmingham”.

“The council administration, and Green councillors in particular, will continue to work to deliver as much genuinely affordable social housing as possible, in whatever ways we can.

“The draft new Local Plan includes a new specific social housing target within the affordable housing target and our new council administration is working to increase the number of social and council homes built in the city.”

‘Realistic, deliverable targets’

A spokesperson for Birmingham City Council said the aim of the proposed target change is “not to reduce the council’s ambition for affordable housing”.

“It is to create a policy framework that delivers more affordable homes in practice,” they said.

“The proposed approach is based on independent viability evidence and is intended to provide realistic, deliverable targets across different parts of the city.

“The council remains committed to increasing the supply of affordable housing and will continue working with developers, registered providers and other partners to maximise affordable housing delivery wherever viable.”

They added: “The new draft policy includes stronger review mechanisms and ‘catches’ more application types than the previous policy.

“The change in approach is focused on increasing the delivery on sites and in schemes.”

The Government has previously said it has acted with “ambition and urgency” to tackle the housing crisis in England, an endeavour which has included a “bold overhaul” of the planning system.

It is introducing a number of changes in a bid to streamline the planning process and speed up the delivery of homes.

“The government is more focused than ever on building the homes our country needs and delivering good growth in every postcode,” it said recently.

Speaking to the BBC last month, Housing Secretary Angela Rayner said the Government was “making a difference” through investing billions in social and affordable homes.

At the Labour Party Conference earlier this week, Prime Minister Andy Burnham also said that the Labour Government will increase public control of housing.

In particular, Labour has said it will back councils with the “powers and resources necessary to call time on rogue landlords” and compulsory purchase properties that fall below acceptable standards.

“Not only will this directly improve the condition of long-neglected properties, it will bring more homes into council ownership,” the party said.

“Labour will also strengthen council powers to take over empty homes and rent them out cheaply to families.

“And Labour will complete reform of Right to Buy, to ensure it doesn’t come at the expense of the public housing stock.”

Comment Guidelines

Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.

Local news you can trust
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice