‘Battery farm’ HMO in Smethwick allowed after council overruled
Sandwell Council’s planning committee rejected a move to open the 11-bed house of multiple occupation (HMO) above Viney’s Opticians in Smethwick High Street last year.
A controversial move to build a new HMO branded a ‘battery farm’ that would add to a town’s ‘rat problem’ will be allowed to go ahead despite being rejected by a council.
Sandwell Council’s planning committee rejected a move to open the 11-bed house of multiple occupation (HMO) above Viney’s Opticians in Smethwick High Street last year amid a warning that allowing the shared accommodation was turning parts of the borough into slums.
Residents and local councillors said Smethwick High Street was already suffering from overflowing bins, fly-tipping, rats and other vermin and blocked drains from several takeaways along the busy route.
Despite the rejection, the HMO will still be allowed to go ahead after the decision was overruled by a government planning inspector.
The planning inspector said the HMO would provide “suitable living conditions” despite not having a communal living area.
The building’s two shared kitchens would count as the main living space, the inspectors report said, and would still fall below the minimum space standard.
But the inspector said this was acceptable as the HMO’s bedrooms were above the required ten square metre size.
The report said the council had refused the HMO over inadequate bin storage but did not provide any evidence of relevant planning policies during the appeal.
The plans were scaled down from initial proposals for a 20-bed HMO but were condemned by neighbours in Victoria Avenue, a small row of houses behind the Smethwick shops, who said the HMO would make “everything 100 times worse.”
Local councillor Ragih Muflihi said there were “massive issues with rodents” due to littering and overflowing bins from nearby takeaways and Victoria Avenue had been plagued by fly-tipping.
Cllr Bob Piper, who at the time represented the nearby Abbey ward, said he was “appalled and shocked” the council had recommended approving the application.
He said the influx of HMOs, many of which had been approved by government planning inspectors against the wishes of Sandwell Council, were turning the borough’s high streets into slums.
“We wouldn’t put battery hens in places like this,” he said at the planning meeting last November. “There’s no common space, there’s nothing.
“The space available for storing waste is little bigger than a cupboard… it is appalling. “We’re turning our high streets into slums… If you drive on to places as far as Bearwood, you’ll see, it’s turning into a slum.”
Comment Guidelines
Iconic Media encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.