Agree with what you have said. I was saddened to see people clambering over the gates at Villa Park last night. I fully understand that certain fans are raging over the possible appointment, but the scenes last night, however incensed the fans may have been, did not paint Villa in a good light. Protest by all means, but do it with some class. As for McLeish, i can’t say he would be my favourite for the job, but if he does come then i will still be going to Villa and giving them my support. I feel this whole episode has been blown out of all proportion, by Media and blogs, and when the dust settles perhaps we can go back to what really matters…the football.

Report abuse

Two points. Firstly, yes we were all delighted when the charismatic, little Irishman came to our beloved club. We played with a belief in ourselves, got some great results and had some quality players come to the club. However, the wheels started coming off after the 3rd season with player revolts, a spiralling wage-bill and unattractive football. You say McLeish is similar to O’Neil, so why is it hypocritical not wanting a carbon copy appointment when we have already been down that path. Houllier, for all his faults, was getting there with an attractive passing game and some skilful players, who were comfortable in possession. McLeish is a backwards step regarding Villa employing a playing style which most fans crave.

Secondly, you say our only choice is to support him if appointed. I’d still like to know why we should offer that support when the club are not supporting us with this appointment? I think we have made ourselves pretty clear that this appointment is totally unacceptable to Villa supporters far and wide for a number of reasons, including his poor record and his past history. You say that our lack of support will create a self-fulfilling prophecy but are we really the ones who will have started it? Will it not be the owner and board of AVFC that have set this turn of events in motion? I will always support my club and I am sure this is what Lerner and Faulkner are counting on as Claret and Blue is in my blood. But I do not have to like it and I do not have to display tacit approval to a decision which has created a schism between the supporters and owner of our great club. UTV

Report abuse

sorry bad spelling ,sensible

Report abuse

Maybe i should mind my own, but from the outside looking in i think villa are making a shambles of this manager business!
From the minute they appointed Houllier i wondered why! then he gets ill! astonishingly you had nowt in his contract to prevent him walking away with all that money, after his health problems previously i find that mad! but even when he was taken ill you should have surely realised he may not return therefore planning for a new manager! but you just seem to be in panick mode!
I think a little arrogance was used with martinez! dont think randy believed he would say NO not alot of people did! then this! Its so obvious you have tapped him Mcleish up or why would he quit?
Buy why your club wants him is beyond me!
Blues have spent a fortune under him & play some of the dulliest football i have witnessed in prem! his record in scotland is impressive yes but thats championship level at best!
This appointment (if it happens) is another example of how out of touch clubs are with there fans! getting a average manager in is one thing but taking him from your bitter rivals in my eyes is a insult! but clubs dont seem to care!

Report abuse

Are the Villa fans a little bit thick? Alex Mcleish is no more a blues fan than I am a, god help me, Liverpool fan!! He went to Birmingham to do a job of work because they paid him to do it. Ok I can understand the fact that he managed to get relegated but they won a trophy more than Arsenal have done in the last 6 years and look at price tag on their squad!! Anyway just to castigate someone who, let us not forget, is actually SCOTTISH not a Brummie is quite frankly pathetic. At the momment boys an girls he’s the best yer gonna get cus Randy aint gonna give a top manager the purse, Raffa proved that, so get over it an be gratefull yer still in the Premier League!! Rant over Thank you.

Report abuse

I am sure everything will work out, you have to admire the size of his melons to cross the divide, and for the immediate pressure he will be under. He must be very confident.

Give him a chance I know I will

Until death do us part villa forever

Report abuse

I’ll tell you what the board are thinkin shall I they’re thinkin who’s the best we can get in that isn’t going to ask for a 50 mill purse. Why didn’t Martinez go to Villa? Ok he is Wigan through an through but you aint tellin me that if Man U Chelsea or even Spurs had come in for him he would still be at Wigan No sir!! So if martinez thought he could have done better at Villa he would have gone. Randy is Learning from Peter coates at Stoke who refuses to bow down to the managers and players if it comes to it who want to spend more than they earn. I feel that you will find more an more clubs who were once like the Villa a top 6 club not willing to break the bank. Randy hasn’t got where he is today by blowing his stash on over rated an over paid managers an players. Raffa’s got some pedigree and if Randy really wanted to go for it he would have given him the 60 Mill he wanted, however not even that amount of cash can guarantee top 6 footie. The villa will be another middle of the table club for a while yet an hey whats wrong with that!! Don get me wrong I’d luv t see Stoke in the top 6 but It aint gonna happen Not with the new breed of Multi billionaires around an i’m afraid Randy just aint in that league.

Report abuse

I’m a life long Villa fan but I’m prepared to give Alex Mcleish a chance.

Statisically speaking he has a better win/lose percentage that most other managers available or willing to come to Villa Park.

I do think however that Villa need to rethink/revamp it’s lines of communication with it’s fans. In this age of social media
better,more frequent and more frank information would go a long way to keep the faithful on-side. The General might be a close and trustest friend of Randy Lerner but someone at Villa Park needs to fill the information gap, and stop the “fog of war”.

Report abuse

i wish people would get off mccleishs back and give this guy a chance yes he got regalted but he won carling cup and got them into europe its more then villa have done in past few seasons. and protest moan all u like but it wont stop him becoming manager will it? people should get behind team and manager instead of doom and gloom stuff. as im sick ofhearing it, when they got regelted first time it wasnt his side it was steve bruces side so fans should get the facts straight, and get bewhind manager it shouldnt be about him being ex blues boss it should be wether hes good enough for job.

Report abuse

This is a wonderful, positive article. Most articles just add fuel by showing negative remarks and talking about how the club is supposedly in trouble. And by the way, to all those out there who think MON could have done better, think again. Our club’s financial losses are all a result of his reign. He never believed in the club’s youth policy; just wanted to keep buying and buying. He burned a hole in Mr. Lerner’s pockets. Look at what might have happened if we had held on to Cahill. Sold him for 5m and now, he’s going for 17m+. We could have done wonders with a defender like him.

Report abuse

Hi I’m a Wolves fan & I can’t believe what’s happening at Villa Park. Randy Learner has been very badly advised if he goes after McLeish.

Why not go for Mad [Square Pegs in Round Holes] Mick…? He has a better record than McLeish & I along with many other Wolves fans would drive him to Villa Park myself..!

Martin O’Neil or Mark Hughes for Wolves…!

Report abuse

MATT

Are you any relation to Kevin ???? .

Report abuse

It was an interesting recruitment. I’m sure that Randy has assessed how best to position the Villa in the future.

Could he see Villa as being a dependable addition to the top 4 sides. The investment required to just ease into it and then stay there is probably outside his reach. Can you get into the top six……maybe, but it’s becoming increasingly difficult. A cup run in the Carling and FA Cups and then into Europe via the back door after being beaten in the final…..very possible. Eck certainly has the pedigree to get to at least the quarter finals in both competitions.

Eck has certainly the eye for a solid defender that he will sell to at a higher price. He certainly is able to develop the work ethic and a never say die spirit to the team (apart from our collapse against Liverpool away, which certainly helped to send us down). he did it with Rangers, Hibs and Scotland too. So maybe if you keep hold of your better players (Young (oops), Albrighton and Downing) then maybe, but maybe not.

Ok I support the Blues, but unlike many I’m still know that Villains are also Brummies, which means that a bit of friendly banter is all that is required. We’ll all miss the derbies and lets hope that we get back up as soon as possible. Best of luck, just not as much as we hopefully get.

Report abuse