Time to map out a plan for Villa's future
- Says blogger Matthew Turvey
Chris Hutchings had to leave Walsall
Wednesday 5th January 2011, 9:10AM GMT.
Walsall blogger Mark Jones reflects the mood of Saddlers fans everywhere as the club move on to a new era without manager Chris Hutchings.
Just as we had all given up hope of some decisive action from Walsall Football Club, they go and surprise everyone by sacking manager Chris Hutchings, assistant Martin O’Connor and Hutch’s mate, chief scout David Hamilton.
I could be critical for the sake of it and say it was long overdue but in reality I’m just relieved. Credit must go to chief executive Stefan Gamble for responding to the numerous e-mails that were fired off to him by angry and anxious fans on Monday night.
To give some context to how things came to a head over the weekend, here are some of the things I originally wrote in the wake of the Notts County and Peterborough debacles.
Having not been to football for weeks there were loads of things that I’d forgotten, or at least put to the back of my mind, about the beautiful game, mainly just how poor the current Walsall side can be.
It took until around 3:09pm on New Year’s Day for the Saddlers to jog my memory.
For those that weren’t there for the Notts County game at the Banks’s Stadium, this is how it went: -
The first goal was a one-on-one chance as a direct result of Steve Jones losing a 50-50ish ball in the middle of the park which was just plain sloppy. Our defence stood around waving their hands in the air like nursery kids asking to go to the toilet as Craig Westcarr ran clear. His shot appeared to go through a hole in goalkeeper Jonny Brain’s chest.
The second goal was truly shocking, a disgrace of a goal to concede. Lee Miller scored with the easiest of free headers. The County striker wouldn’t have had as much time unchallenged to pick his spot if he was practising heading in a training session.
The third goal was a near-post header from a corner that went through our reserve goalkeeper’s hands. Just as the corner was being taken, my 12-year-old son pointed out that we had no-one on the near post. If a 12-year-old can see the basics not being done properly, why can’t those whose job it actually is see it too?
County had plenty of other chances, often cutting through us with consummate ease. They had been just six points ahead of us at the start of play, so the game should actually have been a six-pointer.
In reality, they were in a different league to us – next season they probably will be. To call us amateurish would be an insult to amateur football.
Against Peterborough we were better – although we couldn’t have been much worse.
Taking the lead gave everyone a faint hope of a repeat of the unlikely win at Charlton and we had chances, but deep down you knew it wasn’t going to happen.
The second-half deterioration, complete with more comedy set-piece defending, was depressingly predictable.
We all know about the financial restrictions and limitations that any Walsall manager has to contend with, but what I don’t understand is how we can be so underprepared, badly organised and lacking in fight.
Those of us still turning up every week are for the most part questioning our sanity right now. Someone has to take responsibility for this dross.
Thankfully, as mentioned above, somebody did and thankfully acted on it.
For me, it became clear months ago that Hutchings wasn’t capable of turning things round.
To be fair to him, when he arrived two years ago this month it was an improvement on Jimmy Mullen, but that wasn’t exactly saying much. Last season we did OK finishing 10th and I had hoped we could build on that, but last summer saw more dismantling than anything.
The squad has never seemed balanced, there are no obvious leaders, loan signings have been patchy and performances starting off as poor then becoming increasingly inept. The mistakes of the last two games were typical of pretty much the whole season.
As things continued to decline, Hutch’s reactions became ever more comical and, in some cases, downright bizarre. It was becoming embarrassing and, while the personal abuse he received was distasteful and not to be condoned, he just had to go.
It was sad to see his assistant Martin O’Connor depart. We will never know if he was actually part of the problem or whether things would have been different for him under a different boss.
But it was typical of the man that pretty much the last act in the job was to get sent to the stands for disputing a blatantly offside goal. Even though the game was clearly up, it still mattered to him.
You could never question Mart’s passion for the club, to me he still is and always will be a Walsall legend. I hope he bounces back and I wish him all the best for the future.
As for Hamilton, it was hard to see what contribution he actually made, he certainly never impressed at the Meet the Manager evenings.
When asked about his best signing, he talked about bringing Jimmy Bullard to moneybags Wigan, because that must have been a real hard one to spot, mustn’t it?
Maybe some of the current crop of players he recommended will do better under a different regime.
A clue to the where things might have gone wrong came in the players’ farewell comments on Twitter, many of them praising how nice the management team were.
I’m not sure that ‘nice’ is necessarily an adjective I particularly want to see in a manager – Sir Alex doesn’t win any popularity contests, Ray Graydon, Chris Nicholl and Richard Money were all hard men and even Alan Buckley could rant with the best of them.
The next step of course is to get the right man for the job and anyone who can emulate the achievements of those I’ve just mentioned will do.
The club has haemorrhaged support over the past three years since the Scott Dann transfer and Richard Money’s departure as manager, while many fans have been put off by the continual poor performances being served up this season.
In my opinion, five of the last six appointments have turned out to be failures, so we really can’t afford another one.
The right noises are coming from the club about the season not being over and relegation not being a certainty.
On Monday evening I’d have laughed at them, now there is a slight glimmer.
A happy New Year at last for us Saddlers.
Latest Blog — Microsoft Comes to the University of Wolverhampton
Last week Microsoft visited the University of Wolverhampton to give students the chance to develop their own phone apps that could be published on the Windows Phone Marketplace.
Technology blog
Business Awards
Read the full story here
Full coverage of awards celebrating the region's best businesses.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
LIVE traffic updates
Road, rail and airport - latest
Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new E&S app
Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.

I’d agree that 5 out of the last 6 managers have been failures.
Out of Merson, Broadhurst, Money, Mullen, Hutchings, the fact that only Richard Money has gone on to (or will go on to) manage another fully professional club speaks volumes – Walsall F.C are not a charity, why should we employ managers who are not up to the job?
Report abuse
I hope that there are some good unemployed managers out there as Bonser will not employ anyone that is currently in a job. I am not sure Darren Ferguson would take the job as we are not a club with ambition to match Fergie jnr.
As much as I liked Kinsella as a player at Walsall, we need a proven manager, not another first team coach.
Come on Bonser, give us a real New Year present and bring in someone that can turn this season and the club around with the 2 shilling that you will give him to work with.
CH out
(ooops, he’s already gone, I was just so used to ending my comments with CH out that I typed it automatically).
Report abuse
I was there on Saturday vs Notts County, sitting about 10 feet away from Hutchings and O’Connor. It was embarrassing to see how bad we were – all 3 goals were a joke, especially the second where no Walsall defender was within 5 yards of the County centre-forward. It was obvious that we were being overrun in midfield: Lescott and Richards were being dominated and Steve Jones was as inept providing cover for Westlake as he was going forward. I got a good close-up of Julian Gray and I thought he deserved to be MOTM – he did try to put a shift in and showed some qulaity. I couldn’t believe that Hutchings took him off instead of Jones who did nothing all afternoon. And good riddance to Reuben Reid – all he did when he came on was moan – no way is he a Premiership player. Anyway, there is still hope but we need to get a new manager in pretty quickly and also get about 3 players on loan (a central midfielder, centre-forward and a left-back). I would also make Jimmy Walker player-coach and send Brain out on loan…and McGivern back to Man City.
Report abuse
Phil Burton says 5 out of our last six managers have been failures. Our last six managers were: Lee, Merson, Broadhurst, Money, Mullen and Hutchings.
Obviously four of them were total failures: Merson, Broadhurst, Mullen and Hutchings. But two were not failures.
Lee kept us in the Championship for three seasons and is one of the most successful managers in the history of the club since we won more matches at that level under Lee than under any other manager.
Money won promotion from the fourth level in his first season, so he was not a failure.
Report abuse
Patrick, I agree about Colin Lee. Lee did a great job keeping us in the Championship for 3 seasons – I don’t understand why some people have a go at him – don’t forget we were in touching distance of the play-offs in Lee’s final season until Bonser pulled the plug on a couple of decent loan signings. And as for Dicky Dosh – come back all is forgiven!
Report abuse
5 Saddlertd , Colin Lee could of ,i believe have kept this club a lot longer at championship level if he had had the financial support he was crying out for off his Chairman . I also believe Richard Money would of took this club higher had he had the backing of his Chairman ! The problem is the better you do in football the more the cost goes up , i.e player prices , players wages , ground developement e.t.c and our Chairman is happy just scimming off the cream at the level we’re at , why get more successful and have to pay out more ?
Report abuse
Lee received more financial support than any one else.
Tehre was never a chance of the paly offs as people state, six points off at christmas following a very good win at Cardiff City means that we are par to finish 12 points off them at the end.
There was no need to bring in players at this point, no extra prize money for finishing higher up the championship, so why the need?
But this team that wasn’t far away in the minds of so many blinkered individuals fell away terribly. The performance at Gillingham was worse than aything under Hutchings or Broadhurst and relegation was a nailed on certainty despite a glut of massively expensive loan signings that took the club to the brink financially.
This was the only true point that Bonser has backed a manager and probably haas clouded his judgement ever since.
Lee left the club in a far worse position then when he found it, he started going backwards since Dave Merrington left…oh to have him as manager.
Report abuse