Walsall’s cup tie will tell fans a lot
Thursday 25th November 2010, 9:10AM GMT.
Walsall blogger Mark Jones believes Saturday’s FA Cup tie at Torquay will be the real acid test of what is ahead in 2011 for the Saddlers.
So it looks as though the corner we turned last Saturday has only taken us back into another dead end.
After the much-publicised clear the air meeting last week, the lads rolled their sleeves up, took note of the DVDs and against Carlisle, in the second-half at least, produced a gutsy battling performance to earn the win.
It was the kind of performance that has been sadly lacking for most of this season, but one which will need to be repeated on a regular basis between now and the final day of the campaign on May 7.
Just as I wasn’t about to get too carried away about Saturday, neither am I too despondent about Tuesday’s Sheffield Wednesday result.
I didn’t expect us to get anything up there anyway mainly because, however much it hurts to admit it, the current Saddlers team will get beat at places like Hillsborough.
We did create a few chances, ironically after Jonathan Macken – theoretically the player who should carry our biggest goal threat – had gone off injured.
The real reason why we are bottom of the league and seven points – well eight if you look at the goal difference – from safety is not an unflattering scoreline against one of the excommunicated big boys, but the mistakes that have been made ever since last season ended.
And the problems are still there – an imbalanced squad, mystifying tactics, formations that keep chopping and changing bizarrely combined with an almost obstinate refusal to change what is blatantly not working.
Goalkeeper Jimmy Walker kept non-league Fleetwood at bay in the first round of the FA Cup and he may have to do the same again at Torquay to prevent another humiliating cup exit.
I don’t want to jinx things, but defender Andy Butler has looked a good acquisition too.
But, just as things look like they are improving slightly at the back, there is now apparently a ‘crisis’ up front.
Given that our forwards have managed just one goal in the last seven league games, I’ll say so what’s new?
How we’ve managed to get to the end of November with a ludicrously under strength midfield is another thing I can’t quite work out.
Yes, Matt Richards takes a mean free kick but unless he can notch every game, which he clearly can’t, then I can’t see what makes him a permanent fixture in the team.
He seems to be as undropable as manager Chris Hutchings is unsackable.
The outcome of the Torquay tie will give us a much clearer idea of what’s in store for the club in 2011.
Better get those sleeves rolled up boys.
Latest Blog — A week is a long time in football
This time last week we were staring down the barrel, third from bottom with a worse record than at the same stage last year, writes Saddlers blogger Mark Jones.
Saddlers Blog
Business Awards
Book a Business Awards table
Join our celebrations of the region's best in business on Thursday March 22 - book your table now
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
entertainment
All the film reviews
Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases
OUR NEW APP
Get the new E&S app
Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.

We will have a far better idea of how good this batch of players are when we get shoot of the clueless guy we have in as manager.
The sooner CH goes the sooner we will be in a situation to due how good this squad of player are….
Report abuse
Thought that was a good read until I read the last bit. Like it or not, Richards has been out best midfielder this season – the only midfielder we have in fact who will make himself available to receive the ball before passing to feet. If we go the rest of the season relying on Marshall and Taundry to provide our creative spark, we might as well give up now.
Report abuse
How many times until jeff and his so called board goes we are doomed who really cares a cup run or how well the team plays as soon enough you all wont have a club to support
Report abuse
Why have a pop at Richards??
I can think of many other players in our squad who get games that are far worse than Richards.
Need your head looking at…
Report abuse
No matter how much effort or running you put in to a match if you have no talent like some of the WAlsall players dont have for this level u will get beat week in week out with the odd win now and again..
Report abuse
“WFC_Rob
Like it or not, Richards has been out best midfielder this season – the only midfielder we have in fact who will make himself available to receive the ball before passing to feet. If we go the rest of the season relying on Marshall and Taundry to provide our creative spark, we might as well give up now.”
“sheldinho
Why have a pop at Richards??
I can think of many other players in our squad who get games that are far worse than Richards.
Need your head looking at…”
Unfortunately you are both right; there are worse players than Richards and that sums up the problem. Sure he has makes himself available to receive the ball, but his work when he doesn’t have the ball is non-existent with the result that teams tear through us. The fact that he deserves his place doesn’t mean he is good; rather that the other options are sadly worse.
Hutch Out Now!
Report abuse
Not the best blog MJ. Have you sold out and become a WFC board voicebox? No criticism of the manager, no request for JB, RW or SG to comment on the situation or the reasons why Hutchings has not been sacked.
Or, are you like the rest of us and accepted that our plea for action is going unheard of by the board.
Bookings now being taken for the trip to AFC Wimbledon next season.
CH out
Report abuse
Macken went off after 26 minutes injured? He has been out recently too, so obviously desperate to rush him back and paid the penalty!
Report abuse