Is time running out for Alex McLeish?

Friday 9th December 2011, 7:29AM GMT.

Is time running out for Alex McLeish?

Villa Park has been somewhat of a jumble of emotions in recent weeks, writes Aston Villa blogger Matt Turvey.

At present, from the fan perspective at least, there have been a lot of unresolved problems at the club. Fans will name the issues as the board and the manager. Most of the time, it seems the players evade the blame.

I say most of the time, because Stiliyan Petrov got it in the neck this week from a large portion of people for some quotes that were about Liverpool. Stan was a fan as a kid, and said as much in an interview with Match magazine. I’m sure you all remember Match – it was like Shoot! magazine when we were kids, and had a lot of good stories.

Regarding Petrov though, the fact that it was written for a kids magazine, talking about what kids dream of when they are kids. Target audience and all that. The rest of it was taken out of context as Stan was quick to confirm. The media hey, who can trust them? PS Yes I obviously understand how contradictory that sounds given I write for a media outlet.

Anyway, getting back to this blame game that is ping-ponging around B6 at present, I have to say that it is pretty upsetting to watch. Many seem so entrenched in their position that they don’t much care what happens.

The worst thing here is that fans are going against fans. I honestly don’t care what the board think, but I care what fans think. What distinguishes Villa as a passion of mine is the fellow supporter rather than money men. If football is dying due to money, then turn off the corporate sponsorship life support and give us back the game. Not that it will ever happen of course.

So, in the eyes of us fans, the season may have been poor so far, but to see people flying against each other just because they disagree, it is a real shame. If fans are going to be like that against fellow fans, just how fragmented does Aston Villa look to the rest of the world?

Don’t get me wrong, I have my opinion. Often my opinion is different to others. Nothing wrong with that. We’re never going to agree on everything. It just might be easier if things weren’t so vitriolic between fans.

The anger that is showing is understandable. Nobody wants to see the club doing badly, and nobody wants to pay for football that appears to be poor quality or poor value. These are all valid reasons to be upset and frustrated. It’s just the same for me – I don’t see visits to Villa Park as good value anymore either.

So I understand why people at the club are seen as problems, whether they are board members, players, or the manager. Nobody is beyond criticism.

I personally still have a faint glimmer of hope for the manager, especially after both Dunne and Albrighton came out admitting that the effort being asked for wasn’t being provided by the team, that the long balls were borne of frustration by players rather than McLeish’s direction. Detractors have suggested such an announcement is a clever board ploy to deflect the blame from Alex McLeish. Me personally, I think it is a sign that quite a few players need to realise they should earn their money each week.

All that aside, the fact remains that things must change, and soon. In a month where chances may be few and far between given a series of high profile matches, the chance to secure some kind of a result at the Reebok Stadium has to be high in priority. It may even be termed as “must win”, as much as I hate that term.

Villa fans will know all too well that Bolton did quite a number on us in the cup earlier this season. Barring Tottenham’s non-game, the Bolton result was probably the most disappointing. Losing to United isn’t great, but it is far easier to defend losing to the reigning champions than it is to defend losing to a team that is way down the league.

So Bolton’s game will provide some hope of salvation for McLeish amidst a tough period for the club. It saddens me that I am having to use the word hope when talking about a team that is currrently in the bottom half of the table, but this is where we are.

If Bolton away provides little seasonal cheer for fans, then I doubt the Christmas season will be either jolly or exciting, more a time where fragmentation leaves the current man under fire even further out in the wilderness.

McLeish is running out of time. It may not all be his fault, and other people may have to take the blame over the longer term but, barring improved results, Alex may well find himself as the sacrificial lamb slaughtered to change the mood down at B6.


  1. 1
    Phil Tompkins

    Been a Villa fan all my life. Now I live in Norfolk so don’t get to as many games as I would like. Havn’t been at all this season; not giving the board my hard-earned money to watch that dross!

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Dave Ellis

    I agree with pretty much everything Matt says. I’m a season ticket holder so have been to all the home games but have only been to Fulham away. The first few games we seemed to knock the ball around quite well but that’s stopped now. It seems the Manager’s influence is wearing off. I prefer to back the team and manager rather than get on their backs. However I think McLeish was a poor appointment, not because I dislike him or he’s not capable but because it was obvious he would never be accepted by a large section of the fans. The club needs to stop the rot and quick because we’re only going one way at the moment.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    The King of Bilstonia

    Same here, I refuse to pay to watch the dross being served up and for me most of the blame for the dross lies with McLeish. More people need to stop going in order for the club to understand we aint prepared to pay for dross. Or as a poster on another forum suggested a mass walkout during a match might make the club more aware of how the fans feel.

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    TJ

    To turn things around, McLeish needs

    1) To get the players motivated and playing like they care. Siege mentality gets my vote.

    2) To admit his mistakes and move to a more attacking formation.

    3) Actually be true to his word and drop players that are out of form.

    4) Play somebody, ANYBODY – whether it is Gabby, Heskey, Delfouneso, Weimann, Albrighton, N’Zogbia, Bannan, Ireland, Gardner, Guzan, Cowans – close to Darren Bent. Either in a 4-4-2 or an EFFECTIVE 4-3-3 where the wingers actually get close to the strikers. You know…like the dutch system we tried and dramatically failed!

    5) Play everybody 15-20 yards higher up the pitch. I don’t care if you risk the ball over the top, at least it puts us in the game.

    6) Do not stand off at all times. Take a risk and close down, because currently it is WAY too easy for teams to keep possession against us.

    The players we have are easily capable of turning this situation round. We probably still have the 7th best collection of players in the league. But unless McLeish can get them playing well as a team then we WILL be relegated.

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    TJ

    ** I forgot. 7) Do not under any circumstances allow James Collins to be in possession of the football. When he is, use an electronic tag or something to zap him into playing the ball 5 yards in any direction to a player that won’t simply lump it into no mans land.

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    Sir Billy Quiet

    Blimey I thought all the Numpties supported Wolves! 12 games into the season after 12 months of disruption, give the bloke a chance!

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    WollyWulf

    Post 5 … one of the funniest posts I’ve read on here for a long time.

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    dave the rave

    Problem is with the villa they are not a big club anymore although the fans still think they are. Lerner threw millions in trying to get champions league football and it did not work now the money is not being put in they are just the same as before when o’leary was there, sacking the manager wont make any difference.

    Report abuse

  9. 9
    paul villa

    Call yourselves supporters ?
    What do you lot support ?

    Report abuse



Latest Blog — Microsoft Comes to the University of Wolverhampton

Last week Microsoft visited the University of Wolverhampton to give students the chance to develop their own phone apps that could be published on the Windows Phone Marketplace.
Technology blog

Microsoft Comes to the University of Wolverhampton

Free e-Supplements

Business Awards

Read the full story here Read the full story here

Full coverage of awards celebrating the region's best businesses.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

LIVE traffic updates

Road, rail and airport - latest Road, rail and airport - latest

Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new E&S app Get the new E&S app

Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.