Is the Premier League all that good?

Tuesday 9th March 2010, 9:32AM GMT.

Is the Premier League all that good?

Wolves’ Sporting Star columnist John Lalley believes that the Premier League may not be the powder keg that it’s cracked up to be after watching Manchester United.

The Early Bird season ticket offer expires soon and no doubt the majority of fans eligible to take advantage of this deal will renew their tickets once again.

This comes despite the undeniable fact that no-one can accurately forecast which division Wolves will be operating in next season.

And I can’t pretend that I’ll be stumping up the cash because I’m massively excited at what I’ve seen this season in the Premier League.

The marketing executives and the Sky TV pundits would have us all believe that the Premier League offers us unsurpassable quality in the best competition in the world, with so many games touching the highest levels of skill, athleticism and drama.

Maybe it’s because Wolves have lost more than half of their home matches and our opponents have scored exactly double the number of goals at Molineux than we have, but the football I have witnessed this season has hardly set pulses racing.

With the ‘big four’ having all paid us a visit after Saturday, only some of the football played by Arsenal will linger in my memory. Chelsea were functional rather than inspirational, cautious and wary, whilst Liverpool were so devoid of innovation and creativity that even their own fans were complaining bitterly outside Molineux after their drag of a visit in January.

Without doubt, they were the dullest Liverpool team I’ve ever witnessed at Molineux and, with Fernando Torres absent, Wolves had little trouble in subduing them as the match petered out into a turgid stalemate. The goalless draw was certainly a decent result for us, but for any neutral, the game must have been excruciating.

Manchester United at home. This is the fixture that all and sundry point to as the ultimate motivation for any Championship club with aspirations of a place amongst the elite.

United stand as one of the principal reasons why so many of us are prepared to shell out increasingly illogical sums of money for the privilege of watching football.

The biggest club in the world, hell-bent on becoming the first team in Premier League history to win four consecutive titles and in so doing surpass their hated Liverpool rivals and their 18 championships.

But you will have to forgive me for being slightly under whelmed by the experience last Saturday evening. With their top of the bill star-turn Wayne Rooney missing, there wasn’t much stardust being sprinkled around Molineux.

It was a dour affair with their peak of the range aristocrats making heavy weather of seeing off our willing but generally plodding bunch of Championship interlopers. In terms of the wow factor, this sure was no reincarnation of George Best, Denis Law and Bobby Charlton in full cry.

In truth, the match was indicative of much that has been served up at Molineux all through the season.

United? The pinnacle of our game, the brightest jewel in the Premier crown, the absolute tops, and the most striking example of football drenched in money back in town, but was it so fascinatingly absorbing?

Was it so inspiring and uplifting that you simply were left gagging for the next opportunity to get hooked on your latest fix of high-octane adrenaline?

No, it was all pretty ordinary and mundane, like it has been for much of the season and, of course, what made it worse is that we should have got a point!

From the second tier of wanabees trying to break the monopoly of the big four and ram raid their Champions League cartel, Manchester City dismissed us fairly easily without ever looking anywhere as accomplished as one would expect after such prodigious financial investment.

Tottenham were uniformly dreadful and Villa looked anything but special on their visit to Molineux back in October. Throw in such ordinary outfits as Bolton, Burnley, Hull and Portsmouth and the excessive hype and self-congratulation this league generates seems to be based on flimsy foundations.

Just the same, coming up to the conclusion of our second stab at this Premier League lark, I’d much sooner give it another bash than take an immediate return to the wilderness of the Championship, which despite its grandiose renaming a few years back remains a grinding chore we can well do without for the time being.

But a touch of honest perspective regarding the Premier League would do no harm.

On the evidence of the action at Molineux this season, it certainly possesses all the pace, power and athleticism its chief propagandists boast about, but does it really have that depth of class and such a reservoir of pedigree quality to justify the average £1million plus salaries enjoyed by its players?

The likes of Rooney and Arsenal’s Cesc Fabregas are exceptions rather than the rule and great players by any criteria.

But below their level of genius, this league carries a host of competent and solid professionals – no more no less – who should consider themselves the most fortunate group of footballers lucky enough to have ever played the game for a living.


  1. 1
    Mark Smallwood

    Good blog. Barring Arsenal, who looked like they could score everytime they counter attacked with pace and verve, the temas in this league are very uninspiring. It is worth baring in mind though, that we are often set up to attempt to nullify the oppositions more creative players, especially in the latter half of this season. However, when you watch the flair on display form the likes of Barca and Real Madrid, the Premier League is not the self titled ‘ best league in the world’. Most competitive perhaps, but the overall quality is in decline.

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    The Countess of Coseley

    Not without reason has the song ‘Premier League, full of s**t’ been echoing round Molineux in recent months. This season we have witnessed more diving, cheating, refs unduly influenced by ‘bigger’ teams, extortionate ticket costs, stupid kick off times, etc than ever before, without the dazzling sparkling football that is supposed to be the hallmark of this over-hyped league. Some may argue that Wolves players are niave in not joining in with all of the diving, surrounding the ref etc but I don’t concur with that. Football needs to be cleaned up, and the obscene salaries paid to players need to be capped. If that means the ‘top’ players go abroad would it be a bad thing? Nearly all games in the world are available live on TV or on the internet for people who want to watch them that way, so if Terry and Gerrard to name but two went to play in Italy who would miss them? I’d rather watch the current Wolves team than any of that lot, whatever anyone thinks of the merits of Mick and the players, at least they care and are bothered which is more than you could say for several of the Man U ‘stars’ on Saturday.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    Pedro

    We have never met Mr Lalley,but you have read my mind..Most people put such store by staying in the premiership,survival at any cost they say,,I cant see the point,our Premiership is boring football,not scoring goals,and being afraid of attacking teams.I have been to most of our games this season,and the simple truth is its been rubbish,the only benefit I can see from Premiership football at the Wolves is more money for the club,with very limited investmant in players,our management obviously dont want to attract top players,and pay top wages,so iff by some mirracle we do survive,we look like having the same again next season.I would rather watch good football in the Championship,than garbage in the Premiership,,PS I have allready bought early bird…

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Pedro

    I have just read The Countess,,you have it in a nutshell (WAGES) Iwatched a thing on TV yesterday about Port Vale (Micky Addams)telling the story of Port Vales struggle for survival,the even have people giving there sevices for free just to help the club. then the other end the John Terrys on 170,000 grand a week,,no wonder football is in a mess,I have allways said iff you offer a kid,a life of playing football for a wage of say 100 grand a YEAR tops they would snatch your hand off,,100 grand playing football or 35 grand in a factory?????

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    wbabomber

    What an excellent article.

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    St. Louis Wolf

    Until we get a competitive team we’ll not see the best of Cheski, Man Utd etc…..As we send our fringe players to Telford for a run out they will send there players to Molineux who are in need of a game. We saw a Chelski side that was missing many first team stars and cruised to a win without getting out of second gear.

    Alex Ferguson said he picked the Wolves game to reunite Ferdinand and Vidic as he thought Wolves lacked any attacking punch and it would give the pair a chance to shake off the cob webs. Once again with many stars missing they won with minimal effort with bench players.

    Good sides be-get good sides; we are not therefore we do not!

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    kilkenny wolfy

    what i’d like to know is WHAT FACTORY DOES PEDRO WORK IN THAT PAYS £35 GRAND!?!?!?!?!?!?

    seriously though, good article which i think sums up the way the premiership has been going for the last 3 or 4 years – just not as good as its made out to be….

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    Nick

    I’d rather watch a close competition with some variation in the top 4 each season. There is quality at times, but the differnce between the top and even mid-table is boring.
    I wonder if the so called big four’s business plans allowed for gate crashers when they engineered their protective bubble with the Premiership and Champions League?

    Report abuse

  9. 9
    Johnboy

    I think Pedro may have worked at Goodyears for 35 grand a year….say no more!!

    Report abuse

    • RemWolf

      Only Goodyear managers and engineers earned that kind of money not shop floor workers…and you cant be an overtime junkie on continental shifts.
      Big up the ex building 44 crew!

      Report abuse

  10. 10
    Mike Pearson

    While I agree that the general quality (or lack of) is in question as far as the Premier League is concerned, it can hardly be said that Wolves have added any quality this season. I have supported Wolves for almost 50 years and I have to say our performances this season have ranged from pathetic to embaressing.

    Parking a bus in front of our goal for most of the season and then whining about the “the lack of quality” really takes the biscuit!!!

    I want our team to stay up in the worst possible way but if we are going to repeat what we have seen next season then please do not write these whiny blogs about quality when we are contributing to the paucity of entertainment on display!!!

    Report abuse

  11. 11
    lord wolf of newport

    great article john, i,ve been saying for a long time this premiership is over hyped and not the best league in the world, who started that saying? the best league in the world, its the footballers themselves thats who and these are the same players who are making extortionate wage demands through their agents. rant over.

    Report abuse

  12. 12
    Mattj

    Could it be that you’re merely trying to resign yourself to the humdrum drudge of Championship football, coming to a ground near us sooner than we’d care for?
    I’d suggest the reasons for the mundanity of the football witnessed at Molineux this year has been twofold; the unremitting ordinariness of the Host team; and the consequent lack of real quality that visiting teams need to employ to subdue our honest, but severely limited endeavours.
    Undoubtedly, the Premier League is characterised by hyperbole and bluster; but we were all too ready to embrace the self same qualities when crassly manifested by our Chairman and Chief Executive last summer.

    Report abuse



Latest Blog — Microsoft Comes to the University of Wolverhampton

Last week Microsoft visited the University of Wolverhampton to give students the chance to develop their own phone apps that could be published on the Windows Phone Marketplace.
Technology blog

Microsoft Comes to the University of Wolverhampton

Free e-Supplements

Business Awards

Read the full story here Read the full story here

Full coverage of awards celebrating the region's best businesses.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

LIVE traffic updates

Road, rail and airport - latest Road, rail and airport - latest

Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new E&S app Get the new E&S app

Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.