Time to map out a plan for Villa's future
- Says blogger Matthew Turvey
Comprehensive Spending Review 2010
Wednesday 20th October 2010, 12:20PM BST.
Review our minute-by-minute coverage of the Commons session below.
George Osborne delivered the biggest cuts to public spending in decades – and now we want to know how it will affect you.
Highlights: 490,000 public sector jobs to be lost over the course of the next four years.
Welfare changes to save the country £7bn a year.
Police spending to fall by four per cent each year for the next four years.
- Send us your comments using the form below.
Our team’s commentary – live:
14.45: Some local reaction from the business community.
Martin Wassell, Midlands director of EEF, the manufacturers’, said: “There will be some relief for manufacturers that the cuts were not as bad as feared with some positive announcements in the protection of the science and education budgets and support for low carbon technologies. The private sector will have to play a much bigger role in the future of the economy. Today’s statement showed The Chancellor understands the areas on which to focus, we now need the detail of how we are going to get there. However, for companies the suspense is not yet over and they need clarity on the government’s strategy for growth and, in particular how it will work with the private sector to leverage investment. Industry has already started to increase its investment but this will only be sustained if the government sets out a clear framework for the longer-term. Further announcements in the next few weeks now assume a critical importance.”
James Watkins, executive director of Business Voice WM, said: “Business will need to be imaginative and innovative if it is to fight the supply chain problems that the spending cuts could herald. Cuts in social housing will be a matter of grave concern to the hard-pressed construction industry. The hope is that tax increment funding – allowing councils to keep business rates in return for commercial development – will help the sector. The cuts to the police budget will raise concerns as to how front line officers will be affected at a time when Business Voice WM has found that business crime costs the West Midlands £26,000 an hour. We will be watching this issue closely. The extension of the Midland Metro and the redevelopment of New Street Station will help to relieve the logjam on our roads.”
John Rider, chairman of the Institute of Directors in the West Midlands, stressed the region needed jobs: “It was the only place in the country that over the last ten years had seen a net decline in private sector jobs, unemployment was well above the national average and there were 850,000 people defined as economically inactive. We are in favour of these public sector cutbacks but at the same time the Government needs to protect jobs where it can and provide an economic environment for job creation. Let’s hope the private sector can come up trumps and fill the gap. But it is a risk and I am concerned by the timing.”
13.55: Peter Rhodes writes: “George Osborne sat down and Alan Johnson stood up to respond. This, remember, is the old Labour warhorse who said when he was appointed Shadow Chancellor a few weeks ago that he knew little about economics.
“But what a blistering performance this was as he swept into a passionate, lyrical and utterly assured demolition of the spending review. Ed Miliband watched wide-eyed. And how many Labour MPs were wondering whether they had elected the right man? This afternoon, on top form in the Commons, Alan Johnson looked like the best leader Labour never had.”
13.37: “As Chancellor George Osborne rose to address the Commons this afternoon, with bad news for princes, policemen and politicians alike, he looked like a conjurer whose best trick has been given away by his assistant.” Peter Rhodes gives his analysis of the review: Coalition marriage faces first real test
13.33: That’s it – the Chancellor sits down as the Coalition backbenchers wave their order papers.
13.31: Schools budget to rise in real terms for four years.
13.29: Shaun Lintern – E&S Health Correspondent on Twitter: Chancellor says NHS spending will rise from £104bn this year to £114bn in the next four years – one of worst settlements since the 1980s.
13.27: £30bn to be spent on transport projects over the next four years.
13.26: The Chancellor says that money will be made available for an extension to the Midland Metro. We think that’s the planned extension in Birmingham.
13.25: University funding to be cut by 7.1 per cent a year.
13.24: As expected, major changes at BBC. Osborne: BBC to fund World Service, saving taxpayers £340m, licence fee to be frozen for six years. None of it will be going to Jonathan Ross, of course.
13.20: Some Twitter updates.
Andrew Lowry: Listening to George Osbourne make me and another 495,000 civil servants redundant! At least it’s a sunny day.
realityrose Karen from Wolverhampton: Blimey, some good news – social care funding to be increased by £2bn. #csr
13.15: Our Deputy Business Editor Simon Penfold says: The City’s taking the Budget in its stride. After a brief drop in the FTSE-100 when George Osborne started talking, it is building up again. Investors are finding little to surprise them here, and are happy that something seems to getting done to get the deficit under control.
Richard Mottram, of Wolverhampton stockbroker’s Redmayne Bentley, said: “Some companies are being affected – BAE is down about five per cent in the wake of the defence cuts, and some building firms will probably rise because of the plans to build another 150,000 social homes – but there are few surprises here. Much of this has already been leaked in advance and investors were already prepared.”
13.14: Total health spending each year will rise over and above inflation.
13.11: Universal benefits for pensioners to be retained, the Chancellor announces to big cheers from the Coalition benches. Increase in Cold Weather Payments to pensioners to be made permanent.
13.10: No further changes to child benefit as higher rate change will already save £2.5bn.
13.08: Osborne – Child element of the Child Tax Credit to be increased above indexation in 2011/12 and 2012/13.
13.07: Welfare changes to save the country £7bn a year.
13.05: New Universal Credit to replace benefits and tax credits to be introduced over the next two parliaments.
13.02: There will be changes to MPs pensions.
13.00: State pension age for men and women will reach 66 by 2020. This will save over £5bn a year..
12.57: An extra £900m will be made available to tackle tax fraud.
12.55: Ministry of Justice budget to be £7bn by 2014 – a cut of six per cent a year on average. The move is likely to see the closure of some courts.
12.54: Home Office will find savings of six per cent according to the Chancellor.
12.50: Osborne – Police spending to fall by four per cent each year for the next four years.
12.46: Osborne – 490,000 public sector jobs to be lost over the course of the next four years.
12.45: Osborne – Total Royal Household budget to fall 14 per cent by 2012/13.
12.42: Osborne – the public sector needs to change. We have found £6bn of Whitehall savings.
12.40: Osborne – We are all in this together and we must all share the burden.
12.36: The Chancellor is spending more time talking about the historical reasons for today’s statement – promises of no return to the brink of bankruptcy.
12.32: Osborne – the years of ever rising borrowing are over. We have the largest structural debt in Europe.
12.31: We’re off. George Osborne says ‘Today is the day Britain comes back from the brink’
12.26: Dan Wainwright is tweeting a lot about this – might be worth keeping an eye on his feed
12.25: MerseySaddler on Twitter: Labour have developed an incredible ability to forget the past 13 years, it’s just a shame it’s not that easy for the rest of us
12.19: David Schneider – celeb on Twitter: How marvelous. BBC2 has the Spending Review while BBC1 has Cash in the Attic. Presumably the only place it’s now safe.
12.17: Matt Taylor from Birmingham on Twitter: The real impact of the spending cuts: today I’ll be having a Philpotts s/wich, tomorrow Subway.
12.15: Electric atmosphere in the Commons chamber. This is one of the most anticipated statements for many years.
12.11: PMQs still taking place in the Commons. Less than 20 minutes to go now.
12.10: James Carpenter of Beacon radio on Twitter: My fingers are firmly crossed for all public service workers today…I used to be one
12.08: Not long to go until George Osborne announces plans for the biggest programme of cuts in the UK for decades.
E&S local government editor Dan Wainwright on Twitter: I’m watching the comprehensive spending review. Chief exec of Stafford Borough Council says “we have had plenty of warning about this”
Business Awards
Read the full story here
Full coverage of awards celebrating the region's best businesses.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
LIVE traffic updates
Road, rail and airport - latest
Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new E&S app
Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.

Before the usual whingers get going with cries of ‘cruel Tory cuts’, just remember which party was in government for the preceding thirteen years and just how much they damage they did to the nation’s finances during that time.
Report abuse
Nothing to do with the conservatives for the 18 years previous to that then!
Report abuse
So at what level did the national debt stand at when John Major left office in 1997? And in what direction was it heading?
The truth is that under Labour government spending had come adrift from revenues from 2001 onwards – long before the recession arrived and at a time when the British economy was booming (as Gordon Brown never ceased to remind us at the time).
So if Labour couldn’t pay for all their rash spending promises at the height of one of the longest economic booms in modern British history, how the hell did they expect us to pay for it all once the bubble burst? Or was Brown really so arrogant and stupid as to belief he had abolished ‘boom and bust’?
Report abuse
Actually Ray the debt is as a result of the de-regulation of the banking sector which was the brain child of the Tory Government in the eighties. They were following the economic ideas of economic thinkers and academics Friedman and Hayek, with the latter heading the chicago school of economics.
Please do not rant to the masses with ill informed views please.
Report abuse
Sorry Dan your wrong. Personal debt could be attribured as you describe but Government debt comes from spending more than you take in in tax. That decision was Labours not the banks and they did it for nearly 10 years.
Report abuse
70% of our debt comes from bailing the banks out. The rest is labour over spending. Lets not forget we are not alone in the world with these debts. Every country world wide are suffering from large debts so it’s not just us and our government that are to blame.
Report abuse
Whatever happens the rich will get richer and the poor wil get poorer, standard Tory policy i’m afraid.
Report abuse
At least there where 500,000 more people in work under labour.Rising pension age to 66 we will now have the highest retiring age in Europe typical Tory policy just looking after the better off in this country.Be interested to know what type of work tory Ray does?
Report abuse
I suggest you “google” retirement ages for Europe.
Norway 67
Denmark 67
Germany 65 changing to 67
Similarly Spain,Switzerland etc
Report abuse
Ah, Dan, you seriously undersell the cause!
The good news is that, according to the Office for National Statistics, there were actually 1.67 million new jobs created during Labour’s thirteen years in power.
The bad news is that the ONS reckons that 98.5% of them were taken by immigrants. Alas, not much evidence of Labour looking after the ordinary working man there then.
Report abuse
So if this is Tory Policy, why did the gap between rich and poor get steadily wider during 13 years of Labour administration or has this become Labour Policy ?
Report abuse
Bob
Suggest you check your facts what you say about ages of retirement, incorrect as always, Tories not telling the truth.Suppose you can also jusify icrease of over 35% on International development as well
Report abuse
I have checked the facts Dan. As I suggested try using a search engine. The information is there for all to see. If you can’t use a search engine try Wikipedia
Report abuse
y dont they start at the top when cuts start not at the bottom as normal pluss y we still giveing money away to other countrys in fact they have put the money up then there is that dictatorship the european union money can be safed by not being in it and what about all these emigrants that just walk in and are allowed more money than our own peaple then the banks and mps need to be sorted but no its the working class that pays for the mess
Report abuse
Even after ‘cuts’, this country will spend absurd amounts of money on overseas wars as well as overseas aid. Cut this out of the equation, and we won’t be here forced to even more dust and going through one recession after another. This country is a very rich country – if you belong to the minority who run it..the rest of us are mere subjects of this regime, and our misery is their profit. When..when are we gonna wake up and realise there is no left and no right? Just them and us.
Report abuse
Agreed. People need to wake up and realise that the left / right paradigm is a smokescreen. Politics should be about right and wrong.
Politicians are also quite happy wasting billions on the lie that is climate change,and billions on third word aid.
Report abuse
The five items we need to tackle to reduce our debt and put us firmly on a path to recovery are 1) Stop and reverse third world immigration. 2) Withdraw from EU. 3) Stop ALL foreign “aid” payments 4) Withdraw from Afghanistan. 5) Fully devolve Scotland and Wales. As well as saving large amounts of money it will automatically reduce the number of public sector workers we need which will be an added financial bonus.
Report abuse
Frank, your solution is too straightforward – it is not profitable for the people who wish to profit from our misfortune. It is therefore a ‘threat’ to their very existence; were it not for the chaos they create and they sustain, their positions would became untenable overnight. The only way they can continue their charade is to create enemies and sell fake solutions. They serve only the interests only of the few, not the many. Your proposed solution is something I admire, and something they will promise to deliver. It’s not within their interests to do so.
Report abuse
i cant see me doing my heavy manual job till i am 66 these people who say we must work longer want to try doing some of the jobs we people do in this country ibet he would think twice about hiring the age,it should be brought sdown if anything.The best way to get more money in the system is to get the free loaders off there backsides and earn there money,also all the immigrants pouring into this country just taking things out of the system and never putting anything back in.All governments are the same just think about themeselves.
Report abuse
why is it we are paying foreign aid to countries which don’t need it.We have to make cuts so lets stop sending money abroad in aid,as no one heard of the saying charity begins at home?i don’t see any country sending us any aid when we got hit by flooding.i am sick to death of this once mighty country of ours being a soft touch by the world.
Report abuse
I have not noticed any cut backs in MP’s expenses and the cost of running the house of commons.
Report abuse