Time to map out a plan for Villa's future
- Says blogger Matthew Turvey
Sandwell Conservatives’ deputy leader defects to Labour
Saturday 4th September 2010, 11:41AM BST.
The deputy leader of Sandwell’s Conservative group has defected to Labour in a shock move. Councillor Elaine Costigan says she is disillusioned with the Government’s cutbacks.
She said cutting Sandwell’s schools building programme was “the last straw.”
Mrs Costigan is the daughter of Bill Archer, aged 83, a Conservative councillor in Sandwell for 36 years and Tory Party member for 40.
He is also is her fellow ward member.
Councillor Costigan, who joined the council as a Conservative in 2002, said: “What has happened over the last few months, and the cuts that have been made, have tipped me over the edge. The cuts to Sandwell’s Building Schools to the Future funding were the last straw.”
The former mayoress said she opted to join the Labour Party rather than standing as an independent as she likes the vision of Sandwell’s Labour group. She said: “I am not a political animal. I just want to make life better for the people in the north of the borough.”
Wrong
She will remain as a councillor until May, when she will apply to stand as a candidate for Wednesbury North. She was accepted as a member of the Labour Party at a meeting of the West Bromwich West Constituency Labour Party executive committee last night.
Councillor Archer said he is supporting his daughter’s decision.
Councillor Ian Jones, vice-chairman of West Bromwich West Constituency Labour Party, said: “The last time Labour had a seat in Wednesbury North was 1997. That was the first one for decades, so this is very good news for the Labour party in Sandwell.”
Councillor Darren Cooper, Labour group leader and leader of Sandwell Council, said: “For a long time I thought she was in the wrong political party.”
Sandwell’s Conservative group leader Councillor Ray Nock, said: “My team are aghast that Councillor Costigan, who only weeks ago was attacking Labour policies openly in the press such as the parking charges in Wednesbury has seen fit to jump ship.
“The real losers are the good folk of Wednesbury.”
By Sally Walmsley
Business Awards
Read the full story here
Full coverage of awards celebrating the region's best businesses.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
LIVE traffic updates
Road, rail and airport - latest
Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new E&S app
Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.

So she joins the side that spent all the money, wrote the blank chqs, built up unfunded promises to Sandwell communities. She really must be mad.
Report abuse
By the way can she take her farther with her too.
Report abuse
Her constituents voted Conservative not Labour. She should resign now not in May. She is just another typical self-serving politician.
Report abuse
unless you know exactly what you are on about and have been a local elected member then i suggest you keep it shut-just a pity that Labour do not support Memebrs that walked the floor regardless of their principles-she will be out in May alas as we need more women politicians as they are honest and do not just ppay lip service to the people-I speak from experience
Report abuse
More women politicians? You’re ‘avin laugh aren’t you? Julie kirkbride..honest? Margret Thatcher the destroyer of many an industry !! I suggest you “keep it shut” and do some research on the poor show of women politicians before making sweeping statements like the above.
Report abuse
It is Labours fault there is cut backs.
Report abuse
But it’s your fault that you don’t know the difference between is and are.
Report abuse
The Labour Party was in power for 13 years, its reasons and decision to take us into war with Iraq and Afghanistan has been proved to be questionable to say the least.
Gordon Browns deliberate theft of the money deposited in the working person’s pension’s pot was wrong and has left the workers in this country in desperate poverty.
Under Labour Government, our service personnel, who have been killed or seriously maimed, are just discarded as nothing more that canon fodder after they have served their purpose.
Our schools and infrastructure has decayed to such an extent that Britain is fast becoming a clone of a Third World Country, Labours open door policy on Immigration has bankrupted the country to the extent that they have had to borrow billions of pounds just to keep us afloat, the interest payment on those loans would have put us in a worse state than countries like Greece.
The Labour Government said to the banking industry, “you do what you want and there will be no retribution no matter how illegal it is” and they did!!!! They loaned money out that they didn’t have in order to pay themselves telephone number bonuses, then that same Labour Government took more money off the bankrupted workers in this country and made good the money lost through the greed of those same bankers, and who was left to foot the bill for the Labour Governments disastrous actions, the working class.
Sandwell’s Labour Council is exactly the same, the schools in the borough didn’t deteriorate overnight, it happened over at least the last 13 years when the Blair / Brown government ruled the country, how strange people like Elaine Costigan didn’t feel inclined to raise their heads above the parapets then.
Regards the state of our education system, why didn’t Elaine Costigan complain in April 2006, when Gordon Brown pledged to give poor countries £8.5 billion to improve education in countries like Africa, India, Pakistan?
India recently declared to the world that it now had its own nuclear submarine, it also has it own space rockets!!!!! Its been fighting a war with Pakistan for years, it should also be remembered that Mumbai has more millionaires than New York, so why didn’t Elaine Costigan make a fuss then??
Elaine Costigan you have stood by and watched as Sandwell’s Labour Council poured £76 million down the drain on that monstrous white elephant “The Public” you have watched them spend £450.000 on rocks and plants for Birchley Traffic Island and another huge £30,000 on a sign saying ‘Welcome To Sandwell’ for that same traffic island.
Councillor Mahboob Hussain has a plan to spend £36 million on replacing every one of 30,000 lamp posts in the borough, because he says that are 50 per cent brighter and it is claimed the move will save £1.5 million a year in maintenance and energy costs, so he wants to spend £36 million on replacing 30,000 lamp posts because it will save £1.5 million a year????????
Elaine Costigan doesn’t that tell you that even if Sandwell’s Labour Council were given money by the Coalition, it wouldn’t be spent on the schools in the borough? of course if you think that statement is untrue please tell me why these schools are in such a state now and why Sandwell’s Labour Council didn’t spend money on them before, could it be that this Labour Council doesn’t give a damn about the schools or the pupils in the borough??????????
Elaine Costigan, why should Michael Gove have to apologise for the outcome of the policies of a previous government? Did Gordon Brown apologise for the bankers who bankrupted the country? Did Blair apologise for the illegal wars he took us into? Or did either of them apologise for the state of our schools or education system??????
Personally I think we are better off without councillors like this if they don’t have the backbone or intelligence to face up to proven facts like those above.
Elaine Costigan before I go I leave you with one thought about us the “Workers” and this is a proven fact:
“Labour’s betrayal of British workers” “Nearly every one of 1.67m jobs created since 1997 has gone to a foreigner”
Jim of Bearwood.
Report abuse
Blimey Jim, after reading that all i can add is I agree completely!
Report abuse
Sandwell Council have not spent £78million on The Public. The Arts Council stumped up most of the cash. Get your faces right.
Report abuse
Whatever would Ray Partidge have said. He will be turning in his grave at this disappointing news. Voters in Wednesbury North have solidly voted Conservative for over 40 years. I’m sure they will do so again this coming May.
Report abuse
Well what a suprise, the government have no choice in making cut back’s and any half decent person knows in their hearts that this is the only way forward because of the last bunch of half wits. Well because the going gets tough she jumps ship because it suits her (what about the people who voted for you?) Well i suppose the sandwell council has another loyal member to add to it’s long old gravy train!!!!!
Report abuse
Sandwell has, unfortunately, had a Labour controlled council for over 30 years. The UK has been run by a Labour controlled government for 13 years – and Elaine is blaming this controversy on the party which has supported her for the last eight years. I would have thought better of her if she had resigned, rather than “crossing the floor”. The fabric of school buildings does not disintegrate overnight, so we all know where the real blame lies except, it seems, by this councillor. Shame on you Elaine.
Report abuse
The Green Party better stand a candidate in Wednesbury North then – and capitalise on those Labour voters not wanting to vote for a closet Tory…
Report abuse
lmao are you for real
Report abuse
1994 36.05 a
1995 39.55 a
1996 41.20 a
1997 41.92 a
1998 40.14 a
1999 37.86 a
2000 35.37 a
2001 30.57 a
2002 29.33 a
2003 30.45 a
2004 31.82 a
2005 33.81 a
2006 34.92 a
2007 35.74 a
2008 36.25 a
2009 44.19 a
2010 53.15 e
Debt as a percentage of GDP from 1994 to 2010.
As you can see debt was generally reducing until 2008 wherein the financial crisis hit and Gordon Brown was faced with a decision. To spend to stimulate the economy or to cut services immediately in line with the reduction of income from taxation.
The cuts are a symptom. The cause was greed in the private banking industry.
Report abuse
Most interesting figures. So why is the trend steadily upwards from 2002 rather than 2008 ?
Report abuse
An increasing number of people are warming to the realization that there is no no left and right – that there is no real choice. The system is wrong..it does not represent the people’s wishes and it’s run by private interests that can create and destroy economies and cultures at the drop of a hat. Open your minds.
Report abuse
Could this really be a Tory with some sense????
Oh Jim while I agree with some of what you say..If we are bankrupt..Can you tell me why it is we have just given 70 million to Pakistan aid, and why it was we were at the recent meeting of the worlds top 20 richest countries!! Not bad for a bankrupt country. Seems we can always find money when we need it for a just cause.
No one betrayed the workers more than the Tories in the 80′s Jim!! Short memories thats all with some people.
Report abuse
Elaine if you have integrity, you must resign now!!!!!
Report abuse