Court orders litterbug to pay £175
Wednesday 24th February 2010, 11:30AM GMT.
Dropping litter has cost a Wolverhampton man £175 after he was taken to court.
Litterbug Gareth McNally was initially issued a £60 fixed penalty notice when he was spotted discarding a piece of cellophane on the ground close to Wolverhampton train station.
But having failed to pay, that amount has now more than doubled as legal costs and fines were imposed.
At Wolverhampton Magistrates Court yesterday, the 29-year-old admitting depositing litter in Railway Drive in September last year.
Mrs Donna Richards, prosecuting on behalf of the city council, told the court: “On September 11, a principal enforcement officer from the council was heading towards the train station, in Railway Drive, when he observed the defendant drop a piece of cellophane on the floor and continue on his way.
“The officer introduced himself, explaining that it was an offence to drop litter.
“The defendant explained he hadn’t got time to stop as his daughter was ill.”
She added: “A fixed penalty notice of £60 was issued which today remains unpaid.”
McNally, of Hailes Park Close, in Parkfields, who was unrepresented in court, said he had sight problems in his left eye which may have contributed to the offence.
“I’m blind in my left eye and was walking to the train station and took the cellophane off and as I was putting it in my bag, it’s come off and because of the blind spot I didn’t see it,” he said.
“I do admit I was saying to the officer I was going to see my daughter because she was ill.”
McNally said he had phoned up to pay the fixed penalty notice but as he was on benefits, did not have the means to pay it all at once.
District Judge Michael Wheeler fined McNally £60, and ordered him to pay £100 towards legal costs and a £15 victim surcharge.
Last year, the cuty council issued 407 fixed penalty notices for litter dropping.
Anyone aged over 14 who drops litter in a public place in the city can be issued with a £60 fixed penalty notice.
A maximum fine of £2,500 can be imposed at magistrates court if the penalty is not paid.
Council chiefs have said littering is high on peoples’ agendas and they will continue to crackdown on people who drop litter on the city’s streets.
In October last year, Wayne Lacy, of Bickley Road, in Bilston, was fined £120 after being spotted by a security officer dropping litter from the window of a parked car at Bentley Bridge, in Wednesfield.
Lacy, who was convicted in his absence, had failed to pay a fixed penalty fine of £60.
He was ordered to stump up legal costs of £382.12.
Business Awards
Book a Business Awards table
Join our celebrations of the region's best in business on Thursday March 22 - book your table now
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
entertainment
All the film reviews
Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases
OUR NEW APP
Get the new E&S app
Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.

Remind me to move from Stourbridge to Wolverhampton, NOT!!
That disgusting UNCARING council are nearly as bad as SandHells.
Report abuse
Good, stay in your own filth. You are obviously not the type of person that one would wish to share a town with. This is one of the only things that I do find agreeable about Wolves council. I would make it a five hundred pound fine and triple it for non payment. Voice of reason and all the other contributers on here that are happy to live in a tip, could you please stay the hell out of Wolverhampton, you are unwanted.
Report abuse
Welcome to Big Brother Britain, people cannot even pass wind today without someone watching and hearing every single decibel.
More controls, we are being conditioned more and more all the time, we are being transformed from wonderful free individual beings to laboratory rats. They even have the shock treatment for us now in tasers, just as they have been used on laboratory rats, more cameras, more fines and the majprity of the people welcome these moves with open arms even though it’s is those very people who will end up paying for all this new technology in fines.
Report abuse
Good! Shuold be able to impose community service as well so he can clear up. “Sight problems” my eye!
Report abuse
Welcome to George Orwells 1984!
Report abuse
I like your comment! – And as Orwell predicted;
War is Peace!
Ignorance is Strength!
Freedom is Slavery!
Report abuse
good people ho drop rubbish are dirty beggars who deserve to be punished if they are too bone idle to put there filth in a bin then fine them to the hilt
Report abuse
The fines are no where near large enough. Littering disrespectful people. There are bins everywhere, just hold on to it. Also…get a job.
Report abuse
The idiots in support of these huge fines for dropping a tiny piece of litter will end up as victims themselves, look at the guy who accidentally dropped a ten pound note and was fined 50 pounds for it, if your baby accidentally drops anything, there’s another fine, these schemes are simply about raising revenue and having more control inflicted upon us.
Report abuse
I,m pleased that “voice of reason” is staying in Stourbridge. I hope he,s happy living in his own filth. Myself I prefer to live in a clean environment where people have respect for their surroundings
Report abuse
There’s plenty of bins down railway drive. No excuse.
To those moaning about “Big Brother Britain”, think about what you’re saying there.. if they hadn’t been such an ass as to chuck litter on a busy (and generally nice) public street, with plenty of bins in sight, then it wouldn’t matter if someone was watching or not.
Your saying “bugger, there’s people watching us now, we can’t break the law and make the streets of Wolverhampton a mess!”. And people wonder why we keep getting voted worst City nowadays.
Report abuse
Yes he should have been fined. The problem is that more worrying offences (eg no car insurance)are are dealt with lightly in comparison. A £20 fine would have been more sensible.
Report abuse
Having recently visited Wolverhampton, I was shocked at the filth thrown on the pavements, the dog mess you had to dodge, and the spit. The place is dirty and it isn’t helped by filthy people too lazy to walk to a bin and through their rubbish away.
Report abuse
The term litterbug suggests he is a repeat offender but from reading the article he was only caught dropping litter once as he was in a rush due to his daughter being ill. Hopefully none of you draconian robo-clones ever have to break any offence when rushing to a loved one. Being fined for speeding whilst rushing to a hospital where a loved one has suffered a heart attack is a similar example.
Report abuse
The fine is disgraceful as the man is on benefits and is raising a child. The family must already be struggling enough being on benefits and raising a young child, even less money to spend on their child now.
Report abuse
Are not these fines handed out to people on benefits who more than likely have no means of paying just going to lead to an increase in crime? Crime to pay for the fine?
The litterbug in the article couldn’t afford to pay the original 60 pounds which I imagine is a hell of a lot of money to someone on benefits, so what do the supposed courts of justice do? They triple his fine, if he couldn’t pay the original amount hows he going to afford three times as much?
Report abuse
I think it would make more sense to hand out community service and get the litter droppers to spend some time picking up litter and making the streets tidier.
Report abuse
Last year, the city council issued 407 fixed penalty notices for litter dropping………
congratulations, the revenue from your 407 litter bugs would not cover the wages of 1 enforcement officer let alone a ”priciple” enforcement officer.
The City centre is covered in litter and you only issue 407 fines in 1 year, about 8 a week.
Not very cost effective or efficient is it Wolverhampton?
How many enforcement officers do you have?
Report abuse
War is Peace!
Ignorance is Strength!
Freedom is Slavery
well said
but what gets me is that number 13 said its true its not enouth but do you remmber where the bins are in wolverhampton city centre NO WHERE on the out side and there not enouth
Report abuse
I WOULD LOVE TO SEE THESE PEOPLE WITH A SHOVEL AND A BROOM CLEANING UP THE FILTH DROPPED AROUND WOLVERHAMPTON THEY WOULD THINK TWICE BEFORE DROPPING RUBBISH NEXT TIME. [OINK] [OINK]
Report abuse
Sentencing the person to a day cleaning up rubbish would be interesting.
Report abuse
The man is on benefits so couldn’t afford to pay. What was the cellophane wrapper off ? A get well card ? Or a pack of cigarettes?
Are we suggesting that people on benefits should not be fined? Why not go the whole hog and let them break any laws they like.
I do agree that it would be more useful to get these filthy animals to clear something up rather than just fine them (which as he is on benefits us working people will be paying for, or do people forget that).
I used to live next to a shop and lost count of the number of “people” who took wrappers off things and just threw it to the ground. Usually next to the bin.
You carried it there, carry it to a bin or hime.
Report abuse
I was really annoyed the other day.
There was a bus stop and people decided to shove chip wrappers, cans sweet wrappers down the back of the pull down seats.
It looked an eyesore, but what amazed me the most was the fact the bin was about 2 feet away from the bus shelter. It wasn’t overflowing so no excuse to put it in the bin.
Going back to the gentleman in question.
I think he should have not been brought to court in the first place.He had tried to get them to let him pay in installments but they dont allow it. People whether on benefits or low paid jobs or people who dont even claim money tats a lot to take off them in 1 go.
Personaly i think they should be given the chance to put it right by street cleaning.
There’s litterbugs everywhere regardless of what town you live in…he was just unfortunate to be caught.
Report abuse
And made a scapegoat of!
Report abuse