Company quits after red tape battle

Tuesday 24th November 2009, 11:30AM GMT.

A company has quit the Black Country after a five month disagreement over red tape with council chiefs – which has resulted in the loss of 12 jobs.

Ian Edwards, managing director of Enviromise, in Oldbury, has left his Church Bridge premises and made workers redundant because he says it took too long to get planning permission for his business. Sandwell Council today said it was a noise nuisance issue rather than a planning matter but Mr Edwards is now relocating to Chester.

This will force him to give up a £200,000 grant for equipment from Advantage West Midlands and eight new job opportunities.

The company is one of the first businesses in the UK to efficiently process tyre wire waste following investment in pioneering new machinery. 

But Mr Edwards, from Wednesbury, now faces a three hour round trip commuting every day to the north west city after the council applied stringent noise conditions.

He said: “We are really disappointed to have to relocate, but the new site already has a licence for waste management and the north west authorities appear to have a far more proactive approach to regeneration. The premises in Oldbury used to be a warehouse where they manufactured windows so when we took it over in April we had to apply for a change of use.

“We went to about four different planning meetings and they were in no rush. They did not try to help us at all and for a council that says it supports manufacturing I think it’s pretty poor really.”

The company has recently invested in new equipment which allows all of the tyre waste to be reprocessed for other products.

Sandwell Council’s neighbourhoods chief, Councillor Mahboob Hussain said: “Sandwell Council’s planning committee granted permission for Enviromise to operate this tyre recycling venture with clear conditions on noise, following talks with the company’s noise consultants and the council’s noise experts in environmental health.

“This noise was investigated and we found it constituted a statutory nuisance. An abatement notice was issued requiring the operators to reduce the noise within two months. The company then decided to relocate.”


  1. 1
    Rob H

    The council are at fault.

    Look at it this way…if the council for the area the company has moved to has allowed it to go there then the council clearly has a lot to answer for. Sandwell council is entirely inept.

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    optimistic

    When all the work has gone and all the cars come off the road cos theres no work to go to and all the pubs close,the black country will be nice and quiet won’t it.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    ghost writer

    How can the council be at fault? Sorry but if the company is breaking the noise rules then it’s the company thats at fault!

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    BRUCE

    When I was a kid earning pin money back in the 1960s I could name nearly every employer as nothing like respecting present health and security rules.And all for different reasons.I have joked before here about the deaf ears elsewhere in the European Union.I found visual proof on last week’s French tv programme “Thalassa” concerning the absence of lifejackets on gondolas in Venice ! In fact, worse than that,the Vigili del fuoco (Fire Brigade) don’t wear them either.During the Feast of the Redemptor out on the water the town also attempted,with no success whatsoever,to ban alcohol ! Putting on electric switches flooded by water from the cut (Brierley Hill) with planks was the past.Venice is the present.As for jobs in the West Midlands : try making safety belts for swings !

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    BRUCE

    When I was a kid earning pin money back in the 1960s I could name nearly every employer as nothing like respecting present health and security rules.And all for different reasons.I have joked before here about the deaf ears elsewhere in the European Union.I found visual proof on last week’s French tv programme “Thalassa” concerning the absence of lifejackets on gondolas in Venice ! In fact, worse than that,the Vigili del fuoco (Fire Brigade) don’t wear them either.During the Feast of the Redemptor out on the water the town also attempted,with no success whatsoever,to ban alcohol ! Putting on electric switches flooded by water from the cut (Brierley Hill) with planks was the past.Venice was the present.As for jobs in the West Midlands try making safety belts for swings !

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    Sandwell Council

    Here is Sandwell Council’s full response to this story:

    Sandwell Council’s cabinet member for neighbourhoods and housing Cllr Mahboob Hussain said:

    “This was not a planning issue; this was a noise nuisance issue involving environmental health.

    “Sandwell Council’s planning committee granted permission for Enviromise to operate this tyre recycling venture with clear conditions on noise, following talks with the company’s noise consultants and the council’s noise experts in environmental health.

    “Enviromise’s consultants’ report indicated that the machinery was capable of operating at acceptable noise levels.

    “Conditions were therefore put in place to ensure the business could exist without upsetting its neighbours.

    “It is unfortunate that when the business began operating, our environmental health team received complaints about noise. This noise was much louder than predicted and exceeded the levels specified by the planning consent.

    “This noise was investigated and we found it constituted a statutory nuisance.

    “An abatement notice was issued requiring the operators to reduce the noise within two months. The company then decided to relocate.

    “The planning committee thought carefully about granting the permission and took into consideration the objections of 16 residents living nearby.

    “It is unfortunate that the business was not able to operate within these limits, however, we do have to balance the needs of the existing community with that of a new business with potential to cause noise nuisance.

    “The delays in the planning process were a consequence of the time it took for the company to agree acceptable noise limits.”

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    Jim of Bearwood.

    “The planning committee thought carefully about granting the permission and took into consideration the objections of 16 residents living nearby” looking on Google Earth, are there 16 residents in that area??????? Its all industry round there.

    Jim of Bearwood.

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    JimG

    Councillor Mahboob Hussain is only interested in penalising people!!!! Unless he can wield power over people and financially penalise them he isn’t interested in doing anything else.

    He isn’t interested in creating work for local people; the only time Councillor Mahboob Hussain wants to get involved in anything is when he can bring down the big stick on Sandwell residents to keep them in line.

    He was the one who wanted to have spy camera cars parked outside schools to fine parents who parked there, see : “SANDWELL COUNCIL HAD DRAWN UP PLANS TO BUY OR LEASE A £15,000 VEHICLE” “NEIGHBOURHOODS CHIEF COUNCILLOR MAHBOOB HUSSAIN SAID THERE HAD BEEN A COURT CASE INVOLVING ANOTHER LOCAL AUTHORITY WHICH HAD NOT PUT UP THE APPROPRIATE SIGNS AND HAD BEEN INVOLVED IN LEGAL ACTION” so once he realised he couldn’t raise money from the fines it would have generated, he lost interest in children’s safety around schools.

    Recently Sandwell Council defended a fine imposed on a young mum, Vanessa Miss Kelly, for dropping bread, claiming it attracts rats, her son was feeding the ducks when a warden issued her with a £75 fixed penalty ticket.

    “COUNCILLOR MAHBOOB HUSSAIN, THE COUNCIL’S NEIGHBOURHOOD BOSS DEFENDED THE DECISION TO PROSECUTE PEOPLE FEEDING DUCKS AND BIRDS, SAYING RESIDENTS HAD BEEN MADE AWARE OF THE COUNCIL’S STANCE” I have been there, there were no signs stipulating it was an offence to feed wildlife!!!!!!

    2 minutes walk away is Devonshire Road, now see this notice taken from the Councils own website, “AFTER SUFFERING FROM MONTHS OF PROBLEMS WITH BLACK BIN BAGS AND FRIDGES BEING DUMPED IN THEIR NEIGHBOURHOOD, PEOPLE LIVING IN DEVONSHIRE ROAD, SMETHWICK, ASKED THE COUNCIL FOR HELP”

    “RESIDENTS HAD BEEN CLEARING UP THE RUBBISH ON A REGULAR BASIS, BUT THE PROBLEM WAS STILL ATTRACTING RATS TO THE AREA”

    “COUNCILLOR MAHOOB HUSSAIN, SANDWELL COUNCIL’S CABINET MEMBER FOR NEIGHBOURHOODS AND HOUSING, SAID: “FLY-TIPPING COSTS THE COUNCIL AROUND £200,000 A YEAR AND IS SOMETHING WE TAKE VERY SERIOUSLY” so I think it’s obvious that this young mom was seen as an easy target for COUNCILLOR MAHOOB HUSSAIN, strange the wardens couldn’t issue fines on the people depositing “BLACK BIN BAGS AND FRIDGES” in the area, after all it was happening “ON A REGULAR BASIS”

    Sandwell Labour Council don’t see their job as supplying services to the community, they are just there to punish residents at every opportunity.

    Jim of Bearwood.

    Report abuse

  9. 9
    BROC LANDERS

    MR EDWARDS SHOULD HAVE BEEN GIVEN SPACE AT THE PUBLIC. HE COULD HAVE MADE AS MUCH NOISE AS HE WANTED BECAUSE NO ONE USES THE PLACE IN THE WEEK. AND ITS A PUB ON THE WEEK ENDS

    Report abuse

  10. 10
    Stjoe

    Jim-I have never really had any problems with the council. Had our houses done up outside through a sandwell grant system. We had a noise problem with a pub and they sorted that out for us. Granted that took a while to get the evidence, but they solved the problem in the end.

    It seems to me that this company bought on their own problems by not abiding by the noise regulations. Noise problems are no fun if you live next to these places-even if they do create jobs for people-try it sometime JIM….I have! I do agree about some of the stupid red tape like feeding the ducks!

    Report abuse

  11. 11
    JimG

    Stjoe, been there, got the tee shirt, I grew up in Cross Street, Smethwick, just off Rolf Street, right next door to Smethwick Drop Forgings, that wasn’t only horrendous banging it also made the whole house shake!!!!!!!

    The Fire Station was also a few feet away from the end of our road, but our family knew it was an industrialised area when they moved there, I guess your must have lived in that area for a few hundred years, because from memory that has been an industrialised area for a number of years now.

    Jim of Bearwood.

    Report abuse

  12. 12
    H.wednesburybaggie

    WORKED next to one of these sites for about 5yrs,noise,dust,vermin were a major problem.its alright having a moan at the council when its not your quality life and health thats being made to suffer!!

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

Business Awards

Read the full story here Read the full story here

Full coverage of awards celebrating the region's best businesses.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

LIVE traffic updates

Road, rail and airport - latest Road, rail and airport - latest

Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new E&S app Get the new E&S app

Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.