New light on Stafford Hospital scandal

Thursday 1st October 2009, 10:59AM BST.

martin yeatesA secret report obtained by the Express & Star has shed new light on the scandal at Stafford Hospital and the role of former hospital boss Martin Yeates.

Released under the Freedom of Information Act, the report into the conduct of former chief executive Mr Yeates blames him for a series of failures, errors and misjudgements during the time patient care was so bad.

But its release by Mid-Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust has also sparked anger after a number of key sections were removed, the trust claims, to protect personal information.

The document, written by former civil servant Peter Garland, paints the picture of a hospital whose management, in a bid to balance the books and hit targets, made major cuts in nursing staff without considering how this could affect patients.

This happened in an environment where senior bosses were not challenged and the board of directors were given misleading information. Against a backdrop of poor governance and bosses who failed to see the reality of the shocking death rates, the hospital’s standards continued to fall, according to the report.

Mr Yeates, who was formerly director of care services for Wolverhampton City Primary Care Trust, has never spoken publicly about what happened at the hospital after he “stepped aside” from his role just days before the damning Healthcare Commission report came out.

He was then suspended on full pay while the investigation by Mr Garland was carried out. He finally resigned before he could be disciplined, receiving £80,000 notice pay and a pension payout.

In his report, Mr Garland believed cuts in staffing in 2006 were not properly assessed for their impact.

He added: “This was a serious omission and meant the decisions made were based on incomplete information.

“The chief executive and board should have been aware nurse staffing levels were already low in many areas.”


  1. 2
    North Carolina Wolf

    “receiving £80,000 notice pay and a pension payout”. Hate to think how much he would have made if he had done a good job. Disgusting.

    Report abuse

  2. 3
    David Denny

    Don’t believe all you read in newspapers or reports. I was there at the time, gave evidence to the Inquiry, and it wasn’t this!

    Report abuse

  3. 4
    Seabass

    This man should be made to under go medical treatment at an NHS hospital. That would be a fitting punishment

    Report abuse

  4. 5
    Breeze

    Who ever believes this crock is as bad as the idiots who keep moaning and whinging about their relatives dying at the hospital.Sick to death of hearing about the hospital.They were old..all over 70..what do they expect everyone to live ofr ever..Change the tune..its boring.

    Report abuse

  5. 6
    Paul Hubball

    This comes as no surprise. The poor levels of hospital care in the region are well known and fully supported by mountains of evidence. I feel sorry for those all people who have to use the NHS hospital system. Don’t doctors have any say in what goes on or are they indifferent?

    Report abuse

  6. 7
    Jessica Jones

    - I think Stafford Hospital are getting there, although still a way to go! – But remember the same Trust runs Cannock, and thats a fairly nice place.

    Maybe all Chief Executives and even other high paid members of the Trust should only get a sensible sum and then receieve any more pay through Payment by Results (PbR).

    Report abuse

  7. 8
    Massif Backside

    I think that we should all be greatful that we don’t live in Holby City. It seems that at their hospital there is a scandal every half an hour or so, and lots of murderings and such. Of course, the real culpret is Gordon Brown, whom we can now safely say will not be Prime Minister for much longer. I shall certainly be voting for Mr Cameron, or perhaps Mr Clegg, whoever that is.

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

Business Awards

Read the full story here Read the full story here

Full coverage of awards celebrating the region's best businesses.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

LIVE traffic updates

Road, rail and airport - latest Road, rail and airport - latest

Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new E&S app Get the new E&S app

Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.