White bin bag blow
Tuesday 26th May 2009, 11:30AM BST.
Unpopular white recycling bags that have been blowing away from houses in Wolverhampton are here to stay for at least another year – after council chiefs admitted they could not afford to upgrade them.
Despite the bags infuriating residents by blowing away at the rate of 500 a month, they will remain in place until May 2010 because of the council’s cash crisis. The authority started the extra collection last October for plastics and cardboard recycling and introduced the bags.
It spent £90,000 on almost 100,000 bags after paying 96p for each one.
The Express & Star can reveal that it would cost the authority £330,000 extra to upgrade to boxes – but that bosses have opted to delay it.
The decision has upset critics, who say the council is trying to “do it on the cheap” and has rushed into starting the service.
The council is cutting £40 million from the budget over the next two years and axeing around 200 posts, and says there is no money in the pot for replacing the bags.
Tory councillor Barry Findlay, deputy leader and cabinet member for the environment, said: “Next year we need to replace some of our refuse collection vehicles, and when we do that we will look at making the service simpler.
“The bags cost 96p each, and to upgrade them to boxes would cost a third of a million pounds more. We just haven’t got the money in our budget to do that this year.
“We need to protect people’s money the best we can and when we started the service, we went for the most cost-effective bags.”
Some residents have said that the bags fall over and blow around in the wind, leaving rubbish strewn down the street. Between December and February there were 1,493 complaints.
Councillor Roger Lawrence, leader of the Labour group, said: “We were proposing to do a pilot of the service, which would have ironed out any problems before it was rolled out. The council has tried to do it on the cheap and this is the end result.”
Business Awards
Book a Business Awards table
Join our celebrations of the region's best in business on Thursday March 22 - book your table now
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
entertainment
All the film reviews
Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases
OUR NEW APP
Get the new E&S app
Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.
What do other councils do? Doesn’t Worcester City Council use plastic bin bags which are then recycled along with the items inside it? If not, the recycling amenities sites at Lanesfield and Bushbury recyle bags.
That way the bags could be tied up and the contents wouldn’t blow around.
Report abuse
Typical Tories – they know the cost of everything but the value of nothing. It is probably costing the Council thousands to keep replacing the bags as they get blown all over the city.
Report abuse
No idea, will ask the wife.
The bags are good, but I would prefer a box outside the front of the house rather than a bag I have to keep inside.
At least the Tories are trying to save us money unlike the labour idiots who got Wolverhampton council in the mess it is in.
Report abuse
Typical of Wolves Council really. Chester West & Cheshire Council are using a wheely bin for all the recycle – Plastic, paper, card, Tin & Glass. So why cant wolves copy that and make our lives simpler instead of having a green box, white bag, black bin & green bin.
Waste of money if you ask me.
Report abuse
If we put it in our own box, would they still empty it? I wouldn’t mind…
Report abuse
I’ve noticed that over the last couple of collections my bag has been stuffed securely into my glass and paper box, now if the binmen could just put the box back outside MY front door i’d be happy.
Report abuse
Your neighbours in Walsall a brown bin for garden waste, green bin for recycling (all of it, no bags, boxes, sorting, etc.) and a black bin for everything else!
Much as I hate to admit it, but it looks like, for once Walsall is doing it right from the residents point of view, even if it does cost them a little more!
Report abuse
I’m on my 4th bag already, they just seem to disappear, surely it would be more cost efficient for the council to upgrade to boxes now as I am sure it must be costing them a lot more replacing the 500 or so bags a month that are lost???
Report abuse
these bags are a stupid idea, why can’t we have a wheely bin like walsall council, not only do they blow away they smell aswell, and attract flies.
Report abuse
In reply to Andy – far from being a waste of money ours is a far better and cheaper scheme… as how do you think the different types of recycled material get seperated at the other end… by employed and paid staff…
And its easy enough to put the white bag under the green box when putting out and bringing in straight after its been emptied…
Report abuse
Those who lose their white bags should be charged a meaningful amount to replace – £5 a time or something like that?
Report abuse
Sue, since when have cardboard and plastic attracted flies???? Of course, you do wash your plastics out first don’t you?
Report abuse
Steve why should people be charged? I’ve already lost one bag through no fault of my own….and as for bringing the bag in straight after its been emptied…..some of us have to go to work…quite often enough i have seen other bags flying around the streets because the bin men arent always Courteous to put it in the green box.
However I agree with you on Sue’s comment…..I wash my empties out first, otherwise they will smell – especially if your putting smelly cartons of milk in there!!! yuk!
Report abuse