No work, no pay is answer to ‘sickies’

Tuesday 17th March 2009, 9:54AM GMT.

I recently read in your newspaper that a local official has bemoaned the unacceptable level of absenteeism by employees in the public sector, specifically those in local authority jobs.

These employees have a far higher rate of absenteeism compared to workers in the private sector. I believe, as do many others, that the main reason – and let’s be honest with ourselves about this – is it is all too easy for them to lose time from work without suffering financial loss.

The solution to this malaise, therefore, is both simple and obvious. It is to ensure that in order to obtain payment an employee has to work. In other words, if an employee is absent from work then he or she receives no payment for the time lost. Surely it would be an easy matter to issue each employee with a clock/swipe card which they would use to log in and out of work – a bit like many do in the private sector.

Look at it this way – would any of these absentees go to a store and pay for goods or services they do not receive? Of course not, but, in effect, that is exactly what taxpayers are forced to do. By what right should an employee expect payment in exchange for nothing?

Should a “no work equals no pay” policy be implemented, I believe “sickness” rates would fall, absenteeism would be greatly reduced and less cash would be seen flowing from local authority budgets in order to fund temporary replacements for those missing from work.

I can just imagine the inevitable howls of protest from those who, directly or indirectly, have a vested interested in keeping the status quo, but I cannot understand why public sector workers consider themselves immune from fair and reasonable practices such as “a day’s pay for a day’s work”.

I have had the privilege to work along many loyal, dedicated and conscientious public sector employees who have to carry the additional burden of the others in their midst. It is high time that the behaviour of those who exploit the system went unrewarded.

S Lamberton, Station Road, Aldridge.


  1. 1
    brian

    The public sector is just as bad as the private sector, and loss of pay makes no difference to some of these employees either. Some private companies i have worked for had their own sick pay scheme. That too was abused. The same people every year making sure they got their paid up sick leave as usual. No work = no pay never worked in the employment i spent many years. Every where you go you will always get the same people wagging it, and why should all the good workers loose out because of the same few??

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    milli

    I have worked in private and public sector since the age of 17 (now 44). I have been employed in local authority for 12 years and am a dedicated harding working full-time member of staff. Last year I was diagnosed with breast cancer and unfortunately had over 6 months off sick due to the cancer and a non-related current disability. I returned to work on a full time basis, taking cancer medication and attending hospital appointments for the cancer and disability. Due to the councils policy I’ve hbeen told I’ve had my ‘quota’ of sick (through no fault of my own -I’m sure no one wants cancer!) and if I go off sick am put on to half pay. In Feb I had a chest infection which due to finance worries took as leave and came back when I was still ill possibly passing on the infection to other staff which could cause more sickness and absences. We all know who the malingers are in our dept but as usual nothing is done and genuine cases are penalised time and time again – typical local authority policy!

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    Em Jay

    “Surely it would be an easy matter to issue each employee with a clock/swipe card which they would use to log in and out of work – a bit like many do in the private sector.”

    This shows how little you know about public sector workers…most of them already use such a system. I have for 12 years.

    While there are always a few who abuse the system (including in the private sector) you cannot penalise others as a result. This may shock you, but in my experience most people who claim SSP are genuinely ill.

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    mr/s

    LETS NOT FORGET THAT IF YOU PROVIDE A DOCTORS NOTE
    THEN IT IS HE /SHE IN THERE PROFSIONAL DECISION SAY YOU NEED THE TIME OFF WORK .DONT FEEL GUILTY ABOUT BEING SICK.
    REMEMBER AT LEAST YOU ARE WORKING AND NOT SCROUNGING.

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

Business Awards

Read the full story here Read the full story here

Full coverage of awards celebrating the region's best businesses.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

LIVE traffic updates

Road, rail and airport - latest Road, rail and airport - latest

Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new E&S app Get the new E&S app

Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.