Mayors run up £215k on car expenses

Wednesday 11th March 2009, 11:30AM GMT.

Mayor of Dudley's CarMore than £215,000 has been spent on cars to take Midlands mayors and deputy mayors to civic events and meetings, it has been revealed.

Dudley Council forked out the most, spending £84,969.57 in 2007/08. The second highest was Walsall Council, which spent £49,261.06, closely followed by Wolverhampton City Council at £45,223. Stafford Borough Council paid £32,300 while the bill for Kidderminster Charter Trustees was just £5,000.

Lichfield City Council spends nothing on chauffeuring the mayor as he drives himself to events in his own car.

The figure for Dudley borough includes the salary of two full-time driving attendants at £63,140, £1,492 for petrol and diesel and £347.57 on cleaning. In addition, it spent £19,990 on leasing two cars.

In Wolverhampton, two drivers, who undertake cleaning duties as part of their role, earned £40,835 between them.

The cost of maintaining the mayoral car, which is owned by the council, was £1,488 and fuel costs were £2,900.

Walsall Council owns the mayoral car and has a chauffeur. No breakdown of the costs incurred was available.

In Stafford, the car is leased by the council and the cost includes salary, petrol and maintenance.

In Kidderminster, the Charter Trustees paid £3,100 on a rental contract for a Ford Mondeo and £1,900 on the vehicle’s diesel and servicing. The Mayor does not have a chauffeur.

No Sandwell figures were out.


  1. 1
    Pete

    Bargain!

    Worth ever penny.

    Any particular reason they could use public transport though?

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    ZeElk

    I think thats money well spent.

    After all, when in one’s robes one needs two full time drivers and a Jaguar to get around. Personally, I wouldn’t travel any other way. I’d feel perfectly comfortable being the most public member of any Council thats cutting costs left, right and centre knowing that my travelling arrangements are paid for by 80 residents Council Tax bills or the salary of 10 cleaners / 4 bin men / 5 receptionists / 4 life guards, etc.

    The only one with any sense is Kiddy… home of the Mondeo Mayor!!!

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    Val Evans fan club

    What ever happened to Civic Pride?

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    pete Smith

    Put them on the bus!

    Another abuse of the Freedom of Information Act by the British press.

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    PimpMyTown

    I wonder why sandwell figures were not out then? Hmm might have something to do with the St georges parade and the Public ..They dont want to cause a disturbance amongunst the ones who vote them in?

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    Paul

    Appalling with Dudley MBC putting up council tax by nearly 5% because they’re in dire financial straits (again) its even more disgusting. Bet that won’t be on Dudley MBCs “all good news” website.
    £90000 for the Mayor to run about in a limo, whilst they’re proposing to close the wordl famous Broadfield House museum because they can’t afford £120,000 to keep it open. I know where they can find three quarters of the amount right away…

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    Jo

    No Sandwell figures were out….that figures..LOL!

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    oldbury lad

    i agree with 5 and 7.one year a mayor in SANDWELL used their mayoral car to go shopping in with their wife and kids

    Report abuse

  9. 9
    Carter Magna

    Those chains are heavy… Home James.

    Report abuse

  10. 10
    Yvonne

    What a disgracec that these local authorities are allowed to lavish our money on such luxury what basic services are at risk because of shortage of funds? Are we shocked ….. Just the same as all those mp’s claiming for everything they spend a ligitimate expenses. Again the average working man trying to make ends meet picking up the tabs…………

    Report abuse

  11. 11
    Pulus

    They should all practice what they preach… CAR SHARE!!! A couple of Mondeo Ghia’s or, that new posh Vauxhall Insignia should do the trick. All bookable on a ‘priority’ accross the region.

    Personally, I wouldn’t have a problem with the occasional hire of a limo for Stag/hen nights -oops I mean Royal visits (lol). But for everything else then a pool car/driver should be more than adequate and save much needed PUBLIC funds!!!

    Report abuse

  12. 12
    Carole

    Does make one wonder why no Sandwell figures out YET, RED FACES me thinks……. what’s the matter with a bus………….
    Oh how the mighty will fall when they do come out, (If they ever do) come on people of Sandwell demand them………

    Report abuse

  13. 13
    Change the record

    It’s interesting how the only time the Express & Star opens up the ‘Have Your Say’ facility nowadays is when it’s a story knocking local councils – which invariably draws out of the woodwork all the usual experts who now everything there is to know about what mayors get up to, for example.

    Incidentally Pete, fancy taking your wife out on the bus when you’re both wearing £300,000 of irreplaceable gold and jewellery around your necks?

    Report abuse

  14. 14
    News to me?

    Paul – are Dudley Council really ‘closing’ Broadfield House? I thought the council was looking into building a new purpose-built glass museum in the Glass Quarter proper that will enable far more of the Borough’s glass collection to be out on display than the meagre 20% that is on display at Broadfield House (which is actually a converted old folks’ home!).

    Report abuse

  15. 15
    brian

    Why does everyone including the media keep harping on about councils? I dont hear anyone moaning about the cost of our Royal family’s transport, or even our primeministers. They have a job to to so for god sake leave them all alone!!! I am not in favour of wasting money like on the public, but transport costs can be part of any job.

    Report abuse

  16. 16
    Past mayor

    In defence of mayors’ attendants, it is doing them a disservice to dub them ‘chauffeurs’. Driving is just a small part of what they actually do.

    Although their principal function is to take care of the chains of office (attendants like to joke that the Council can always elect another mayor, but the chains are literally irreplaceable!), they also dress the Mayor to ensure those chains are worn correctly, they are an invaluable source of advice to the Mayor about civic protocol (as well as intelligence about the people he or she is likely to have to greet), they plan and research each engagement meticulously to ensure practicalities such as timekeeping are taken care of, they act as master of ceremonies at important events, and they regularly give talks to schools and community groups about the history of the Borough and its civic insignia.

    And when all that is done, they will often find themselves being roped in to act as barman, waiter, photographer, cloakroom attendant, parcel courier, you-name-it-they-do-it. As such it is nothing unusual for an attendant to be out with the Mayor from dawn till dusk, criss-crossing the Borough from one end to the other in up to four or five engagements in one day.

    Report abuse

  17. 17
    besty

    WE’RE BEING RIPPED APART BY EVERY COUNCIL DEPARTMENT,WHY COULD’NT THE OUT DATED MAYORS GET A TAXI OR JUST A NORMAL MOTOR TO FERRY THEM TO ALL THESE VERY NEEDED JOBS?,WHAT EVER JOBS THAT IS,TOTAL WASTE OF OUR HARD EARNED TAXSES AGAIN,TELL US SOMETHING WE DON’T KNOW.

    Report abuse

  18. 18
    Pete

    Change the record says

    Incidentally Pete, fancy taking your wife out on the bus when you’re both wearing £300,000 of irreplaceable gold and jewellery around your necks?

    My answer is I do not use public transport EXACTLY because it is unsafe, unreliable and totally indequate.

    Then again it is not MY job to get this sorted is it? I wonder whose it is?

    Report abuse

  19. 19
    Paul Hickman

    Can the people defending these mayors expenses for example (past mayor) explain the huge differance in costs between say dudley and wolves
    coucils is it perhaps the dudley mayor works twice as fast and attends twice as many functions?

    Report abuse

  20. 20
    Past mayor

    Besty…

    Some mayors in smaller local authorities (where the mayoral workload is consequently far lighter) do use taxies to ferry their mayors to engagements. However, the taxi drivers often end up following the limousines of the bigger authorities because at least their chauffeurs know where they’re going and what they’re supposed to be doing (no offence to local taxi drivers, but greeting visiting royalty demands rather different qualities to shuttling clubbers about on a Saturday night).

    Furthermore, I remember once being taken to present prizes at a primary school whilst the Mayoral limo was in for repairs and none of the local hire companies had any equivalent-sized cars available. Had you been there to observe the look of disappointment on the children’s faces when I stepped out of a Vauxhall Astra hatchback it would have answered the other part of your question.

    Report abuse

  21. 21
    Change the record

    Paul Hickman – I suspect the variations are explained by the differing ways the costings are allocated. For instance, does Dudley include the costs of their attendants’ employers’ national insurance contributions under the mayoral budget heading, whereas in Wolverhampton they are included under a separate budget heading?

    This is why Freedom of Information requests often make for poor comparisons: one authority’s mayoral attendant on the mayoral budget (who just happens to deliver mail as well) is another authority’s mail courier on the administration budget (who just happens to drive the Mayor around).

    Report abuse

  22. 22
    BOSTER

    So that is why they need to stop us using the free car parks on a Saturday, to raise an extra £100,000

    Report abuse

  23. 23
    Mat

    So Past Mayor, on point 16. Just over £30,000 for being an odd job man. I’d have a bit of that cake, the usual going rate is minimum wage!!!

    Report abuse

  24. 24
    EAGLEEYE

    DO WE REALLY NEED THESE PARASITES. I MEAN WHAT FUNCTION DO THEY REALY UNDERTAKE OTHER THAN SPONGING FROM THE PUBLIC PURSE

    GET RID OF THEM NOW AND SPEND THE MONEY ON SOMETHING USEFUL

    Report abuse

  25. 25
    Paul

    Thanks for your comment News to Me:
    I never said Dudley Council were closing Broadfield House, but they were PROPOSING TO CLOSE it, though given Dudleys record its probably a 99.9% cert! I’m unaware of any plans to build a new purpose built glass musuem, where would this be? My understanding from the local press & Dudley MBC’s own website is that they intend to move the collection onto Red House Cone site, which whilst a fantastic musuem in its own right isn’t really able to house two museums on one small site. All the experts seem to agree its a bad idea…….
    Just had my council tax bill through which tells me council tax is only rising by 87p….when the actual rise is £3! Bit sneaky quoting a weekly figure for the increase when you bill people monthly!
    Why do we need a mayor anyway, if people want to attend civic functions, scoff prawn vol-a-vents and sparkling wine I’ve no objection, provided they pay for it themselves. Why should we council taxpayers pay for other people to have a good night out on out taxes.
    On the other hand given the potholes in virtually every road in Dudley Borough perhaps the £90000 is paying for a Hummer to get the Mayor through in one piece!

    Report abuse

  26. 26
    Past mayor

    I can assure you that the vast majority of the engagements that mayors attend are at the specific invitation of community organisations like scouts, guides, amateur dramatic societies, disability support groups, fund-raising charities, and so on, who recognise the historic importance of the office of mayor and who want the mayor and mayoress to be present to add lustre to the proceedings or to confer the approbation of the Borough upon all the amazing things they have achieved.

    It might sound nice being taken from place to place in a big Jaguar, but being mayor and doing the job properly can be very hard work – more so for the poor old mayoress, who is invariably not accustomed to the public spotlight and so can often find it even harder to keep on smiling or making small talk when she’s already on your third engagement that day and has also been in work that morning too (let’s not forget that many mayors and mayoresses also have day jobs around which their duties have to be fitted). Besides, when you’re attending up to four hundred engagements in a year I can assure you quickly tire of ‘scoffing vol-au-vents’.

    However, I personally received the greatest thrill from the encouragement ordinary people took from knowing that the Borough – as symbolised by my big badge of office – had recognised their endeavours. That is the real reason I enjoyed so much being mayor – the cars, the occasional dinners and the other trappings of office being of no import when set against the sheer joy your presence brings to the lives of others.

    So if any of you have a spare five nights, three afternoons and two morning free each week I’m sure your mayors would make you most welcome to join them in opening summer fetes, visiting residents in care homes, presenting school prizes and welcoming important visitors to the town. Then I am confident you would go away appreciating that the office of mayor is worth every penny that is spent on it.

    Report abuse

  27. 27
    BOSTER

    Let me ask you a simple question Mr Past Mayor; Dudley Council is closing its free car parks on a Saturday to make an extra £100,000; the council also spends £90,000 a year on the mayoral car. What do you think the average taxpayer in Dudley would rather have – free car parking, or a mayoral car.
    Incidentally, councils and council staff will still be able to use the free car parks. Nice to know that public servants are not being given any special privileges, isn’t it?

    Report abuse

  28. 28
    Bizzy

    Boster… Let’s melt down all Dudley’s various mayoral chains and sell them for the half a million pounds or more they must be worth. Then you can have free parking for the rest of the week too… well, for a year at least.
    However, an important piece of your town’s heritage and history will meanwhile have gone forever.

    Incidentally, the ‘free’ car park you refer to actually belongs to the Council House for use during the week by the staff who work there, as well as for visitors to the building. It has only ever been opened up to the public on Saturdays as a goodwill gesture – kind of like you letting me park my car on your drive while you’re at work.

    Report abuse

  29. 29
    Past mayor

    In answer to Bosty, one or two councils have abolished the office of mayor as a cost-saving measure (such as Hayle and Liverpool) – only to reinstate them a few years later in response to popular demand.

    Report abuse

  30. 30
    Mat

    Past Mayor. You really need to get into the real world. The councils keep spending our well earned money and then keep telling us to pay an extra 5% ish each year. I get a 0% pay rise each year and last year because of a council error it cost me £200 which they refused to repay. Just tell me where the money is supposed to come from and when we will get what we want, not what is dictated to us? Free country, democracy, the joke is at our expense.

    Report abuse

  31. 31
    Past mayor

    Mat – I refer you to Comment 29. In actual fact, I was wrong: Liverpool didn’t abolish the office of Lord Mayor as a cost-saving measure, but rather the ruling Militant Tendency did so out of narrow ideological spite.

    However, in 1991 the people of Liverpool got what they wanted and voted for the office of Lord Mayor to be reinstated.

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

Business Awards

Read the full story here Read the full story here

Full coverage of awards celebrating the region's best businesses.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Express & Star and Shropshire Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

LIVE traffic updates

Road, rail and airport - latest Road, rail and airport - latest

Our new, live traffic and travel updates service - check before you set out.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new E&S app Get the new E&S app

Download the Express & Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.